Kyle's profile

Kyle's reviews

  5  
Kyle has 137 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kyle's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, resourceful, patient, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The Best Guide Through Buying and Selling
about 1 year ago
The Best Guide Through Buying and Selling

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Kyle not once, but twice! First when he helped us purchase our home 5 years ago, and again recently when it came time to sell. On both sides of the process, he was nothing short of exceptional. His communication and response time are truly unparalleled. No question ever went unanswered, and he made us feel supported every step of the way. His knowledge of the home buying and selling process is superb, and his extensive network of contacts and resources made everything so much smoother than we could have imagined. What continuously stands out about Kyle is his calm, steady, and encouraging demeanor. Buying and selling a home can be stressful and overwhelming, but he has a way of guiding you through it with confidence and ease. We always felt like we were in the best hands possible. If you’re looking for someone who combines expertise, professionalism, and genuine care for his clients, Kyle is THE ONE. We cannot recommend him highly enough!

Seller review
 Exceptional Realtor Who Made Selling a Breeze
about 1 year ago
Exceptional Realtor Who Made Selling a Breeze

I can’t speak highly enough of Kyle and the outstanding service he provided throughout the process of selling my home. He took the time to understand the unique features of my property and crafted a smart pricing and marketing strategy that generated significant interest. Thanks to his efforts, we received multiple strong offers and closed above asking and faster than I ever expected. Kyle handled every detail with care and confidence, from staging advice and high-quality listing photos to negotiations and closing logistics. Communication was seamless, timely, and honest which was something I greatly appreciated during such a significant transition. If you’re looking for a realtor who’s knowledgeable, responsive, and truly dedicated I think Kyle is the perfect choice!

Seller review
Best of the best!
about 1 year ago
Best of the best!

Working with Kyle was such a pleasure. I contacted him to assist me in selling my St Pete home in flood zone A post hurricanes Helene and Milton. Even though the house was spared, I knew selling it would be a challenge. He came to my home and made suggestions for small spruces prior to listing. He also spent time researching comps to establish the value of my home and give me an idea of what my payout would look like- which ultimately was exactly in line with what he initially anticipated. Kyle went above and beyond to make a video of the neighborhood and tour of the house to help gain interest. His communication was excellent throughout the entire process. He never pressured me to lower the price and made valuable recommendations that only come with a lot of experience. Overall, you just know he’s a great person who has your best interests at heart. I’m excited to work with him again in the future!

Buyer review
The best Realtor in Florida
about 1 year ago
The best Realtor in Florida

This is not an exaggeration. Kyle was outstanding in his communication skills, follow through, attention to detail and in going anbov and beyond of what I was expecting from a Realtor. I am a fellow Realtor in another state so I know what is involved in any call transaction and Kyle exceeded all my expectations. He is an excellent angent and I would not hesitate to recommend him to anybody. He is honest, reliable and personable.

Seller review
Thorough Professionalism
about 1 year ago
Thorough Professionalism

Kyle was attentive to presenting my much beloved bungalow in the best possible light. He respected my privacy as the owner. He attained a favorable price despite challenges of grandfather oaks. Said oaks are protected thus it took a special buyer to accept terms. I am grateful for the time, energy and expertise that he brought to the representation and successful sale of my property.

Seller review
Kyle was great at selling our place!
over 1 year ago
Kyle was great at selling our place!

I fully recommend Kyle as an agent. He was referred to us and I’m glad that we chose him to represent us. Kyle was great to deal with from the first meeting through the closing. He was always positive and professional. He had great ideas on how to present the home and was always quick to respond to anything I had questions about. He was well versed on how to price our place and we landed very very close to that price in the end. Great agent and a great guy.

Seller review
Realtor who is a Pro!
over 1 year ago
Realtor who is a Pro!

Kyle Hickey is a pro. My company has bought numerous properties both commercial and residential. Mr. Hickey along with being pleasant is attentive to detail and made a transaction that had a few hurdles successfully close. He clearly went the extra mile for me. Kyle also found a property for a business partner of mine and closed that deal in record time. Sign with Kyle as your agent, you will be more than satisfied. Jim Gilleran President JMD Development Inc.

Buyer review
Kyle is the absolute best!!
over 1 year ago
Kyle is the absolute best!!

We’ve worked with Kyle for almost three years in search of the perfect home, and we truly couldn’t have done it without him. His expertise, patience, and deep knowledge of all things related to homeownership were invaluable. Kyle genuinely cared about helping us find the right home for our growing family, and he always kept us informed with clear, timely communication. We’re so grateful for everything he’s done—highly recommend him!!! He also sold our old house in record time!! The average house on the market during this time is 75 days and we were under contract in 15 days. It was WONDERFUL!! He is the best!

Buyer review
Cannot give enough stars
over 1 year ago
Cannot give enough stars

Kyle was instrumental in making this whole process as close to stress free as buying a house can be. We were expecting so much more stress and we had such an amazing group of people helping us and Kyle led the way. And most importantly, Kyle is just a great human. We love working with people who we would also want to be friends with and Kyle is the embodiment of that.

Seller review
Knowledgeable, Caring and Willing to go above and beyond
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable, Caring and Willing to go above and beyond

Kyle is great. He knows more about the process and market more than anyone I have ever worked with. As a father himself he understands how to work with families and gives his input on pros and cons of each property. He is the opposite of pushy. He understands the goal is to find everyone the perfect home for them and not just shove them in a home that may not be perfect for them. If I ever have the need for a real estate agent in the future or if anyone asks for a recommendation, Kyle will be my only answer.

Buyer review
You can't find a better realtor, person, or team anywhere else!
over 1 year ago
You can't find a better realtor, person, or team anywhere else!

Kyle was absolutely amazing! He was so patient and not pushy. He truly listened to everything we wanted and was a fast communicator. When it came time to close kyle and his team got everything done from offer to keys in 16 days! Every single person on his team from the inspector, to mortgage broker, to closer were all phenomenal and I couldn't have pictured a smoother process! Thank you so much!

Seller review
Kyle is the BEST!
over 1 year ago
Kyle is the BEST!

Kyle is awesome to work with. He is on top of everything and is always quick to answer any questions with superior knowledge and expertise! I would highly recommend him to anyone that is buying or selling a home.

25 - 36 of 137
© 2026 RateMyAgent