Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 119 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
almost 5 years ago
Jay was extremely helpful throughout the process

Jay was extremely helpful throughout the process. He was patient, informative and always acted with integrity in our best interest. There were several difficult twists and turns in our home buying process, and Jay was able to help us navigate all of them and provide the wisdom of his experience so that we arrived at our closing on time and with the least amount of stress possible. I would highly recommend anyone looking to sell or purchase a home in the Tampa Bay area to strongly consider working with Jay and the team at Florida Executive Realty.

almost 5 years ago
Jay Quigley served as both a listing agent and buyer's agent for us

Jay Quigley served as both a listing agent and buyer's agent for us. He exceeds all our expectations for a realtor in terms of professionalism, experience, and patience. He worked closely with us from end to end, and was always on hand to answer any questions and offer practical advices. We can always trust Jay to act out of our best interest. If you are looking for someone who is competent, honest, and trustworthy, Jay would be the perfect choice!

almost 5 years ago
Jay is far and away the best realtor I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with

Jay is far and away the best realtor I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. We have now used him in three transactions. He was the only realtor who was willing to help my wife and I find a rental when moving from out of state. Jay then helped us build our home AND find a second property after that. He always protects the best interests of his clients. I would recommend Jay’s services to anyone. In fact, I recommended him to my own mother (who also had a great buying experience when relocating from out of state)! Jay works hard, maintains honorable business practices, and gets the job done in spectacular fashion. I’ll never use another realtor as long as I’m in the Tampa area. Thanks for all your help Jay!

about 5 years ago
I can’t begin to share how fortunate I have been these past months to know that Jay Quigley was gui

I can’t begin to share how fortunate I have been these past months to know that Jay Quigley was guiding me through the process of selling my sisters home in Spring Hill. My sister passed suddenly and being her only sibling I was faced with selling her house. Jay explained from the onset exactly what we needed to do. Living in PA, jay was totally hands on for me and explained each step. We all thought the roof looked great but jay went one step further. Checked county records and we found out how old it was and an inspection would have failed. We would have lost the sale. We got a roofer in, repaired quickly and inspection proved good! If jay had not double checked we would have lost the sale!!! Service does not exist like that. The closing has now been finalized. Professionals like jay are a credit to any Business. I can’t begin to thank him. Trust is so important to all of us and Jay is so kind and trustworthy. I will always be thankful I met him

about 5 years ago
There is no limit to how many great things I can say about our home buying and selling experience wi

There is no limit to how many great things I can say about our home buying and selling experience with Jay Quigley. Jay was a highly suggested referral from a friend. His professionalism is incomparable. From our first meeting, we were impressed with the communication and transparency he provided. We discussed expectations and timelines which we've maintained throughout the process. Jay was available and easy to contact and would meet us as needed whether in person, over the phone, text, or Zoom. Our experience didn't come without hiccups but he was right there as our advocate and kept us on track. Jay exceeded our expectations and always went above and beyond for us. If we need to move again, there is no question which realtor we would work with.

about 5 years ago
Truly I don’t even know where to begin when it comes to the service that was provided by Jay

Truly I don’t even know where to begin when it comes to the service that was provided by Jay. I am a young first time home buyer with 0 experience. Not only was jay trust worthy from the moment we shook hands but he had the best patience with me and my million questions via text and late night phone calls. He was courteous and kind and was so thorough with his explanations. He really took his time and even in this crazy aggressive Florida market he never made me feel pressured and always had my best interests at heart. He was so honest with his assessments as well and if he didn’t think something was a good fit for my needs he would tell me immediately. He would consistently use his expertise and show me things I should be looking out for that could be a concern. I have not only enjoyed this entire experience with him and his entire team but I feel like I have gained a new friend for life. I am so glad that I made this decision to join forces with him. Oh and I almost forgot to mention. He negotiated better than Tom cruise in jerry maguire (I hope he will appreciate that reference) Got me a great deal on my home. If you don’t get jay as your agent you truly missed out .

about 5 years ago
Jay is a tremendous asset in the purchase or sell of real estate

Jay is a tremendous asset in the purchase or sell of real estate. My son used his services twice since moving here from Ohio a couple of years ago and my wife and I recently purchased a beautiful new home with Jay acting as our agent. We are from Kentucky. He is not only extremely professional but he is so solid and genuine in so many ways. Trusting someone to represent you is a serious matter for which you need someone who is ethical, knowledgeable, dependable, etc. Jay is all theses and more. For us, Jay has been a God send. He has taken what could have been stressful and given us peace of mind. Charlie & Carol Borders

about 5 years ago
When my wife and I decided to make the leap and move down to the New Tampa area we did not realize t

When my wife and I decided to make the leap and move down to the New Tampa area we did not realize the great fortune we would have by forging a business relationship and friendship with Jay Quigley. Jay was an absolute pleasure to work with, helping my wife and myself with the various decisions and choices that couples have to make when choosing where to begin the next phase of life. Jay’s knowledge of the area, business connections and advice helped to make our ultimate new home choice an easy decision. I would recommend Jay to anyone, friend or stranger, who was looking to relocate down to the New Tampa area. Jay is truly an individual who cares about getting his clients to the right outcome as I am sure he has been for all past and will be for all future clients he has.

about 5 years ago
Jay has made the entire home purchasing experience enjoyable! From showing to closing, he was always

Jay has made the entire home purchasing experience enjoyable! From showing to closing, he was always available to us, answering questions, offering recommendations and helping us in so many ways. Knowing that we had someone who was truly representing our interests and concerns gave us confidence. I WILL highly recommend Jay to any and all friends and family looking to relocate into the Tampa area. He has become a true friend to our family.

over 5 years ago
Jay Quigley came recommended by my realtor Andrea in the Ft

Jay Quigley came recommended by my realtor Andrea in the Ft. Lauderdale area. My wife and I were very impressed by the willingness and helpfulness, and Jay's professionalism in showing us condo rentals to us for our daughter. We're looking forward to working with him again in the future when our daughter looks to buy a house. I would highly recommend Jay for anyone looking to rent or purchase a home.

over 5 years ago
You will not have a better experience anywhere else

You will not have a better experience anywhere else. Jay listened to our urgent need for a new home and quickly provided us with possibilities that matched our requested specifications. It took no time at all before Jay provided us with a full day of houses for viewing. We were able to find our dream home that day. Jay is the expert in his field. Don’t waste your time with anyone else and call Jay for all your real estate needs.

49 - 60 of 119
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent