Dave's profile

Dave's reviews

  5  
Dave has 74 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Dave's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Knowledgeable and kind
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable and kind

Dave was really thorough and kept me in the loop about developments.

Seller review
Exceptional Realtor – Highly Recommend!
over 1 year ago
Exceptional Realtor – Highly Recommend!

Working with Dave Poeppelmeier has been an absolute pleasure! From start to finish, he made both the purchase and sale of my property a seamless and stress-free experience. His professionalism, deep market knowledge, and dedication to his clients truly set him apart. Dave was always available to answer my questions, provided expert guidance at every step, and went above and beyond to ensure I got the best deal possible. His attention to detail and negotiation skills are unmatched, making the entire process smooth and efficient. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor—whether you’re buying or selling, I highly recommend Dave for his expertise, integrity, and commitment to excellence. Thank you, Dave, for your outstanding service!

Buyer review
Dave Is Amazing!
over 1 year ago
Dave Is Amazing!

I have worked with Dave for several years and he is one of the best real estate agents in Toledo. He knows the market and will help you make a competent and informed decision. I strongly recommend him!

Buyer review
5-Star Review for Dave Poeppelmeier, Real Estate Agent
over 1 year ago
5-Star Review for Dave Poeppelmeier, Real Estate Agent

Working with Dave was an absolute pleasure! He was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and thorough throughout the entire process. Whether it was answering my countless questions, navigating complex negotiations, or ensuring every detail was handled with care, Dave exceeded my expectations at every turn. His dedication and attention to detail gave me confidence and peace of mind, knowing we were in capable hands. Dave truly goes above and beyond for his clients, and his expertise in the real estate market is unmatched. I couldn’t be happier with the outcome and highly recommend Dave to anyone looking for a top-tier real estate agent. He’s the best!

Buyer review
Game changer Real Estate Agent!!
over 1 year ago
Game changer Real Estate Agent!!

Working with Dave has been an absolute game-changer for my real estate journey. His deep, end-to-end expertise in purchasing, property management, and investment is invaluable. As someone who owns a highly respectable portfolio himself, Dave brings a wealth of knowledge, practical insights, and—most importantly—"battle scars" from his own experiences. This makes him not just an agent but a mentor who guides you through every step of the process. Dave’s ability to save costs during the purchasing phase is remarkable. He goes beyond the basics, often rejecting properties outright based on his expertise—saving time, money, and unnecessary inspections. His dedication doesn't end with the purchase; in fact, that's where his true value shines. He remains a trusted ally, especially in the challenging post-acquisition phase where first-time buyers and even seasoned investors can stumble. Real estate investing can feel overwhelming, with so many moving parts. Dave helps you navigate every stage: 1. Before the purchase: Targeting A/B/C areas based on your investment goals, weighing single-family vs. multi-family properties, and considering old vs. new neighborhoods—all with a keen eye on local ordinances (e.g., lead laws in Toledo). 2. During the purchase: Connecting with trusted inspectors, lenders, insurance agents, and other key resources. 3. After the purchase: Helping you secure reliable property management and building strong local connections. Dave is truly a one-stop shop with unmatched expertise in the Toledo local market and a wealth of knowledge from years of managing long-term rentals. If you're looking for someone who combines professionalism, experience, and a genuine commitment to your success, Dave is the agent to call. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Great Realtor
over 1 year ago
Great Realtor

Working with Dave Poeppelmeier was excellent. He knows his profession very well. From communication at first to handling the difficulties of making a deal. His advice eased a lot of stress and prevented me from making irrational but market-oriented and therefore most profitable decisions.

Seller review
Great Experience Selling Investment Properties
over 1 year ago
Great Experience Selling Investment Properties

I recently sold two investment properties with the help of Dave, and the experience was fantastic from start to finish. He provided expert guidance on pricing, marketing, and negotiating, ensuring that I got the best return on my investment. Dave was proactive, responsive, and always kept me in the loop throughout the process. Thanks to his hard work and market knowledge, the sale went smoothly, and I couldn’t be more satisfied with the outcome. I highly recommend Dave for anyone looking to buy or sell investment properties.

Buyer review
Phenomenal Real Estate Agent
over 1 year ago
Phenomenal Real Estate Agent

Dave is an incredibly knowledgeable and skilled real estate agent—the best I've worked with so far. As out-of-state investors, we've relied heavily on Dave, and he has exceeded our expectations at every turn. He answers every question promptly and thoroughly, and his walk-through videos of properties are both informative and engaging. During these walk-throughs, he not only points out potential issues but also provides thoughtful, analytical insights that go beyond what most realtors offer. Dave has truly been our eyes on the ground, and his attention to detail and expertise have been invaluable. On top of that, he's a genuinely great person. We couldn't recommend him more highly!

Buyer review
Great for an Out of State Buyer
over 1 year ago
Great for an Out of State Buyer

Dave helped me from start to finish on acquiring my first property in Ohio as an out of state buyer. He provided all the information I needed to make a confident decision without ever seeing the property, and he brokered all of the negotiations with the seller. No other agent in the Toledo area I'd rather work with.

Buyer review
What can I say besides.
over 1 year ago
What can I say besides.

His market knowledge is spot on, he communicates well and in a timely fashion, he is a true professional.

Buyer review
Best realtor in Toledo
over 1 year ago
Best realtor in Toledo

Dave has been so great to work with! We’ve purchased several properties with and each one was a great experience. Dave is very knowledgeable on what’s going on in the market and how to get a sale to close. He’s great with communication and goes the extra mile putting together pictures and videos of properties we weren’t able to go see in person ourselves. We definitely will use him in the future and would recommend him to anyone looking for a home or an investment property.

Buyer review
Helpful and quick to reply with questions
over 1 year ago
Helpful and quick to reply with questions

Dave knows the Maumee market really well. We looked at about 10 houses and got an accepted offer. I would recommend Dave if you are in the market to buy or sell.

25 - 36 of 74
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent