Melody's profile

Melody's reviews

  4.9  
Melody has 57 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Melody's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, patient, friendly, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Efficient
over 1 year ago
Efficient

She was always on it! Always made sure we understood every step. Very flexible when we were looking at houses. Comforting vibe from her. She is genuinely excited for her clients and such a kind person.

Buyer review
PHENOMENAL!
over 1 year ago
PHENOMENAL!

Melody is so professional and personable at the same time! She’s so efficient and super knowledgeable on all aspects of the market!

Buyer review
smooth process
over 1 year ago
smooth process

Melody displayed a great deal of knowledge regarding the area and home buying market. Quick to respond to questions. Her communication throughout was professional and essential for my understanding of the process. Thank you so much for your patience and understanding.

Seller review
Highly knowledgeable, professional and excellent communication.
over 1 year ago
Highly knowledgeable, professional and excellent communication.

The sale of my house was something I had never done before. After my husband's passing I decided to sale the house immediately, however, it took me four years to do so simply because I had never sold a house before and simply did not know how or where to start. After speaking without friends Melody Caraballo's was referred to me. After meeting with her I was impressed by her information and how comfortable i was with her information. I hired her without hesitations and she took me by the hand, step by step until the job was completed within close to just two months. After all the process of selling the house was completed... it was sold within two days after it was posted on the market. Needless to say, I was elated. All closing was completed by the closing date and payment was done with in the following week. the house went up for sale on a Friday and the house was sold that Sunday! Needless to say I was elated!

Buyer review
She doesn’t miss a beat !!!
over 1 year ago
She doesn’t miss a beat !!!

We’ve worked w/ this hidden gem for the past two years looking to downsize from a 2,202 sq ft, 3-floor, 4 bedroom, 2 bath house on the Eastside to a 1-floor, 2 bedroom, 2 bath condo on the Westside (preparing for retirement and old age) … It’s a crazy market at the moment and Melody is certainly not afraid of crazy !!! KNOWLEDGEABLE - She knows tips and tricks that aren’t easily found online or on a phone app TRUSTWORTHY - She’s honest, responds to requests in a timely manner, and communicates openly ENGAGING - She has a great attitude, is confident in her abilities and truly interested in helping clients RESOURCEFUL - She has the tools, resources and commitment to provide pertinent data, explain “the process” in layman’s terms, act as the facilitator between buyer and seller, and she can evaluate the need for and provide a list of experts (when needed) … Thank you Bubba Jr for all your help the past two years. Your hard work helped us find our dream condo, and we couldn’t be more grateful or excited about this milestone !!!

Buyer review
Recommended
over 1 year ago
Recommended

Melody was very helpful in assisting us finding our new home. She was especially helpful and available when we approached closing. She was also very knowledgeable concerning the whole home buying process from initial viewings through to closing. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a new home.

Buyer review
Melody was FANTASTIC
almost 2 years ago
Melody was FANTASTIC

Melody was very thoughtful with her picks for houses and was able to find houses that closely met my criteria. She gave helpful info and suggestions as well as providing knowledge on topics I was unfamiliar with. She brought notable points of interest to my attention (like things that could be future money sinks) so that I was aware. She was also very friendly and personable. Since this was my first home buying experience, I did not know and lenders etc. Melody has great connections that will take care of you well, and are willing to educate you as you go through the process of buying your home. Melody made the home buying experience enjoyable and easy. Don’t hesitate to have Melody guide you through your next home-buying experience!

Buyer review
From cat-urine carpets to posh Polish brick house!
almost 2 years ago
From cat-urine carpets to posh Polish brick house!

We started our long journey of house hunting by simply typing in "highest rated realtor in cleveland ohio", and ratemyagent did not disappoint. We were so lucky to have found Melody. From the get go she was quick to respond, and offered step by step simple instruction for the entire process of searching and purchasing a home. She was always patient, kind, and understanding - even with me being super meticulous with needing to comprehend the entire process as a first time home buyer. Her expertise and insight of the structural components of houses was also spot on for many of the houses we toured; where she would point out dips in the foundation/ceilings, or items that clearly needed to be tuck pointed, etc. She was always willing to work with us and our schedules to tour as many houses as we could. She gave us the resources/contacts we needed to succeed. We saw some crazy and funny things - great houses and smelly houses - and throughout this highly stressful process, we still had a wonderful time because of her. And when we finally did choose a house, she offered sagely and sound advice to help us secure the win. If I had to do this all again, I would choose Melody in a heartbeat.

Buyer review
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
almost 2 years ago
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Melody was amazing through the entire process of buying our first home. We had an extremely tight timeline of 6 weeks to find a house we loved and to get it closed and Melody worked late nights and weekends to get this done for us! She is extremely knowledgeable and goes that extra mile to make sure youre taken care of, and is honest about the houses that she shows you! We toured 6 houses on a SATURDAY and she helped us pick the perfect home for us! I cannot say enough good things about Melody and would 10000% recommend her if youre looking to buy a house !:)

Buyer review
The Best Realtor in Cuyahoga County!
almost 2 years ago
The Best Realtor in Cuyahoga County!

Melody is awesome and I thank God that I found her when I did. Before meeting her, I'd spent the the entire winter and nearly all Spring house hunting all over town with 3 other realtors with zero success. I contacted Melody on a Friday, told her what I wanted and Melody found me the house that I always wanted on her very 1st attempt that same Friday! Melody helped me close a deal on my house in less than 48 hours. I Love her! If I could give her 10 stars, I would ! She was very knowledgeable about both of the properties that she showed me. I highly recommend her to anyone.

Buyer review
Melody was so knowledgeable about the entire process of buying a house!
almost 2 years ago
Melody was so knowledgeable about the entire process of buying a house!

Melody was so knowledgeable about the entire process of buying a house! We were on a super tight time crunch so, within a few days of telling her our situation, she spent her whole Saturday showing us 6 houses. She then worked late into Saturday night to put together our offer letter and had the seller accepting our offer by the next morning! I truly believe Melody will get her clients the best possible outcome for their given situations!

Buyer review
Personable
almost 2 years ago
Personable

She was personable and always available

13 - 24 of 57
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent