Carrie Everingham

Carrie has become a member of our family after the time spent searching for our home. Not only was she on top of the market and constantly keeping us in the loop on listings, she offered incredibly valuable and unfiltered opinions/perspectives on properties. Carrie’s level of patience is unmatched - nothing seems to ruffle her feathers (even two young kiddos who would often join showings). If you are looking for a true partner in your home buying journey who is honest, committed, communicative, kind, fair, level headed, incredibly knowledgeable, and altogether wonderful, Carrie is who you need. We will never be able to thank her enough for her time and effort.

Carrie knew exactly what was needed for us to sell our home. From start to finish, she was very helpful, attentive, and her pre-sale recommendations were spot on. We sold quick and we'll be happy to tell all of our friends what an AWESOME experience it was working with her!

Carrie knew exactly what was needed for us to sell our home. From start to finish, she was very helpful, attentive, and her pre-sale recommendations were spot on. We sold quick and we'll be happy to tell all of our friends what an AWESOME experience it was working with her!

Working with Carrie was the absolute BEST home-buying experience! Buying a home from 2.5 hours away in such a busy & competitive market seemed like a daunting nightmare, but Carrie transformed that process. She helped regulate my chaotic nerves, let us know when to act urgently and when to chill out in the most approachable and respectful way. She always was very quick to respond to text/ email; she made us feel comfortable asking her anything! She has extensive knowledge about the neighborhoods, amenities, and traffic in Columbus and her knowledge has been priceless. On top of all of that, she has amazing contacts in all areas of home improvement which we’ve found so helpful touching up areas of our new home. I cannot recommend her enough, next time we’re in need of a realtor I’ll be calling her in a heartbeat!

Working with Carrie was the absolute BEST home-buying experience! Buying a home from 2.5 hours away in such a busy & competitive market seemed like a daunting nightmare, but Carrie transformed that process. She helped regulate my chaotic nerves, let us know when to act urgently and when to chill out in the most approachable and respectful way. She always was very quick to respond to text/ email; she made us feel comfortable asking her anything! She has extensive knowledge about the neighborhoods, amenities, and traffic in Columbus and her knowledge has been priceless. On top of all of that, she has amazing contacts in all areas of home improvement which we’ve found so helpful touching up areas of our new home. I cannot recommend her enough, next time we’re in need of a realtor I’ll be calling her in a heartbeat!

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Carrie Everingham with Cutler Real Estate to purchase a home for my parents, and I truly cannot recommend her enough. From the very beginning, she stood out with her exceptional communication skills—always keeping us updated, answering every question (big or small), and making sure we felt informed and supported throughout the entire process. Her promptness was beyond impressive; whether it was scheduling showings, submitting offers, or responding to texts and emails, she was always on top of everything. It made what could’ve been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. But what really sets Carrie Everingham apart is her kindness and thoughtfulness. She treated our family with such care and understanding, always looking out for my parents' best interests as if they were her own family. It was clear from day one that she genuinely cared, not just about the sale, but about helping us find the right home. We are so incredibly grateful for her guidance and heart throughout this journey. If you're looking for someone who is not only highly skilled but also compassionate and reliable, look no further than Carrie Everingham.