Craig's profile

Craig's reviews

  5  
Craig has 162 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Craig's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, supportive, patient, clear communication, honest, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Craig is exactly the person we needed when we started looking to buy our first house
over 5 years ago
Craig is exactly the person we needed when we started looking to buy our first house

Craig is exactly the person we needed when we started looking to buy our first house. He was responsive, honest and down to earth. He taught us what to look for in a house, what should scare us and what was exciting about a house. He has such a great sense of humor and is all around a fantastic person. He isn't just a realtor, he's a human being. He helped us find the perfect house for us, taking us through as many houses as we needed to on our timeframe until we found "the one". Can't recommend him enough!!! Thank you Craig!

Buyer review
Craig is awesome
over 5 years ago
Craig is awesome

Craig is awesome. I could text him any time.of day, any day of the week and he'd answer. He never made me feel dumb for not knowing something, just taught me something new. Any question I had, he knew the answer. From showings all the way to closing, he was an amazing guide to the whole process. He took us through as many houses as we needed to understand what we wanted and to find "the one". And once we found it, he helped us to get the best deal possible. Can't recommend Craig enough. He is the guy! Thanks Craig!

Buyer review
We really lucked out finding Craig
over 5 years ago
We really lucked out finding Craig

We really lucked out finding Craig. He's the best realtor around. I would recommend him 10 out of 10 times! He does his job very well and his past experiences in the construction industry lets him better inform buyers of issues with homes they're looking at. He's very punctual and is a great communicator.

Seller review
Very professional and easy to work with
over 5 years ago
Very professional and easy to work with

Very professional and easy to work with. Sold my house in under 2 days and over asking price. Quick to respond to question and made the whole process very painless. Would definitely use again.

Buyer review
If you're looking for a Realtor, Craig Hickey is the man to hire!
I luckily found him on Zillow and
over 5 years ago
If you're looking for a Realtor, Craig Hickey is the man to hire! I luckily found him on Zillow and

If you're looking for a Realtor, Craig Hickey is the man to hire! I luckily found him on Zillow and what a blessing that was for me and my Husband. It's our first time looking for a home while expecting our first bundle of joy so we were in a hurry to find the perfect place for our growing family. The very first time getting in contact with Craig it was through text which was okay with me because Zillow connected us, I was interested in a home that was in contingent but completely in love with the house. Craig was able to get us in to see that house immediately with the option to get in a offer if we wanted, which was amazing to me that he didn't steer us away from a house that was in contingent but if there was a way for us to still bid he made sure that happened. The first house was a bust because pictures are very deceiving and Craig was going to make sure we knew what was WRONG with the house in every way before we made up our mind which was a great for us, we weren't very knowledgeable about houses and what not to look for when shopping for one. Craig made sure he kept in contact with us daily with his emails, texts and calls, it didn't matter where the house was he was there to show us nor was the time of day a factor! We really appreciate Craig for helping us find our dream home and being a awesome, truthful and reliable realtor for us!

Buyer review
Craig is the best agent!
over 5 years ago
Craig is the best agent!

Craig is the best agent! . He was always there to show us a listing and gave us great advice about each home we looked at!

Buyer review
Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond
over 5 years ago
Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond

Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond. Craig was referred to me from my co-worker and that was a blessing because Craig is the best Realtor EVER! Having Craig as your Realtor is like having a Real Estate Agent and a Contractor walk through homes with you at the same time. He has a wealth of knowledge that is unmatched in the industry. He can tell you about fire safety, home hazards, pros and cons, you name it. He is so knowledgeable and it will inevitably save you time and money. He gives you the information needed with honesty and respect. I will always recommend Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty. Thank you so much for helping me and my family find our beautiful home.

Buyer review
Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond
over 5 years ago
Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond

Craig Hickey and Mi Choice Realty are a 5 star company and beyond. Craig was referred to me from my co-worker and that was a blessing because Craig is the best Realtor EVER! Best thing is that he is so knowledgeable, he saves you time and money, gives you the information needed with honesty and respect. I will always recommend Craig and Mi Choice Realty. Thank you so much for helping me and my family find our beautiful home.

Buyer review
Craig has been fantastic helping us find a new home, and selling one as well! We were looking to buy
over 5 years ago
Craig has been fantastic helping us find a new home, and selling one as well! We were looking to buy

Craig has been fantastic helping us find a new home, and selling one as well! We were looking to buy a new home, which meant having to also sell the current home within the same timeframe. He was always flexible to get us showings that worked around our work schedules, easy to get a hold of, responds quickly and is very knowledgeable. His background in building/construction is a huge plus, as he knows things to look for in a potential home that other relators we met with before him didn't talk about before. I appreciated that he took the time to explain his findings and answer all questions during showings, teaching us so much! He's also very knowledgeable about the entire buying and selling process, helping us along the way as we bought and sold! He's straightforward, no BS. He isn't a sales person: he doesn't try to convince you on any aspect of a home just to make a sale, but presents things as they are. As far as helping us sell: we were booked solid for showings for two days, went pending in two days, with multiple offers over asking! If you want a great relator, call Craig for a house showing or two and you will quickly see why we recommend him!

61 - 72 of 162
© 2026 RateMyAgent