Kyle's profile

Kyle's reviews

  5  
Kyle has 137 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kyle's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, resourceful, patient, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Kyle is an 11/10.
7 months ago
Kyle is an 11/10.

Kyle Hickey was exactly who you want on your team when you're selling your house. Kyle knows the St. Pete market and had a clear strategy from the jump on how to position our home to get the best outcome. He had solid advice on pricing, timing, and presentation. Kyle's communication is 10/10. He kept things moving, kept us in the loop, and talked me off a ledge more than once (and probably more times that I should publicly admit). Selling a house can be a pain, but Kyle made the process a lot more pleasant, and a lot easier. He genuinely cares about getting a great result for his clients and getting the deal done. Kyle went above and beyond to make sure our sale went through and that meant a lot to my husband and I. I would absolutely use Kyle again and absolutely recommend Kyle again.

Buyer review
You will never regret hiring Kyle
8 months ago
You will never regret hiring Kyle

I would highly recommend Kyle. After a couple of less than ideal experiences with FL agents and real estate transactions, I found Kyle after doing my own online search of reviews and other info. I sent him an email and got a call back minutes later. It was clear why Kyle has so many great reviews. He listens, is extremely knowledgeable (like down to every square inch of st Pete) and responsive. All great qualities in an agent. Being new to the area I relied on Kyle to help me nail down where to buy and what watch out for. I couldn’t have been more impressed by all he knew and how he quickly understood what I was looking for better than I could articulate. Kyle also knows all the good local agents which helps. We found a great home at a good price in old northeast and I just moved in. Couldn’t be more pleased with the purchase or choice of agent who is like an old friend at this point. He was super responsive day and night and talked me off the ledge a few times when negotiations were difficult. In short, I couldn’t recommend Kyle more highly.

Seller review
Great Agent
8 months ago
Great Agent

Great agent, communicated with us very promptly, knowledgeable about the current market. Would recommend!

Seller review
Trusted Expertise & Exceptional Service
9 months ago
Trusted Expertise & Exceptional Service

I can’t say enough great things about working with Kyle and his team. From start to finish, I was incredibly impressed with the level of service I received. Even though I know I’m not his only client, he made me feel like I was a priority every step of the way. The experience felt truly personalized, and he took the time to thoroughly educate me throughout the entire selling process so I always felt informed and confident in my decisions. I’ve known Kyle for over a decade and have had the privilege of watching him grow in his career, and it’s been amazing to see the professionalism, dedication, and expertise he brings to his clients. He genuinely cares and it shows in how he communicates, advocates, and delivers results. I would highly recommend Kyle and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. You’ll be in excellent hands.

Buyer review
Move to St Pete
9 months ago
Move to St Pete

Highly recommend Kyle to anyone looking at buying in the St Pete area. As people coming from out of state Kyle was very communicative, flexible and helped us through the process. He sent photos of the building often which we loved! 10/10

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and communicative
10 months ago
Knowledgeable and communicative

From the first time I met Kyle while touring a home I was impressed by his knowledge of things he pointed out that are important to an investment but not something I know much about (replaced pipes, age of repairs, windows, etc). He has great practical knowledge, which he shared freely. He also knows the St Pete market well and had good advice on areas and trends. Throughout the offer and closing process, he was always very responsive and communicative. The selling agent even complimented him on how well he stayed in contact. I’d recommend him to anyone buying a home and especially to those needing advice on those hidden elements of each home!

Buyer review
Awesome Experience
10 months ago
Awesome Experience

Couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. Kyle made the whole process easy, gave us great insight into the market, and he was always available when we had questions. His guidance and negotiating helped us land a great home. Super easy to work with and highly recommend.

Buyer review
Kyle is the best!
12 months ago
Kyle is the best!

Hands down the best realtor! Kyle makes the home buying process easy and stress free. Kyle is knowledgeable and will go above and beyond to make sure everything goes smoothly. He is a great communicator and listener. Just one example of Kyle’s dedication to look out for us, Kyle made sure to add a contingency in our contract that an old permit needed to be closed out before our closing. Because of this, we had a new HVAC system installed the day before we moved in. Highly recommend him!

Seller review
Kyle is the Best Agent in St Pete
12 months ago
Kyle is the Best Agent in St Pete

I would recommend Kyle to everyone buying a home. Not only is he a good authentic person but he’s also excellent with real estate. He helped us through the entire process and made everything easy. He will be our Agent for life!

Seller review
Kyle is the best!
12 months ago
Kyle is the best!

Responsive, knowledgeable, trustworthy, and gets the deal done. Kyle knows the local market like the back of his hand and works tirelessly to connect buyers and sellers. Can’t recommend him enough.

Seller review
Creative / Respectful and Communicative
12 months ago
Creative / Respectful and Communicative

Kyle worked hard to get our goal met, my house sold in a trending buyers market. Kyle used an unusual, but wonderful tactic to get attention by making a video while riding his bike with a drone filming him through the neighborhood to highlight what it has to offer. As the sale proceeded, Kyle used his vast knowledge and creativity to make a smooth transition to the ginsl goal was met. Stellar professional.

Buyer review
Best Realtor Around!
about 1 year ago
Best Realtor Around!

It was an absolute treat to work with Kyle. He is extremely knowledgeable and you benefit from his years of living and working in the St Pete/Tampa area. He listens closely to what you are looking for and brought a number of great houses that met my requirements to my attention. He goes the extra mile - crawling around the house to locate electric panels, crawl space access, and more to make sure you have a complete understanding of the house in question. On top of that, he is a fantastic person and so great to be around, he makes the whole experience a pleasure. I highly recommend Kyle to anyone considering a home purchase.

13 - 24 of 137
© 2026 RateMyAgent