Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 119 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
Jay Quigley is the most professional agent we have ever used

Jay Quigley is the most professional agent we have ever used. He was always available to answer any question with patience and understanding. Jay supported us through every step of our buying process. We highly recommend his services. Jay definitely goes the extra mile for his clients!

over 5 years ago
Jay is a fantastic realtor with a winning combination of fun personality and professional experience

Jay is a fantastic realtor with a winning combination of fun personality and professional experience that leads to the desired outcome- quick sale! For him, I was an out of town seller. During our initial call, Jay took the time to understand my needs and when we met shortly after for a property walk through and price listing meeting he did not disappoint. Preparation is everything and Jay made sure I had the facts to make next steps decisions. His local contractor recommendation was spot on with pricing and quality of work too. He was my eyes on the ground and provided white glove service on everything including the inspection action items. Jay was a great communicator as well when it came time to work through tough decisions when a slam dunk same-day full price offer seemed to stall. He level-set realities and masterfully negotiated on my behalf. I really can not recommend him enough. Just let Jay guide you through your desired outcome.

over 5 years ago
I can’t speak highly enough of Jay as our real estate agent

I can’t speak highly enough of Jay as our real estate agent. He patiently helped us find exactly what we were looking for, and once found we closed on our new place quickly with no delays. As a first time home buyer we were terribly nervous, but he answered all of our questions and made the entire experience a pleasure. Thanks to Jay, our experience was great from start to finish. We highly recommend him!!

over 5 years ago
I can’t speak highly enough of Florida Executive Realty, and more specifically, Jay as our real esta

I can’t speak highly enough of Florida Executive Realty, and more specifically, Jay as our real estate agent. He patiently helped us find exactly what we were looking for, and once found we closed on our new place quickly with no delays. As a first time home buyer we were terribly nervous, but he answered all of our questions and made the entire process a pleasure. Thanks to Jay, our experience was great from start to finish. We highly recommend him!!

over 5 years ago
Professional, kind, all around great person! I recently had the pleasure of working with Jay Quigley

Professional, kind, all around great person! I recently had the pleasure of working with Jay Quigley on a transaction. From the moment he scheduled a showing on my listing his professionalism showed. Jay went above and beyond with every detail. His attention to detail made for an incredibly smooth transaction. He truly has earned his fantastic reputation. It was an honor working with Jay and I look forward to working with him again in the future.

over 5 years ago
Jay Quigley is an amazing agent who is perfect for a first-time homebuyer

Jay Quigley is an amazing agent who is perfect for a first-time homebuyer. We selected Jay as our agent because we were looking for an Accredited Buyer's Representative with local knowledge and sufficient experience, and Jay couldn't have been a better fit. Jay is from the Tampa Bay area and has an extensive amount of local knowledge, as well as great local contacts. Jay guided us through the home buying process and supported us every step of the way, including after the purchase. Jay helped us to set realistic goals and worked with us to achieve them. Whenever there were hiccups in the process, Jay was right there guiding us through them. Jay was also a huge asset whenever we visited properties, as he pointed out areas of concern that we would never have noticed on our own. Jay helped us figure out how much to offer when we selected our house, and we were thrilled when we learned that our accepted offer was actually 5k below the appraised value. Throughout the entire process, Jay responded to all communications right away and demonstrated consistent follow through. Jay got us to the finish line in a wonderful home, and we highly recommend Jay to any buyer in the area.

over 5 years ago
I am thrilled to have chosen Jay as our realtor for our first house purchase

I am thrilled to have chosen Jay as our realtor for our first house purchase. He went beyond any expectations I had for a realtor. Communication and transparency are very important to me, and he was always on point. Jay was not only courteous and kind but also very PROFESSIONAL. He is very detail oriented and will always look out for your best interest. I have no reservations recommending Jay to anyone who wants buy/sell property, he will impress you.

over 5 years ago
Jay was amazing and so helpful when it came to what we needed to do in order to get our home sold

Jay was amazing and so helpful when it came to what we needed to do in order to get our home sold. Him and his team were very accommodating as things changed throughout the process. Jay's professionalism and understanding of our individual situation made selling our home seamless. Thank you so much for everything! Your kindness is greatly appreciated and I will be calling you again when I buy my next home!

over 5 years ago
Realtors like Jay Quigley are rare! We began working with Jay when my wife and I needed to find an a

Realtors like Jay Quigley are rare! We began working with Jay when my wife and I needed to find an apartment. I had recently left the military and the wife and I moved all the way from Hawaii to the Tampa area. For the year we lived in the apartment Jay's level of commitment, communication, and overall thoughtfulness amazed me! He kept in touch, mailed birthday cards with personalized hand written messages, a magnet with the Ray's schedule, etc. Deciding to work with Jay again when my wife and I were ready to purchase a home was a no-brainer! He goes above and beyond to put the client first and look out for their best interest. For the sake of not writing a novel I will simply say that if I had to purchase property site unseen on Mars, I would have zero reservations with Jay as my realtor!

over 5 years ago
My Realtor was extremely helpful

My Realtor was extremely helpful. He went out of his way to help in any way he could! I’m an older person and put my mind at ease the whole way through the process

over 5 years ago
Absolutely fantastic! Jay helped us navigate the waters as we attempted to purchase a for-sale-by-ow

Absolutely fantastic! Jay helped us navigate the waters as we attempted to purchase a for-sale-by-owner. He helped us through the process of negotiating with an unprofessional seller and ultimately helped us avoid purchasing a house with a lot of structural problems. Then, he helped us refine our criteria and ultimately buy a wonderful home in Land O' Lakes. Jay was there every step of the way and we consider him a valuable part of our "forever team!"

61 - 72 of 119
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent