Dave's profile

Dave's reviews

  5  
Dave has 81 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Dave's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, patient, honest, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing Experience
over 1 year ago
Amazing Experience

Dave has been super responsive, knowledgeable and helpful with finding deals I may have missed keeping our preferences in mind. It helps that he also has investment properties so he we were on the same page. He went above and beyond to vet the home before we had a chance to see it as we were tied up. Appreciate the help Dave!

Seller review
Grateful to Have Worked with Such a Great Realtor!
over 1 year ago
Grateful to Have Worked with Such a Great Realtor!

I’m so glad we had Dave Poeppelmeier by our side while selling our home. From start to finish, he was a fantastic communicator, always quick to respond, professional, and super easy to talk to. We felt informed and supported through every step of the process. Having someone who truly cared and made everything feel straightforward made a world of difference. I’d happily recommend him to anyone looking for a great realtor!

Seller review
Excellent
over 1 year ago
Excellent

"I can't recommend Dave Poeppelmeier enough! From start to finish, he made the entire process of selling my house smooth. Not only did he help me price my home perfectly, but he also connected me with all the right professionals— from contractors to inspectors— ensuring everything was taken care of. His expertise and dedication truly stood out, and he was always available to answer any questions I had. I was able to sell my house quickly and at a great price. If you're looking for a knowledgeable, reliable, and professional realtor, I highly recommend Dave.

Seller review
Recommend!!
over 1 year ago
Recommend!!

Really knowledgeable guy! He invests in the area so he helped us find what we are looking for when he understood what we were looking for. Took a video of the home for us before we saw it and everything went smoothly!

Seller review
Great Customer Service
over 1 year ago
Great Customer Service

I recently worked with Dave to list a property; the experience was great. His deep knowledge of the local market and unwavering dedication to finding a suitable buyer made the process smooth and stress-free.

Buyer review
Professional Agent w/ Extensive Experience
over 1 year ago
Professional Agent w/ Extensive Experience

I've been working with Dave to purchase some investment properties and just closed on a house. Dave is a deeply knowledgeable agent with strong real estate / investment market experience, connections, and guidance. Dave is well respected in the industry - as all of the 3rd party connections I've made have shared their admiration of his character and acumen. I would very highly recommend Dave and will be glad to continue my business relationship with him.

Buyer review
Highly Recommended
over 1 year ago
Highly Recommended

I have now worked with Dave to close on 3 rental properties, all done from out-of-state. Dave is a great person and gives his honest feedback. He is involved with the community, provides great insight to the Toledo market, and has a wonderful team he works with to make sure closing goes well and there is a seamless transition to your ownership. He provides a great list of resources for everything you will need in case you don't have a team of your own. Dave is always quick to respond, has sent me video walkthroughs, and talked through inspections with me. I trust his judgement and will continue working with him for many more years. Thanks again for your hard work, Dave!

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and kind
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable and kind

Dave was really thorough and kept me in the loop about developments.

Seller review
Exceptional Realtor – Highly Recommend!
over 1 year ago
Exceptional Realtor – Highly Recommend!

Working with Dave Poeppelmeier has been an absolute pleasure! From start to finish, he made both the purchase and sale of my property a seamless and stress-free experience. His professionalism, deep market knowledge, and dedication to his clients truly set him apart. Dave was always available to answer my questions, provided expert guidance at every step, and went above and beyond to ensure I got the best deal possible. His attention to detail and negotiation skills are unmatched, making the entire process smooth and efficient. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor—whether you’re buying or selling, I highly recommend Dave for his expertise, integrity, and commitment to excellence. Thank you, Dave, for your outstanding service!

Buyer review
Dave Is Amazing!
over 1 year ago
Dave Is Amazing!

I have worked with Dave for several years and he is one of the best real estate agents in Toledo. He knows the market and will help you make a competent and informed decision. I strongly recommend him!

Buyer review
5-Star Review for Dave Poeppelmeier, Real Estate Agent
over 1 year ago
5-Star Review for Dave Poeppelmeier, Real Estate Agent

Working with Dave was an absolute pleasure! He was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and thorough throughout the entire process. Whether it was answering my countless questions, navigating complex negotiations, or ensuring every detail was handled with care, Dave exceeded my expectations at every turn. His dedication and attention to detail gave me confidence and peace of mind, knowing we were in capable hands. Dave truly goes above and beyond for his clients, and his expertise in the real estate market is unmatched. I couldn’t be happier with the outcome and highly recommend Dave to anyone looking for a top-tier real estate agent. He’s the best!

Buyer review
Game changer Real Estate Agent!!
over 1 year ago
Game changer Real Estate Agent!!

Working with Dave has been an absolute game-changer for my real estate journey. His deep, end-to-end expertise in purchasing, property management, and investment is invaluable. As someone who owns a highly respectable portfolio himself, Dave brings a wealth of knowledge, practical insights, and—most importantly—"battle scars" from his own experiences. This makes him not just an agent but a mentor who guides you through every step of the process. Dave’s ability to save costs during the purchasing phase is remarkable. He goes beyond the basics, often rejecting properties outright based on his expertise—saving time, money, and unnecessary inspections. His dedication doesn't end with the purchase; in fact, that's where his true value shines. He remains a trusted ally, especially in the challenging post-acquisition phase where first-time buyers and even seasoned investors can stumble. Real estate investing can feel overwhelming, with so many moving parts. Dave helps you navigate every stage: 1. Before the purchase: Targeting A/B/C areas based on your investment goals, weighing single-family vs. multi-family properties, and considering old vs. new neighborhoods—all with a keen eye on local ordinances (e.g., lead laws in Toledo). 2. During the purchase: Connecting with trusted inspectors, lenders, insurance agents, and other key resources. 3. After the purchase: Helping you secure reliable property management and building strong local connections. Dave is truly a one-stop shop with unmatched expertise in the Toledo local market and a wealth of knowledge from years of managing long-term rentals. If you're looking for someone who combines professionalism, experience, and a genuine commitment to your success, Dave is the agent to call. Highly recommend!

25 - 36 of 81
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent