Elise's profile

Elise's reviews

  5  
Elise has 352 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Elise's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, supportive, detail-oriented, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
First time home buying made easy!
almost 3 years ago
First time home buying made easy!

It was a great blessing to have worked with Elise on purchasing our first home. She was very patient with us, looking at so many houses before we decided on one. She did everything she could to make the process as seamless as possible. She was always available and put us in contact with the right people. Thank you!

Seller review
Great service
almost 3 years ago
Great service

We have used Elise Fay for 8 transactions. Great response and execution

Seller review
Elise had a great sense of the market.
almost 3 years ago
Elise had a great sense of the market.

Elise was very thorough from the start. She had several vendors she worked with that did some repairs to get the home ready for the market and show at it's best. Elise utilized the Coming Soon feature on Zillow to test the listing price and we had several realtor showings during our first, and only, open house. Elise and her team were very knowledgeable and easy to work with. Elise is very responsive to emails and texts. We had a great experience working with Elise!

Seller review
Elise is the best.
almost 3 years ago
Elise is the best.

Elise sold my mother's place after she relocated out of state. She handled all the staging, the sale, and the closing with zero issues. Her team is organized, reliable, and dedicated. We wouldn't use anyone else.

Seller review
Great team to have on your side
almost 3 years ago
Great team to have on your side

Another great experience working with Elise Fay of EXpRealty/Sibbach. She was a huge help in getting our home ready for market with tons of local contacts and tips to make it more marketable. It was ready as soon as we were and it sold the first weekend at full asking! She and her team made the process so easy and everything was handled flawlessly. Even after the purchase of our new home and sale of old, she followed up to see how things were going. She truly cares about her clients!

Seller review
Exemplary!
almost 3 years ago
Exemplary!

Very Patience with me, Listened to my concerns, Good advise, Very knowledgeable about the housing market, and selling process, Overall good experience.

Seller review
The Best Agent Around!
almost 3 years ago
The Best Agent Around!

This is the third time Elise has represented us. We were very pleased each time. Four years ago when our daughter started medical school at Midwestern University, we bought a house with Elise as our realtor. Our daughter has now graduated so we decided to sell the house. Given that we live out of state, we needed a lot of extra support. Elise helped us determine what we needed to do prior to selling the house, and she arranged and coordinated all of the services that were necessary, such as the painters, cleaners, handyman etc. Then when we were responding to the buyer’s post-inspection requests, Elise also arranged and coordinated these. In fact, since we weren’t around to even take out the garbage, she did that too! She is totally adept and willing to do whatever is needed! Our house sold very quickly. We put it on the market on a Friday, Elise had an open house on Saturday, and we accepted an offer out of multiple offers on Sunday. We were very pleased with the offer and the entire process. Although I know that luck is always part of an easy sale, I also think the correct preparation and selling process/strategy is a huge and critical factor! Thank you Elise!!

Buyer review
Great customized service!
about 3 years ago
Great customized service!

To begin, I was an out-of-state buyer, so I really needed someone to guide the entire process from the search through the closing. Elise Fay stepped up and got it done. She is very knowledgeable about all aspects of the market and gave me valuable advice about the 15 homes we viewed. It turns out that the home I purchased was not one that we were able to view, but rather, I had built a trust in her judgement during our search and trusted her to view the home for me in my absence. As was my experience walking through homes with her, I received a thorough evaluation of the home and decided to purchase sight unseen. This only happens if you trust someone's opinion and believe that they have your best interests at the forefront. Outstanding realtor and would highly recommend!

Buyer review
Awesome experience
about 3 years ago
Awesome experience

Elise is awesome, she listened to our wants and needs and worked her magic. Elise helped sell and purchase our home. She is very knowledgeable and answered all our questions in a timely matter, we were never left wondering on any situation or question. Elise made us feel like family, if you are looking for a realtor, Elise is the one, we definitely recommend her, you will not be disappointed. Thank you Elise!

Buyer review
Elise is the realtor you want!
about 3 years ago
Elise is the realtor you want!

I would not have wanted to go through the home buying process with anyone else. In this challenging market, it took a while to find just the right home but Elise had the patience of a saint with us. She was always available and responded to requests almost immediately. Her years of experience and knowledge guided us through the process effortlessly. She has assembled an all star team that was a pleasure to work with and the utmost professionals. Everything was handled promptly and correctly the first time. Glad Elise was by our side!

Seller review
Amazing Care and Service. Highly Professional!
about 3 years ago
Amazing Care and Service. Highly Professional!

Having experienced 4 real estate transactions in my lifetime, my experience with Elise was by far the most exceptional! After contracting with Elise, my friend needed me to act on her behalf as her POA. Having not met Elise and living in another state, I had to introduce myself over the phone and explain the new situation. Elise immediately responded with care, concern and and sensitivity to my friend’s situation. Elise was flawless in her ability to maintain an amazing, empathetic and professional service to both my friend and myself. I had no doubt that she had my friend’s best interest in mind at all times. A few roadblocks along the way were soon overcome with Elise’s expert assistance. I was incredibly pleased with Elise’s expertise and kindness throughout the entire journey! Definitely a top recommendation! Five stars!

97 - 108 of 352
© 2026 RateMyAgent