Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 130 reviewsacross 47 different locations, showing 12.
4 months ago
Jay is a fantastic realtor, and I can’t recommend him highly enough

Jay is a fantastic realtor, and I can’t recommend him highly enough. From the start, he sat down with me to walk through the current market and gave me honest, insightful guidance on selling my home. His marketing strategy is incredibly thorough: advertising across a wide range of websites and social media, a 3D home tour, professional photography, professional materials for open houses and showings, and practical staging tips. He puts maximum effort into marketing, and it shows. What really set Jay apart was his communication. He provided consistent feedback on how the marketing was performing and how to better position the home as conditions changed. Once we were under contract, he stayed just as engaged, working with both me and the buyer’s agent to keep everything moving smoothly to closing. Even in a down market, Jay got the home sold. A++++ If you’re selling in the Tampa Bay area, call Jay first.

6 months ago
I have known Jay Quigley for 30 years - both as a co-worker and more importantly as a friend

I have known Jay Quigley for 30 years - both as a co-worker and more importantly as a friend. In all of those years, Jay has always been kind, caring, straight forward and very professional in all aspects of his life. So when it came time for us to need a realtor there was never any question about who we would get. Jay had previously sold a home for a parent and we witnessed firsthand just how hard working he is - right down to scrubbing toilets! Jay was no different when it came to selling our home (although no toilet scrubbing necessary this time). Jay did the homework, came in and gave it to us straight, told us what we needed to do, what he was going to do, we got it done and our home sold quickly - very quickly. What we love about Jay is that he shoots straight from the hip - there was no sugar coating, no telling us only what we wanted to hear, and he was very adept at talking us off the ledge when necessary - albeit in a very caring, kind and professional manner. We would highly recommend Jay Quigley to anyone looking for a realtor - not just any realtor - but one that is professional, matter of fact, caring and goes the extra mile not only for you but with you. That realtor is our friend, Jay Quigley.

6 months ago
Jay Quigley with Florida Executive Realty is simply phenomenal

Jay Quigley with Florida Executive Realty is simply phenomenal. From our initial meeting (where he was extremely well prepared) and throughout the process of selling our house, Jay was professional, communicative and responsive, and quickly earned our trust. He took the time to understand our objectives, assessed the home with a critical eye, and suggested what we should do to make the home most appealing to prospective buyers. We followed Jay's advice almost to the letter; as a result, we had two excellent offers (including one slightly over list price) within 12 hours of our listing going live. Jay took what could have been a lengthy and stressful process and made it quick and easy for us. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, I would recommend Jay Quigley with enthusiasm and without hesitation!

7 months ago
I highly recommend Jay as a realtor; from consult to closing, it was seamless

I highly recommend Jay as a realtor; from consult to closing, it was seamless. Jay is great at staying in touch throughout, & his expertise of the Tampa real estate market is unparalleled. There is no one I would have rather trusted to advise me during my first-time home purchase than Jay Quigley.

8 months ago
Jay is an exceptional realtor and human being

Jay is an exceptional realtor and human being. He truly goes above and beyond for his clients. He originally helped my husband and me find a rental in the area before we bought our home, and because of his professionalism then, I didn't hesitate to have him list my mother’s home for sale. Jay is detail-oriented and ensures you always feel like a priority. I highly recommend him if you want someone who treats you like a person rather than a "number" and truly has your best interests at heart.

9 months ago
I got in touch with Jay through a reference from a friend and from the first message he was knowledg

I got in touch with Jay through a reference from a friend and from the first message he was knowledgeable and pleasant to work with. He is punctual and respects others' time. He responded to all of my issues and questions quickly and never spoke down to me. I always felt like Jay wanted me to fully understand every step of the process. Working with him was a pleasure. They say moving is one of the more stressful things you can do but Jay made the whole home buying experience super easy and stress-free. 10/10 I would recommend him to all of my friends and anyone looking to buy a home in Florida.

10 months ago
Jay has been amazing to work with

Jay has been amazing to work with. Every transaction has been seamless from beginning to finish. He is professional, responsive, and truly makes the process stress-free. I highly recommend working with him for any real estate needs.

10 months ago
Jay was great to work with

Jay was great to work with. He was understanding of our connection to our first home that we were leaving behind and helped us find a great home to create new memories in with our bigger family. He was patient and took into consideration all our wants and needs for our new home, directing us to a place that we will cherish and love for years to come. He went beyond what we expected of a realtor. And I'd highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

11 months ago
Jay went above and beyond to help us find our home

Jay went above and beyond to help us find our home. When we were ready to settle on a property that wasn’t quite right, he encouraged us to hold out — and he ended up finding us a much better home at a greater value. We’re so grateful for his guidance, patience, and commitment. Highly recommend Jay!

about 1 year ago
Jay was incredibly helpful and reliable during the purchase of our first home! He helped us navigate

Jay was incredibly helpful and reliable during the purchase of our first home! He helped us navigate smoothly through the entire process. Jay also has great connections to local businesses and providers in the area that we utilized during the purchasing proccess. Jay was readily available anytime of the day for questions or concerns. It was a privilege working with Jay on our first home purchase!

about 1 year ago
Jay was incredibly helpful during the purchase of our first home

Jay was incredibly helpful during the purchase of our first home. He worked diligently to help us narrow down the perfect home at a perfect price. Jay went above and beyond. He was responsive day and night and answered every question we could come up with, truly a pleasure to work with.

1 - 12 of 130
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent