Kyle's profile

Kyle's reviews

  5  
Kyle has 134 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kyle's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, resourceful, patient, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Professional and friendly.
10 days ago
Professional and friendly.

Kyle was enjoyable to work with. Great communication. I felt that Kyle was easy to work with very personable and 100% committed to selling my property. He had good ideas of how to accomplish the task at hand. I’ve worked with him before and will again if the real estate need arises.

Buyer review
The perfect realtor for a first time homebuyer!!
17 days ago
The perfect realtor for a first time homebuyer!!

I can’t say enough good things about Kyle Hickey! As a first-time homebuyer, I was nervous and overwhelmed, but Kyle made the entire process so much easier. He was patient, knowledgeable, always available for my questions, and genuinely cared about helping me every step of the way. I always felt like he had my best interests at heart and was truly in my corner. I’m so grateful for everything he did to help me purchase my first home. I highly recommend Kyle to anyone looking for a realtor who truly goes above and beyond!

Seller review
Excellent experience and would highly recommend!
27 days ago
Excellent experience and would highly recommend!

I truly couldn’t have asked for a better realtor or a smoother experience selling my home. I have worked with Kyle in the past and would recommend him to anyone! He’s extremely knowledgable and experienced and provides very sound advice that always feels genuine and sincere. He’s always one step ahead of what’s needed and highly responsive. He kept me informed without overwhelming me, handled every detail, answered all of my questions, and made sure I felt confident in every decision along the way. He certainly has a way of making the most stressful situations feel effortless. Everything from listing to showings, negotiations, inspections, and closing went so smoothly, and I always felt like I had someone in my corner who genuinely knew what he was doing. He is truly exceptional at what he does — professional, trustworthy, hardworking, and extremely knowledgeable about the entire process. Having someone you can trust is invaluable when you’re making a decision this big, and I couldn’t have been in better hands!

Seller review
Couldn’t ask for a better realtor!
about 2 months ago
Couldn’t ask for a better realtor!

We were recommended Kyle by a friend and we are so thankful! We were very anxious leading up to the listing of our house thinking about how stressful the process could be. Kyle made everything so easy and streamlined from start to finish. He is attentive, an excellent communicator, and truly knows how to get the job done. Thank you again Kyle for helping us sell our home and purchasing our dream home!

Buyer review
Excellence in ALL aspects of the transaction!
3 months ago
Excellence in ALL aspects of the transaction!

Kyle and team are keenly aware of all details needed to closing the deal. They are quick to follow through and tract all outstanding tasks. Kyle and his team take the initiative and work to ensure the buyer is informed at all times. I had an Outstanding experience leveraging Kyle and his team for this transaction.

Seller review
Outstanding and professional
3 months ago
Outstanding and professional

Kyle was great with communication and was very attentive to listening to my concerns and multiple questions and was a breeze to work with. And I will be using him in the future and also referring to any family members or friends with no hesitation.

Seller review
Aggressive, knowledgeable and excellent market knowledge!
5 months ago
Aggressive, knowledgeable and excellent market knowledge!

Kyle was on top of the listing with professional photos and a very address specific advertising plan that was right on the mark!! This is the second Kyle has sold for me and I appreciate his professionalism!

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
6 months ago
Excellent Realtor

If you want a realtor who will go above and beyond for you, look no further. Kyle demonstrated market knowledge, excellent communication skills, and made us feel at easy throughout the entire process. He answered all of our questions and always provided the knowledge to ensure we knew what was coming next. He made our cross country move, a smooth transition. We can't thank you enough Kyle!

Seller review
Kyle is an 11/10.
6 months ago
Kyle is an 11/10.

Kyle Hickey was exactly who you want on your team when you're selling your house. Kyle knows the St. Pete market and had a clear strategy from the jump on how to position our home to get the best outcome. He had solid advice on pricing, timing, and presentation. Kyle's communication is 10/10. He kept things moving, kept us in the loop, and talked me off a ledge more than once (and probably more times that I should publicly admit). Selling a house can be a pain, but Kyle made the process a lot more pleasant, and a lot easier. He genuinely cares about getting a great result for his clients and getting the deal done. Kyle went above and beyond to make sure our sale went through and that meant a lot to my husband and I. I would absolutely use Kyle again and absolutely recommend Kyle again.

Buyer review
You will never regret hiring Kyle
7 months ago
You will never regret hiring Kyle

I would highly recommend Kyle. After a couple of less than ideal experiences with FL agents and real estate transactions, I found Kyle after doing my own online search of reviews and other info. I sent him an email and got a call back minutes later. It was clear why Kyle has so many great reviews. He listens, is extremely knowledgeable (like down to every square inch of st Pete) and responsive. All great qualities in an agent. Being new to the area I relied on Kyle to help me nail down where to buy and what watch out for. I couldn’t have been more impressed by all he knew and how he quickly understood what I was looking for better than I could articulate. Kyle also knows all the good local agents which helps. We found a great home at a good price in old northeast and I just moved in. Couldn’t be more pleased with the purchase or choice of agent who is like an old friend at this point. He was super responsive day and night and talked me off the ledge a few times when negotiations were difficult. In short, I couldn’t recommend Kyle more highly.

Seller review
Great Agent
7 months ago
Great Agent

Great agent, communicated with us very promptly, knowledgeable about the current market. Would recommend!

1 - 12 of 134
© 2026 RateMyAgent