Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 130 reviewsacross 47 different locations, showing 12.
about 4 years ago
Jay, my bf, and I were so impressed with you from the very first call

Jay, my bf, and I were so impressed with you from the very first call. This was the first time for both of us purchasing a house in a different state from where we live. We had a small window of time to find a house, close and move. You worked with us diligently to find the perfect house. You fought for us when things got tough all the way thru closing. And followed thru on items that lingered after closing. In addition to all of this you introduced us to an amazing Mortgage firm that also took great care of us. We felt like you had our backs thru the entire process! Your mindfulness, compassion and humor made the entire process a pleasant experience. Thank you!!!

about 4 years ago
When looking for a realtor, I wanted someone who was well-informed on the industry, the market, and

When looking for a realtor, I wanted someone who was well-informed on the industry, the market, and the Tampa Bay Area, all of which I was able to find in Jay Quigley. As a first-time home buyer, I appreciated that he took the time to get to know me, set expectations, and walk me through the process. He was always patient, responsive, and honest with me, and I never felt like he was trying to "sell" me on something that was not right for me. Overall the house hunt had been a long, difficult, & emotional process, especially in this current market, but I have now officially closed on my new home! It is a wonderful feeling, and I am forever thankful I had Jay as my realtor through it all. If you are looking for a realtor who is thorough and knowledgeable, with a strong sense of integrity, as well as a sense of humor then Jay Quigley is the perfect realtor for you. Thank you for always going above and beyond and helping me through this crazy/chaotic process, Jay!

about 4 years ago
Jay was the agent I needed to find the home I wanted

Jay was the agent I needed to find the home I wanted. Given the market was a completely sellers market when I was looking (purchased March 2022), I felt frustration around the chances of us ever finding a home. Jay was reassuring in ever conversation that "If you follow the process, you will find the house.". He was a fantastic agent and absolutely knows his business. Highly recommend!

about 4 years ago
Jay was the agent I needed to find the home I wanted

Jay was the agent I needed to find the home I wanted. Given the market was a completely sellers market when I was looking (purchased March 2022), I felt frustration around the chances of us ever finding a home. Jay was reassuring in ever conversation that "If you follow the process, you will find the house.". He was a fantastic agent and absolutely knows his business. Highly recommend!

about 4 years ago
We started working with jay 3 yrs ago

We started working with jay 3 yrs ago. Finally we?re able to move to Florida & build a home. Our requirement was 2 homes next to each other. He recommended the villas at cypress preserve. In a matter of 2 hours we had signed contract for 2 homes next to each other. Thanks Jay!

over 4 years ago
Jay was everything that we hoped for in a real estate agent

Jay was everything that we hoped for in a real estate agent. No only did he help us purchase our home years ago, but he helped us sell it at the perfect time again five years later. He?s an excellent negotiator, communicator, and has a real knack for contracts/legal documents. Thanks so much for taking care of us!

over 4 years ago
If you are in the market for a home in the Tampa area stop what you are doing and call Jay Quigley!

If you are in the market for a home in the Tampa area stop what you are doing and call Jay Quigley! Jay is professional, personable, knowledgeable, accessible, hardworking and I could go on & on. Jay was able to make my daughters dream come true when she decided to look for her dream home in this daunting market. Jay was patient, honest and really took the time to not only walk her through but educate her on the entire home buying process. After just 2 weeks he found her forever home!! I cannot sing enough good praise about him. Thank you Jay! The Rhodes Family

over 4 years ago
If you are in the market for a home in the Tampa area stop what you are doing and call Jay Quigley!

If you are in the market for a home in the Tampa area stop what you are doing and call Jay Quigley! Jay is professional, personable, knowledgeable, accessible, hardworking and I could go on & on. Jay was able to make my daughters dream come true when she decided to look for her dream home in this daunting market. Jay was patient, honest and really took the time to not only walk her through but educate her on the entire home buying process. After just 2 weeks he found her forever home!! I cannot sing enough good praise about him. Thank you Jay! The Rhodes Family

over 4 years ago
Jay is wonderful, friendly, and respectful

Jay is wonderful, friendly, and respectful. He does a fantastic job protecting the interest of his clients while honestly explaining the current market conditions. My family has used him for multiple the sale/purchase of local properties and we will continue to do so as long as he is in real estate.

over 4 years ago
Jay was our agent in the sale of our current home … as well as our agent in purchasing our new home

Jay was our agent in the sale of our current home … as well as our agent in purchasing our new home. Jay is very attentive, responsive, knowledgeable and ethical. Not only did he help us through the sale of our current home, he was also able to recommend several businesses we needed, with all his connections (painters, junk removal, etc.). All those he recommended also did a great job for us! I would highly recommend Jay, and will certainly consider him for any future real estate needs!

over 4 years ago
When I set out on the journey to find my first home, I did not realize what an uphill battle it woul

When I set out on the journey to find my first home, I did not realize what an uphill battle it would be. Finding the ?perfect forever home? during this market seemed impossible. For six months, I felt like a guppy fighting for a spot among the sharks (All cash buyers, over bidders, you name it!) and was working with a realtor who was leading me in the wrong direction. Jay was referred to me, and everything changed. I?m forever grateful that someone threw me the life raft that is Jay Quigley. He puts his clients needs first, above the desire to make a commission. He gave me a consultation where he allowed me to voice my frustrations with the process and understood my wants and needs right off the bat, while remaining completely transparent on what his plan would be to find my perfect home. Throughout the process he was attentive, responsive and worked incredibly hard to send me listings I hadn?t had access to, to give me the best chance to make an offer quickly. It took just TWO WEEKS for Jay to find me the absolutely perfect situation for my family. I closed on a house today that I never imagined I?d find, in the perfect neighborhood, at the perfect price point, with every desire met and no bell or whistle spared. He made my dream of home ownership a reality, and more importantly, he gave me an education about the entire home buying process. He is patient, attentive, fair, honest and kind, and I could not possibly recommend him higher. Jay is the real deal, and if you?re like me and feeling lost at sea, use a life raft and call Jay. Simply the best. I will never use anyone else! (But won?t need to because I LOVE MY HOUSE!!! Thank you Jay! We did it!)

37 - 48 of 130
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent