Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 119 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
about 4 years ago
When I set out on the journey to find my first home, I did not realize what an uphill battle it woul

When I set out on the journey to find my first home, I did not realize what an uphill battle it would be. Finding the ?perfect forever home? during this market seemed impossible. For six months, I felt like a guppy fighting for a spot among the sharks (All cash buyers, over bidders, you name it!) and was working with a realtor who was leading me in the wrong direction. Jay was referred to me, and everything changed. I?m forever grateful that someone threw me the life raft that is Jay Quigley. He puts his clients needs first, above the desire to make a commission. He gave me a consultation where he allowed me to voice my frustrations with the process and understood my wants and needs right off the bat, while remaining completely transparent on what his plan would be to find my perfect home. Throughout the process he was attentive, responsive and worked incredibly hard to send me listings I hadn?t had access to, to give me the best chance to make an offer quickly. It took just TWO WEEKS for Jay to find me the absolutely perfect situation for my family. I closed on a house today that I never imagined I?d find, in the perfect neighborhood, at the perfect price point, with every desire met and no bell or whistle spared. He made my dream of home ownership a reality, and more importantly, he gave me an education about the entire home buying process. He is patient, attentive, fair, honest and kind, and I could not possibly recommend him higher. Jay is the real deal, and if you?re like me and feeling lost at sea, use a life raft and call Jay. Simply the best. I will never use anyone else! (But won?t need to because I LOVE MY HOUSE!!! Thank you Jay! We did it!)

about 4 years ago
Jay Quigley is the consummate professional whose many years of experience proved to be more than equ

Jay Quigley is the consummate professional whose many years of experience proved to be more than equal to the task of supporting my home search requirements. He won me over with an extensive and detailed understanding of the housing market, location, and challenges. His expert interpersonal skills and communications acumen were stellar, all of which assured me that my needs (and that of my family) were first and foremost in the search. From beginning to end, he provided the right amount of contact, follow-up, and advice to get me into a home with which I would be delighted. Despite three “under-contracts” and rejected offers too numerous to count, we finally closed on home, all thanks to Jay’s commitment and dedication. I highly recommend Jay as your agent of choice.

about 4 years ago
Jay Quigley did a phenomenal job! He is very knowledgeable and truly wants to make his clients happy

Jay Quigley did a phenomenal job! He is very knowledgeable and truly wants to make his clients happy. Jay made this process so easy for me, he followed up frequently, and left nothing to fall in the cracks. In addition, he really has the ability of connecting with people. I really enjoyed his sense of humor while assisting me through what could have been a stressful process. I will refer him to everyone I know! Thank you Jay, you're the best!

over 4 years ago
Jay is extremely versed in all aspects of real estate

Jay is extremely versed in all aspects of real estate. He was able to answer all my questions immediately and knowledgeably. We were blessed with his knowledge, kindness, and protection during the buying and selling of our home. He far exceeded all of our expectations and wishes. His professionalism and natural kindness makes him the model of real estate agents. He will be our real estate agent for every transaction from this point forward. Do yourself and family a favor and seek Jay for all your real estate needs! I always will!

over 4 years ago
When my wife and I decided to make the plunge and move to the Land O Lakes FL area from California,

When my wife and I decided to make the plunge and move to the Land O Lakes FL area from California, we did not realize what w were actually looking for in a home. A close friend recommended us to contact her friend in Florida who is a Real Estate agent as well, but not in that immediate area. She then recommended Jay Quigley right away and we had the good fortune to have a professional business relationship and friendship with Jay. He was an absolute pleasure to work with, helping my wife and myself with the various decisions and choices that couples have to make when choosing where to begin the next phase of life. Jay’s knowledge of the area, business connections and advice helped to make our ultimate new home choice an easy decision. I would highly recommend Jay to anyone, friend or stranger, who was looking to relocate to the Land O Lakes or Tampa area. Jay is truly an individual who cares about getting his clients to the right outcome as I am sure he has been for all past and will be for all future clients that he encounters.

over 4 years ago
Jay and Brian were exactly what one could hope for in realtors

Jay and Brian were exactly what one could hope for in realtors. They provided expert guidance, reassurance, and peace of mind during the stressful process of selling my home. Since I initially had my home listed for sale by owner, Jay and Brian were able to come in and sell my home incredibly fast while ensuring I got a great price. I literally couldn’t have done it without them ...believe me, I tried!

over 4 years ago
Moving from a long way away Jay helped us to find the perfect house at the perfect time! At a time w

Moving from a long way away Jay helped us to find the perfect house at the perfect time! At a time when the Florida housing market was skyrocketing, Jay helped us get the house we wanted most on our FIRST offer. He helped negotiate a price well BELOW asking that ended up being the exact appraisal value. At every point of the process, he was a solid sounding board and very responsive. He is the best realtor you could hope for!

over 4 years ago
Jay was a tremendous help when we sold our house in Land O Lakes

Jay was a tremendous help when we sold our house in Land O Lakes. He was there whenever we had questions and really acted as a partner in the process. He took the time to actually listen to our goals and made suggestions as to how to reach those. His expertise was invaluablen I couldn't recommend him any more highly.

almost 5 years ago
The purchase of our home would not have happened without the knowledge, guidance, and care of Jay Qu

The purchase of our home would not have happened without the knowledge, guidance, and care of Jay Quigley. His understanding of the market trends, our needs, and sellers in our current market gave us an edge as home buyers. Jay is honest and willing to speak truth. It wasn't always what we wanted to hear, but definitely what we needed to hear and understand to successfully navigate this seller's market. Most importantly, Jay cared for us like family. He looked out for us during the ups and downs of the home search process. He was there day and evening to keep us focused and positive until we found our forever home. We are so grateful to Jay for guiding us to our home!

almost 5 years ago
My wife and I recently moved to Tucson, AZ, and needed to sell our house

My wife and I recently moved to Tucson, AZ, and needed to sell our house. We met Jay through my brother-in-law, and newly minted Realtor himself. We’re more than pleased with how he took an interest in us and our situation, advocating for us and guiding us through the selling process, is even though we were already in Arizona for the bulk of the transaction. I would recommend Jay highly to anyone who needs to sell or buy a house. Thanks again, Jay, for all your hard work and dedication to your profession.

37 - 48 of 119
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent