Carrie's profile

Carrie's reviews

  5  
Carrie has 93 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Working with Carrie to help list and sell my condo was seamless
about 4 years ago
Working with Carrie to help list and sell my condo was seamless

Working with Carrie to help list and sell my condo was seamless. From helping with little details, providing tips/tricks for the showings, giving me real time offer details as they came in, and closing quickly, selling for me was effortless. I was able to select from multiple offers and Carrie helped navigate those complexities. Not only would I recommend Carrie to anyone selling in this fast paced market, I will definitely use her in the future when our family is ready for our next chapter!

Buyer review
<p>We had the most wonderful experience working with Carrie
about 4 years ago

We had the most wonderful experience working with Carrie

We had the most wonderful experience working with Carrie. She was super responsive to our requests for showings, knowledgable about the Columbus area, and worked with us to find our dream home. As a first time home buyer, Carrie made the process so easy by sharing her knowledge and expertise to craft the perfect offer. I highly recommend Carrie Everingham for anyone looking to buy a home in the Columbus area - she is truly the best!

Buyer review
<p>Carrie was amazing to work with, to purchase our new home
about 4 years ago

Carrie was amazing to work with, to purchase our new home

Carrie was amazing to work with, to purchase our new home. She lead us thru every step of the process with calmness and clarity, which enabled us to find the perfect home for us. We can't thank her enough and would absolutely recommend her to anyone buying or selling their home!

Seller review
<p>Carrie is the best!! She is very responsive and details oriented
about 4 years ago

Carrie is the best!! She is very responsive and details oriented

Carrie is the best!! She is very responsive and details oriented. She has a wealth of industry knowledge and experience and always creates a positive and fun experience buying/selling. I couldn’t recommend anyone else than her. She is always available and it’s very important as a client to keep moving things faster. I highly recommend Carrie. We have enjoyed working with her.

Buyer review
<p>Made buying a home in a crazy market fun and stress free
about 4 years ago

Made buying a home in a crazy market fun and stress free

Made buying a home in a crazy market fun and stress free. Incredibly smart and well versed in submitting an offer that is going to be appealing to a seller, and gives great advice throughout the entire process. Absolutely could not have been any better.

Seller review
We had a complicated schedule to work around, but she was quite willing to accommodate us
over 4 years ago
We had a complicated schedule to work around, but she was quite willing to accommodate us

We had a complicated schedule to work around, but she was quite willing to accommodate us. She seemed intimately familiar with the local area and communities and resources. During the sale, she helped us work through negotiations to win the bid. Now she continues to work with us after moved in, guiding us as we settle in and still helping with references and local resources. This is particularly valuable while the family is divided (in separate locations) during work transitions. Thank you, Carrie.

Seller review
Carrie is the most pleasant, thoughtful, knowledgeable and helpful realtor
almost 5 years ago
Carrie is the most pleasant, thoughtful, knowledgeable and helpful realtor

Carrie is the most pleasant, thoughtful, knowledgeable and helpful realtor. We have worked with her on our first home purchase, and went back to her to sell our current home and buy our next one. She listens and will work beside you for the entire process through. I will always recommend anyone to reach out to her!

Buyer review
Carrie assisted us in the search and purchase of our new home
about 5 years ago
Carrie assisted us in the search and purchase of our new home

Carrie assisted us in the search and purchase of our new home. As new empty nesters, we had many specifics we were looking for, so we were willing to wait for the right home to come on the market. Carrie was very patient and we never felt pressured. She listened to our wants and needs, and kept us on track reminding us of what we wanted or what was missing in certain properties. I also felt like she was a good mediator when it came to what I wanted vs. what my husband wanted and helped us find ways to compromise or find solutions to make each of us happy. Carrie is very knowledgeable on repair costs and remodeling ideas, and has an amazing network of reliable contractors. I respect her honest advise and appreciate her expertise as a realtor. She made the process much more enjoyable and I consider her a friend! Carrie will help you find what your looking for!

Buyer review
We have used Carrie twice for buying a home and once for selling a home
over 5 years ago
We have used Carrie twice for buying a home and once for selling a home

We have used Carrie twice for buying a home and once for selling a home. We love her! We would never use anyone else. She is responsive, caring, & informative. We have referred several friends to her and they also had a good experience!

Buyer review
Carrie cares about her clients and handles every detail
over 5 years ago
Carrie cares about her clients and handles every detail

Carrie cares about her clients and handles every detail. We are repeat customers and wouldn't go anywhere else. Carrie has a keen eye and years of experience. She ensures everything is handled professionally. Thanks Carrie!

Seller review
Carrie did a great job with all aspects of our sale
over 5 years ago
Carrie did a great job with all aspects of our sale

Carrie did a great job with all aspects of our sale. From helping us to get the house ready, to listing the house through the closing process she was there to help at every turn. She had good recommendations for vendors to use for painting, maintenance, staging, etc which helped us get the house set to sell. She also recommended what things we needed to do to prep the house and what things we didn't need to do. She was always conscious of the return we would get for whatever we were planning on doing. The house was in contract very quickly (5 days) so her results were great. She was very helpful with the negotiation process; both on the price side of things and the remedy request side. And she was there to help with the closing if we needed it. We would highly recommend Carrie to whomever is buying (we used her when we bought in 2012) or selling. Also if you are thinking about building we would recommend her for that too. She is knowledgeable in all aspects of the home buying/selling process.

Buyer review
Carrie is awesome! Cannot recommend her enough! Carrie helped us buy a home recently
over 5 years ago
Carrie is awesome! Cannot recommend her enough! Carrie helped us buy a home recently

Carrie is awesome! Cannot recommend her enough! Carrie helped us buy a home recently. She has so much expertise in the Dublin area, which was apparent immediately. And could not have been more accommodating with our very rushed schedule! During our search, she always provided honest thoughts and recommendations, which could not have been more appreciated. From start to finish, she guides you through the process every step of the way. Everything from the big important things .. . down to the nitty gritty (like exactly what utilities companies you need to call to set up service with!). And has also been so incredibly helpful after the fact in providing recos on local tradesmen, etc. (all of which have been amazing recos). Cannot recommend Carrie highly enough!

61 - 72 of 93
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent