Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
380 reviewsacross 30 different locations, showing 12.
almost 3 years ago
First time home buying experience

Susie stuck with us through thick and thin. We have been home shopping for 5 months and she helped us with 9 different offers. Finally, we got the perfect home for us! She answered every late night phone call and text, met us on any and every day of the week and various times, and gave us feedback and guidance each step of the way. Susie really was so helpful and I’m so glad we had the chance to work with her.

Susie Basham

Susie Basham

  5   (33 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Andy Bathje - a joy to work with - I would recommend without reservation - thank you Andy!

Andy Bathje was great to work with in selling my house and farm. He took time to listen and understand what was important to me. He gave helpful advice and was consistently available for any questions I had along the way. He kept me informed of queries, showings, and feedback. Andy offered and provided so much beyond what a realtor generally does including walking the land (27 acres with woods) with potential buyers so they could appreciate the beauty leading to the Kentucky River. He was creative in his efforts to showcase my place by ensuring that the stone fence and springhouse areas were cleared for photos and hiring a drone photographer to capture the land all the way back to the river. Clearly, Andy considered the unique qualities of my property and captured a vision of all it had to offer. He was then able to communicate it well to potential buyers. I felt very well represented and know that "my" beautiful farm and house are now well loved by others. Andy is always professional while also very friendly and easy to work with. I would recommend him to anyone who has need for the help of a realtor in a heartbeat! Thanks Andy for all your help.

Andy Bathje

Andy Bathje

  5   (64 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Andy is the best of the best

Through every step of the process, Andy was excellent to work with. You don't feel like you're working with a realtor. You feel like you're working with a trusted friend who has your best interest in mind. He took great care of us, he'll do the same for you.

Andy Bathje

Andy Bathje

  5   (64 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Wonderful from start to finish!

Sandy helped us buy our new home and sell our old one. She was wonderful throughout the whole process helping us get a full price off on our own home and beat out others´ offers on the home we were hoping to buy!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Excellent Service - Great Experience!

I wanted to sell my last rental house. There were no other homes for sale in the area, so I could not tell which agents were showing homes in the area. I signed up of a "find an agent" service and Sandy called me right away. We met at the house and together we came up with a price and marketing plan. Within 2 days, the house was sold. Both buyer and seller are happy. I would gladly work with Sandy again. She was not only professional, but she delivered.

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
First Time Home Buyer

I've known Bathje for years, so it was a no brainer once my wife and I decided to buy our first home to go to him. He made the process super-fast and easy. We started out just looking and ended up buying a house in the first few weeks. His communication through the entire process was great, especially when there were some things that popped up on the inspection. He was patient with us while I made sure everything was fixed to our liking. Would highly recommend and will definitely be giving him a call once we decide to start expanding our family!

Andy Bathje

Andy Bathje

  5   (64 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Easiest home selling experience ever!

The easiest home selling experience we've ever had was with Sandy. You won't regret using her as your agent!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Sandy was the absolute best!

Sandy was a pleasure to work with. She remained patient and comforting despite the stressful process of selling and moving. She very accommodating and tried to help in any way she could. Can’t wait to work with her again!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Simply THE BEST!

Sandy was wonderful!! Very professional, honest, timely with communications, and overall incredibly easy to work with. House sold in a week and it was an absolute pleasure working with Sandy!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Another Great Experience!

Sandy is the best! I highly recommend her for all of your buying and selling needs!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Exceeds Expectations!

Sandy and The Agency are the best realtors around! Sandy, our realtor and friend of 8 years, assisted in both the selling and purchasing of our homes. She is very knowledgeable, friendly, and all around a pleasure to work with!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Sandy Did What No Other Agent in 5 States Could!

It was hard to be taken seriously as residents of Colorado that we wanted to uproot and move to a house on a lake. Sandy spent over an hour on an initial call with my husband taking notes on what we were looking for. For the first time in 3 years, we started receiving MLS notifications for homes that met our criteria and price range. Sandy drove to Danville several times to show up homes virtually and listened carefully to our input. Thanks to her diligence we are now living in our dream home on Herrington Lake!

Sandy Allnutt

Sandy Allnutt

  5   (208 reviews)
85 - 96 of 380
© 2026 RateMyAgent