Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 108 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andy's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, easy to work with, well-prepared, dedicated, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Andy is tops as a realtor that worked for us
6 months ago
Andy is tops as a realtor that worked for us

I have moved 9 times with John Deere and ourselves Andy is the most professional kind realtor we have ever hired If you want someone who works diligently for you Hire Andy We have great respect for hm three realtors ahead of Andy did not produce a sale by it Andy did

Seller review
Fantastic Agent!
6 months ago
Fantastic Agent!

I worked with Andy mostly in the sale of my dad’s house in Green Valley. He was on top of everything. He knew what I was going to ask for even before I asked it, and took care of all the little things that come into selling a house. I felt confident that he and his team knew exactly what we needed to sell the house and was able to answer any questions I had and any I may have had. I really enjoyed working with him and no doubt would hire him again.

Seller review
Excellent
7 months ago
Excellent

We enjoyed working with Andy Anderson. He came prepared with lots of information regarding our property and the market. He listened to our thoughts and needs. He showed us alternatives for listing, and then , without pressure, let us decide how and when to enter the market. Once on the market, he pursued prospective buyers, negotiated sale, and helped us through closing . All interactions were personable and professional.

Seller review
The agent you hire makes all the difference!
7 months ago
The agent you hire makes all the difference!

Michelle Metcalf and Andy Anderson did an outstanding job from start to finish! I came to Michelle and Andy from a nightmare situation where my previous agent posted a lack luster listing for my house where it was poorly presented with low quality pictures, a bland write up and was over priced. As a result of choosing the wrong agent, my house sat on the market with little traffic for almost 11 months. Enter Michelle Metcalf and Andy Anderson! From the beginning they were focussed, energetic and provided expert advice on presenting and pricing my house. They arrived at the listing appointment very well prepared with information on the local housing market and my neighborhood along with a comprehensive and professional marketing plan that included much more than just posting a listing. Not only did they have my property under contract in less than 30 days, they quickly, professionally and effectively managed every challenge that arose (and challenges do come up with every transaction) with a positive and successful outcome through an EARLY closing and beyond! Michelle and Andy are a high performing team and I have never experienced such coordinated, professional and high-quality service in the 15 real estate transactions I've been involved with in 3 states during my lifetime.

Seller review
Went above and beyond!
7 months ago
Went above and beyond!

Andy went above and beyond. He watched out for the house since we were out of state. He blew the patio off so it would look good for the Open House. He turned the water off for me. He was very responsive when I would reach out!

Seller review
Andy is the CONSUMMATE PROFESSIONAL!
8 months ago
Andy is the CONSUMMATE PROFESSIONAL!

Andy is Michelle Metcalf’s partner, and together they advised me on preparing my home for the marketplace and managed the selling of my home in record time. I was an absentee seller and when Andy said something was to be taken care of, you could count it as done. I would recommend Andy to anyone who is serious about selling their home. Thank You Andy for taking charge and bringing the sale of my home to fruition in record time.

Seller review
Andy is incredible!!!
9 months ago
Andy is incredible!!!

My wife and I could not be more pleased with Andy's help in selling our house in Green Valley. He was always available to answer questions and offer professional help whenever needed. He is a man of integrity, very knowledgable of the Green Valley market, a very hard worker and a true professional. We would highly recommend Andy for any real estate transaction.

Seller review
Great service
9 months ago
Great service

Andy was very helpful when we decided to sell our Green Valley home. He was patient when answering our questions, and proactive when listing it with his business partner Michelle. I highly recommend this team.

Buyer review
Best realtor i've worked with!
10 months ago
Best realtor i've worked with!

Andy Anderson helped me find,and buy my dream house.He's very in tune with the housing market,he always answered all my questions.Keeping me informed of all the steps that concerns the buyer.Andy is also very kind and generous,he has gone above and beyond thru-out the buying process.I would recommend Andy Anderson to anyone looking to make a real estate deal.

Buyer review
One of the best real estate agents we've ever had!
10 months ago
One of the best real estate agents we've ever had!

For over 3 years, we explored the opportunity to relocate to southern Arizona and Andy was an amazing partner every step of the way! His knowledge and expertise of the area, the communities and overall AZ lifestyle was incredibly helpful in us finding an amazing home in a dream community. We are super excited to start our next phase and we are certain we could not have made this possible without Andy helping us through it all. He was incredibly patient with us, and as our situation evolved, he was very flexible and guided us through every step of our journey. We've bought and sold many homes and this was one of the easiest and smoothest home purchases we've done and Andy was a huge reason why. We would highly recommend Andy to anyone looking for a real estate agent!

Seller review
Great team
10 months ago
Great team

Andy goes above and beyond. He was always willing to answer questions and did a great job setting expectations. He also went out of his way to make sure the home was ready for showings following a small storm that made a little mess of the yard. Being that we were selling from out of state, this was an important detail that went a long way for us. We are very grateful for all of his help and the hand he had in listing, selling, and closing our sale.

25 - 36 of 108
© 2026 RateMyAgent