Carrie's profile

Carrie's reviews

  5  
Carrie has 93 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Carrie did a wonderful job helping me buy my first home
about 9 years ago
Carrie did a wonderful job helping me buy my first home

Carrie did a wonderful job helping me buy my first home. My realtor knew the Columbus market well, and was always willing to be honest about the value of the homes we saw - never trying to mislead me or withhold knowledge just to get me to close on something. In a hyper-competitive market it was great to have somebody willing and able to meet for showings, walk-thrus etc at a moments notice. When some issues with the home itself arose after closing, they were still there for me to make sure everything got ironed out.

Buyer review
Carrie and her team at Conley and Partners are such a great group of realtors to work with
over 9 years ago
Carrie and her team at Conley and Partners are such a great group of realtors to work with

Carrie and her team at Conley and Partners are such a great group of realtors to work with. From the quick response times any day of the week, to handling every detail in the process, they did so much work to be sure our homes closed seamlessly and on time. We have worked with Carrie to buy and sell twice, and would recommend her to everyone we know!

Buyer review
Carrie Everingham provided unbelievable help, service, and guidance in a very stressful process
over 10 years ago
Carrie Everingham provided unbelievable help, service, and guidance in a very stressful process

Carrie Everingham provided unbelievable help, service, and guidance in a very stressful process. Not only did she know every step expertly - from finding the right neighborhood for us to reasonable price expectations to closing day process - she provided a very real, very calm presence during the whole ordeal. Our situation was somewhat complicated, and Carrie was able to help provide guidance and thorough assistance the entire time. You will definitely appreciate choosing Carrie and the team that she works with!

Buyer review
I would HIGHLY recommend Carrie to anyone looking to buy a new home
over 10 years ago
I would HIGHLY recommend Carrie to anyone looking to buy a new home

I would HIGHLY recommend Carrie to anyone looking to buy a new home. Coming in as a first time home buyer, I had NO idea what I was doing, and she helped me every single step of the way: from negotiating the offer, scheduling the inspection, directing me to a wonderful lender and making sure everything was taken care of on things I didn't even think of or consider!! She was SUPER PROMPT at getting back to all my calls and random texts... and really just took the worry and stress out of any and all aspects! THANK YOU SO MUCH CARRIE!!!

Buyer review
Carrie ignored the prior two searches I did with her in past years
almost 11 years ago
Carrie ignored the prior two searches I did with her in past years

Carrie ignored the prior two searches I did with her in past years....without buying anything.....and, fully engaged herself in our 3rd search for a Dublin condo with a tight spec (price, location, size, move in ready, one floor, etc). She steered us away from interesting, but No Spec Fit, options we expressed interest in. She kept me well informed about the local market and comps as we negotiated with our Seller. Her local knowledge came in very handy throughout the process. We are Happy Dublin Condo Campers !!! Brian and Sandy

Buyer review
Carrie did an AMAZING job with us
almost 12 years ago
Carrie did an AMAZING job with us

Carrie did an AMAZING job with us. It was our first time buying a home and Carrie made the process so smooth and enjoyable. We went out to see over 20 homes with Carrie and my husband and I loved her honesty and keen eye for detail. She really paid attention to what we were looking for and did a great job in guiding us into the right direction (never out of our price range) As new home buyers, we did not know a lot about the process of buying a home therefore we had a ton of questions. Carrie was extremely patient with us and also provided A LOT of insight. Her professionalism, organization, and friendliness was above and beyond. I would definitely recommend Carrie to friends and family and look forward to working with her again down the road when we decide to sell.

85 - 93 of 93
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent