Dave's profile

Dave's reviews

  5  
Dave has 81 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Dave's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, patient, honest, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Our man in Toledo.
over 3 years ago
Our man in Toledo.

Inspired by some success stories on the Bigger Pockets Podcast, my wife and I were looking to purchase rental property in Toledo. We did some homework and research regarding out of state property investment and interviewed a few agents over the phone. Dave Poeppelmeier came across as the most genuine, enthusiastic, interested, and knowledgable out of all the agents we spoke with. As our property search progressed, Dave reassured us over and over again, through his professionalism and experience, that we were in good hands. There were no stupid questions, no pressure to buy or sign anything we found questionable. In fact there were one or two properties he advised us to stay away from based on his experience and neighborhood trends. Phone calls and emails were replied to promptly. Videos of site walks, pictures of defects and damage were sent quickly. After about three months of working with Dave we found our first rental property and we are absolutely grateful for his expertise and guidance. We truly felt like Dave was our eyes on the ground as well as our agent protecting our interests. We absolutely recommend his services to anyone looking to purchase real estate in the city of Toledo, OH.

Seller review
Thanks Dave!
over 3 years ago
Thanks Dave!

As an out of state investor, it gives me comfort working with Dave as he’s an active and experienced investor in Toledo himself. His in-depth knowledge regarding the Toledo market, market insights, understanding of REI, network of inspectors, lenders, insurance agents etc is invaluable. I appreciate Dave’s responsiveness and diligence when viewing potential investment properties on my behalf. He goes above and beyond to take and send pictures or video of properties when appropriate along with a summary of the property and has a good intuition for whether or not it would serve as a smart investment. Dave is a good asset to have on your side, especially if you’re an out of state investor.

Buyer review
Have YOU Used Dave?
over 3 years ago
Have YOU Used Dave?

As an out of state investor, it gives me comfort working with Dave as he’s an active and experienced investor in Toledo himself. His in-depth knowledge regarding the Toledo market, market insights, understanding of REI, network of inspectors, lenders, insurance agents etc is invaluable. I appreciate Dave’s responsiveness and diligence when viewing potential investment properties on my behalf. He goes above and beyond to take and send pictures or video of properties when appropriate along with a summary of the property and has a good intuition for whether or not it would serve as a smart investment. Dave is a good asset to have on your side, especially if you’re an out of state investor.

Buyer review
Will Use Again 👏
over 3 years ago
Will Use Again 👏

As an out of state investor, it gives me comfort working with Dave as he’s an active and experienced investor in Toledo himself. His in-depth knowledge regarding the Toledo market, market insights, understanding of REI, network of inspectors, lenders, insurance agents etc is invaluable. I appreciate Dave’s responsiveness and diligence when viewing potential investment properties on my behalf. He goes above and beyond to take and send pictures or video of properties when appropriate along with a summary of the property and has a good intuition for whether or not it would serve as a smart investment. Dave is a good asset to have on your side, especially if you’re an out of state investor.

Buyer review
Great Experience 👍
over 3 years ago
Great Experience 👍

As an out of state investor, it gives me comfort working with Dave as he’s an active and experienced investor in Toledo himself. His in-depth knowledge regarding the Toledo market, market insights, understanding of REI, network of inspectors, lenders, insurance agents etc is invaluable. I appreciate Dave’s responsiveness and diligence when viewing potential investment properties on my behalf. He goes above and beyond to take and send pictures or video of properties when appropriate along with a summary of the property and has a good intuition for whether or not it would serve as a smart investment. Dave is a good asset to have on your side, especially if you’re an out of state investor.

Buyer review
5 Stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
over 3 years ago
5 Stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

As an out of state investor, it gives me comfort working with Dave as he’s an active and experienced investor in Toledo himself. His in-depth knowledge regarding the Toledo market, market insights, understanding of REI, network of inspectors, lenders, insurance agents etc is invaluable. I appreciate Dave’s responsiveness and diligence when viewing potential investment properties on my behalf. He goes above and beyond to take and send pictures or video of properties when appropriate along with a summary of the property and has a good intuition for whether or not it would serve as a smart investment. Dave is a good asset to have on your side, especially if you’re an out of state investor.

Buyer review
Exceptional agent for investors
over 3 years ago
Exceptional agent for investors

I've been in RE for over a decade and have bought and sold properties as an investor in multiple states, and Dave is by far my favorite agent to work with. I'm an out-of-state investor and he took the time to understand exactly how and what I wanted to invest in within this market. He makes me feel like I'm his only client and has personalized my experience from everything to the home-finding process, market analysis, lending, property management, etc. Dave is also a RE investor in the area which makes him extremely selective in his property search with me. He's not afraid to tell me 'no' and he is not just trying to sell me something. I've purchased multiple units with Dave and he thoroughly vets each one and makes sure all of my criteria are met before we commit to offering. He is the kind of agent that will set up a tour on the first date a listing becomes available and create a video walk-through with honest, and sometimes hilarious, commentary throughout. He is well-connected in the area to help new investors and homeowners with all the nuances of buying and owning a home. Dave is an invaluable asset for the before, during, and after parts of the home buying and ownership process. Dave is what we call a 'no-brainer', a 'slam-dunk', a 'homerun' but for this review, he is a 5/5, and will do business with him again!

Buyer review
8 Units in Toledo, OH w/ Dave Poeppelmeier
over 3 years ago
8 Units in Toledo, OH w/ Dave Poeppelmeier

Dave Poeppelmeier helped me acquire (8) units in Toledo this past year and he was a critical resource to close on the deal. He was great about communicating and moving the process forward to close. I highly recommend Dave to any one looking to invest in the Toledo, OH market.

Buyer review
Reliable and flexible
over 3 years ago
Reliable and flexible

Dave helped me to buy my first duplex. It was very good to work with him. He brings in his experiences as a real estate investor and helped me a lot to make it happen. He will go the extra mile for you. He was always very reliable, is 100% trustworthy and flexible. The seller screwed up the contract twice and Dave reacted very quickly and dealt with it both professionally and fast. Total recommendation.

Seller review
Very satisfied with selling of my property.
over 3 years ago
Very satisfied with selling of my property.

Dave did a great job representing me in the selling of my property. He made a few suggestions to me and the sale went smoothly. I would highly recommend Dave to anyone who selling or purchasing a property.

Buyer review
Toledo Investing Expert
over 3 years ago
Toledo Investing Expert

Dave helped me purchase 4 SF and 1 four unit over the course of 2022. I have a heck of a lot of trust in Dave and his analysis in the Toledo market.

Buyer review
Toledo Market Expert
over 3 years ago
Toledo Market Expert

Dave helped me purchase 4 SF and 1 four unit over the course of 2022. I have a heck of a lot of trust in Dave and his analysis in the Toledo market.

61 - 72 of 81
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent