Dave's profile

Dave's reviews

  5  
Dave has 78 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Dave's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Good from Beginning to End
4 days ago
Good from Beginning to End

Dave was very helpful, very knowledgable, and very friendly. His whole career has been in Toledo real estate so he is familiar with the local laws and ordinances (different from other Ohio cities), which directly affect the deal and helped inform my decision. He also knows the quality of neighborhoods which which affects the livability/rentability of a property. He was even willing to "run the numbers" on properties I was considering to see in the end whether they would be profitable investments or not. He was very good at communication: he proactively kept in touch with me to make sure the purchase process moved along smoothly, and he was accessible whenever I had questions about anything. He responded to texts and emails promptly which is a sign of professionalism. He has investment properties himself which means he is able to judge a deal and offer practical advice from the perspective of a potential owner. In the end we closed a deal on a property that I am very satisfied with, and I will use him again when I get my next property in Toledo.

Buyer review
Great Experience
5 days ago
Great Experience

Thank you for helping me navigate the Toledo market! Couldn't have made it happen without you!

Seller review
Dave took all the stress about selling a house and made it disappear by handling every detail.
5 days ago
Dave took all the stress about selling a house and made it disappear by handling every detail.

Dave managed the entire process efficiently and professionally. He conducted a thorough review of the property we were selling, provided helpful suggestions to enhance its presentation, and captured high-quality photographs. We received multiple offers within just a few days. Throughout the process, Dave kept us informed at every stage, skillfully negotiated among the offers, and secured a favorable return. If you're seeking a knowledgeable, professional, yet personable realtor, I highly recommend his services.

Buyer review
Excellent agent and happy to work with a knowledgeable investor friendly agent
about 1 month ago
Excellent agent and happy to work with a knowledgeable investor friendly agent

Working with Dave Poeppelmeier on the purchase of 2849 W Laskey Rd was a great experience from start to finish. As a real estate investor, I value agents who understand numbers, opportunity, timelines, and how to help navigate deals efficiently — and Dave absolutely delivered. He was responsive, professional, easy to work with, and helped keep the transaction moving smoothly throughout the process. He understands the investment side of real estate and was great at communicating clearly and staying on top of details, which is extremely important when managing multiple projects and properties. I appreciate having good people and strong professionals in my corner as I continue scaling my portfolio, and I’d definitely recommend Dave to other investors or anyone looking for a knowledgeable and dependable realtor.

Seller review
Got it sold!
3 months ago
Got it sold!

Dave was very responsive and communicative. He sent detailed analysis of the market before I even listed. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
The Ultimate "Boots on the Ground" Partner for Out-of-State Investors
3 months ago
The Ultimate "Boots on the Ground" Partner for Out-of-State Investors

As out-of-state investors purchasing our first property in Toledo, we couldn't have asked for a better partner than Dave Poeppelmeier. He provided expert advice on neighborhood choices and acted as a complete 'one-stop shop,' connecting us with a high-quality lender, inspection companies, and reliable property managers. What truly set Dave apart were the detailed YouTube walkthroughs he sent. He didn’t just show the highlights; he proactively pointed out areas of concern that would need to be addressed, which gave us immense peace of mind from hundreds of miles away. We felt incredibly well taken care of throughout the entire process and will absolutely be working with Dave on our future deals!"

Seller review
Dave, was amazing and made it all well worth it
3 months ago
Dave, was amazing and made it all well worth it

Dave was instrumental in helping me through the home selling process, demonstrating excellence in communication, market knowledge, negotiation skills, and professionalism. He made my first experience smooth and stress-free, and I couldn't have asked for better support throughout the process .

Buyer review
Made our house search easy!
5 months ago
Made our house search easy!

We ran into Dave by chance, he was showing a house just around the corner from where we currently lived. That house was not quite right for us but we stuck with Dave and after just a few more showings we found a house that seemed just right for our family! Despite some tight time restraints, Dave made it easy for us to make an offer and was there every step of the way to help us as first time homebuyers.

Buyer review
Reliable and fast communication
5 months ago
Reliable and fast communication

I have worked with Dave Poeppelmeier a couple of times now. Every time I have worked with him, he has been very reliable and quick to respond. That is a big plus for an investor. He has a lot of experience and gives good advice, and he is also solution-oriented. I am very satisfied. 5+

Buyer review
Great Buying Experience
5 months ago
Great Buying Experience

Working with Dave Poeppelmeier to buy an investment property in Toledo, OH was a great experience from start to finish. Dave and his team truly are knowledgable of the local market and were consistently responsive when I had questions. No matter the time or day, Dave was available to answer my questions and guide me through every step. I particularly appreciated how Dave went above an beyond to speak to the pros and cons of each property and even walk me through inspections. If you want a stress-free and supportive home-buying journey, I'd highly recommend Dave Poeppelmeier!

Buyer review
Investor Friendly and Highly Knowledgeable
6 months ago
Investor Friendly and Highly Knowledgeable

Dave was highly communicative throughout the entire process. He helped provide feedback on multiple properties while we were looking for the deal that was right for us. He has connections with different people that makes everything go smoother during the buying process.

Buyer review
Dave the Realtor Poeppel-Master
7 months ago
Dave the Realtor Poeppel-Master

Working with Dave as our out-of-state real estate agent has been nothing short of exceptional. We’ve worked with him twice now, and both experiences were seamless, supportive, and far beyond our expectations. He helped me and my husband secure two amazing properties, and we couldn’t be more grateful. As out of state buyers we really relied on his expertise and would have passed on both properties without his very reports and he walked us through all his reasoning. He knows his market and knows what other buyers don't and will help you with your blind spots.

1 - 12 of 78
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent