Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 130 reviewsacross 47 different locations, showing 12.
over 1 year ago
Jay was an incredible guide for my husband and me throughout the process of selling our home

Jay was an incredible guide for my husband and me throughout the process of selling our home. His expertise was evident from the start—he negotiated every detail with precision and offered invaluable recommendations along the way. There are so many aspects of a real estate transaction we hadn’t even considered, and Jay took the time to educate us through each step. Thanks to his guidance, we sold our home for more than we expected. If you're buying or selling in the Tampa Bay area, there’s truly no one better to have in your corner than Jay Quigley.

over 1 year ago
My husband and I live in North Carolina, and we wanted to find the perfect property in Florida for a

My husband and I live in North Carolina, and we wanted to find the perfect property in Florida for a winter home. Our son and his wife used Jay to find their dream home in Wesley Chapel, and Jay did not disappoint. He spent over a year helping us find the town, community and price point that we were needing. His eye for detail, communication on how we should proceed and his guidance on how to weed out the ones that weren't right for us and the ones that were perfect. Not only was Jay a true professional but he also personalized the process so that we had no worries when it came to the final day of closing. If you want an amazing experience buying a condo, villa or a single family home, do not use anyone else than Jay.

over 1 year ago
When my sibling & I had to sell our mothers house we were so overwhelmed & honestly had no idea wher

When my sibling & I had to sell our mothers house we were so overwhelmed & honestly had no idea where to start, Jay was highly recommended by a friend & from the first time we talked we knew he was it. He was so open & warm which felt like taking to a friend vs. a typical realtor. He understood where we were coming from, guided us throughout the whole process & was very easy to communicate with whenever we had questions & to keep us up to date. He made it all VERY simple. We completely trusted him & 100% believe we made the right decision by choosing him as our realtor. We both absolutely recommend!

over 1 year ago
I greatly appreciated having Jay's guidance all along the way throughout my home purchase

I greatly appreciated having Jay's guidance all along the way throughout my home purchase. I was completely inexperienced, and he kept me feeling confident and helped me make what I believe was the best possible choice. I appreciated his directness and honesty, and I felt secure. Jay was also very knowledgeable and helped network me with other people to help with this home's inspections and maintenance. It's been a few months of settling in now and I am loving my home more and more every day!

over 1 year ago
The Best Experience We've Had with a Realtor! We highly recommend Jay S

The Best Experience We've Had with a Realtor! We highly recommend Jay S. Quigley, P.A. from Florida Executive Realty in Tampa, FL for his exceptional professionalism and dedication. From the very beginning, communication was clear, consistent, and effective. Jay explained every step of the selling process thoroughly, which gave us great peace of mind and confidence. Thanks to his experience and strong negotiation skills, he was able to secure a deal that worked very much in our favor. He was always kind, patient, and attentive to our needs. It’s clear that he genuinely cares about his clients and works with integrity and commitment. Without a doubt, Jay S. Quigley, P.A. has been the best realtor we’ve ever worked with. We wholeheartedly recommend him for his professionalism, outstanding service, and excellent track record!

almost 2 years ago
I worked with Jay to purchase a house in the Tampa area and could not have more satisfied

I worked with Jay to purchase a house in the Tampa area and could not have more satisfied. Jay listened to my needs and represented the entire process with excellent professionalism and was always consistent in responding to what I was looking for. His friendly demeanor made the process easy to work with, and he made excellent recommendations of other vendors to complete the purchase. I think he went the extra mile in every situation and also followed up to make sure I was satisfied. It was truly a pleasure working with Jay.

over 2 years ago
What can I say about my good friend and realtor Jay Quigley? Jay is a true profession at his job and

What can I say about my good friend and realtor Jay Quigley? Jay is a true profession at his job and keeping relationships. More than two years ago my wife and I were interested in selling our condo. Jay kept us up to date the entire time, sending us anniversary cards, showing us market pricing updates, congratulations card for our now one year old, birthdays and so much more. If you truly want to feel valued, go with the best professional in the town. He works hard at his job, sitting with folks, discussing options, explaining all the details that goes into house buying, selling, and even hosting first time buyers classes for those interested. My wife and I were able to sell our condo in just at a week with offers behind it. He helped us price our condo at a rate that it would sell while others in our same neighborhood were trying to go above market in pricing. And when it came to buying, we had access to all the options out there. We combed through the homes, found the one right for us and Jay took it from there. I can’t express the gratitude I have of my friend Jay and the 6 plus years of knowing him. If you’re looking for a great realtor, look no further, Jay Quigley is your man. Also, him and his wife do a great job at hosting gatherings for their clients. Can’t wait to have my house warming done by him.

over 2 years ago
Jay must be the cordon bleau of realtors

Jay must be the cordon bleau of realtors. As a second time homebuyer, my experience was significantly elevated this time around. From making sure we had a thorough understanding as sellers of the why behind the listing price, to getting us psychologically prepared and strategized for decluttering the home to be professionally photographed, he was attentive to every minute detail we would not have considered ourselves. I definitely went into this with some anxiety about doing a concurrent sale and purchase, but his confidence in orchestrating the moving parts made the whole experience much less daunting and feel manageable with our busy work and parent lives. I was very comforted by his presence throughout the closing day appointment at the title company as opposed to simply staying for collecting commission, which I have experienced in the past with a different realtor. Jay was extremely responsive and accessible, highly knowledgeable, especially regarding market trends, and tremendously helpful in preparing us for listing our home. Jay has been a blessing to our family. He was our therapist and encourager when feeling overwhelmed about all of the steps it took to get two homes closed within a week apart while balancing parenting and three jobs between my husband and me. 10 stars ⭐️

over 2 years ago
Jay is the BEST! As first time homebuyers we had zero clue what we were doing and Jay helped us with

Jay is the BEST! As first time homebuyers we had zero clue what we were doing and Jay helped us with every little detail.. from making sure we had a competitive offer to personally inspecting our house on closing day, he walked us through every step with such professionalism and confidence. Will certainly be using Jay forever and will recommend him to all our family and friends.

13 - 24 of 130
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent