Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
351 reviewsacross 38 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, supportive, detail-oriented, friendly, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Buying or selling, Andy will make it happen!
about 1 year ago
Buying or selling, Andy will make it happen!

Andy was super helpful when we decided to relocate from Oregon to Green Valley, Az. He always kept us up to date on what was happening with the purchase of our new home. He came over after the sale to make sure everything was good and to answer any questions we had. Andy has been so helpful and we are grateful to have him as our realtor.

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
This realtor rocks!
about 1 year ago
This realtor rocks!

Really can’t say enough good things about Andy Anderson and his professionalism as a realtor. He is so great to work with. He’ll always get back to you immediately if there’s any issues and when issues DO arise, he will take charge of it and make sure it gets done. We felt we were in extremely capable hands and we lucked out and got a fantastic realtor. You should use this guy too you won’t be sorry. And by the way, a very nice human being too. And last, but not least our house sold in three days!!

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
5-Star All The Way!
about 1 year ago
5-Star All The Way!

Michelle and her partner Andy Anderson are simply “ must use” realtors. Every problem that cropped up was quickly resolved. Andy really went the extra mile. Saying we are “super satisfied” still doesn’t quite describe it. We always felt we were in VERY capable hands. And… our home sold in 3 days!!!

Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf

  5   (206 reviews)
Seller review
A great experience reconnecting with Andy
over 1 year ago
A great experience reconnecting with Andy

Any was our sales person when we bought our home in Quail Creek. By chance we found Andy at Remax when we decided to sell. Andy is a real pleasure to work with. He had very good knowledge of the Quail Creek market and gave us solid guidance. Andy was very prompt in responding to questions or inquiries and his follow up was always immediate. Although I wanted to get a higher selling price, where we closed was reasonable given the state of the market. Great job Andy!

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
When we first met him we mediately liked him
over 1 year ago
When we first met him we mediately liked him

Recommended, he is a very hard working guy, They got the home sold and things went well. Hope he has a good year.

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Always available and helpful
over 1 year ago
Always available and helpful

Andy was very helpful and knowledgeable during the sale process of our home. He was also very accessible when we had questions. He worked with his associate Michelle Metcalf to make our home more attractive to potential buyers by pulling up some area rugs we had that were carpet taped to the floor for safety reasons, so the tiled floor could be seen. It was a good marketing strategy. My husband and I were both seniors and could not pull it up by ourselves. The strategy worked. We were able to sell our home in a short amount of time. Thank you Andy for helping us with this process.

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
We were very satisfied with our choice of Michelle  Metcalf
over 1 year ago
We were very satisfied with our choice of Michelle Metcalf

We think Michelle is the hardest working agent you could choose. Even though this is a slow market this year, through advertising she managed to draw many people to our open houses, one time 20 couples. She anticipates problems before they happen and tells you how to solve them or sends out reasonable priced knowledgeable technicians to solve them for you. She was always available when you had questions. A great negotiator. We were 100% happy with our pick of Michelle for our realtor.

Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf

  5   (206 reviews)
Seller review
Successful Sale.
over 1 year ago
Successful Sale.

We were selling in a challenging market. Michelle and Andy did a great job explaining the market and guiding our pricing decisions. Communication was always responsive and any follow-up done promptly. It was a pleasure working with both Michelle and Andy. Although I was hoping for a higher price, where we closed was realistic for the market.

Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf

  5   (206 reviews)
Seller review
Happy with the quick sale
over 1 year ago
Happy with the quick sale

Michelle did a good job of keeping me informed regarding the sale of my home. I was new to buying and selling real estate and she made it much easier by promptly answering all my questions and found a buyer more quickly than we expected. She and her associate Andy went above and beyond the call of duty to help us make the house as attractive as possible for listing. I want to thank them for their help. Their efforts were very much appreciated.

Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf

  5   (206 reviews)
Seller review
5 Stars - Outstanding Experience with Michelle Metcalf
over 1 year ago
5 Stars - Outstanding Experience with Michelle Metcalf

Selling a home can be stressful, but working with Michelle Metcalf made the entire process smooth, efficient, and even enjoyable. From our very first conversation, Michelle impressed me with her deep knowledge of the Green Valley market, clear communication, and genuine commitment to helping me achieve the best outcome. She guided me through every step—from pricing and staging to marketing and negotiations—with professionalism and care. Her attention to detail and strategic approach resulted in a quick sale at a great price. Michelle was always available to answer questions, provide updates, and offer honest, thoughtful advice. I truly felt like I had a partner in the process. Beyond her real estate expertise, Michelle is simply a wonderful person—warm, trustworthy, and dedicated. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent, and I would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Green Valley area. Thank you, Michelle, for going above and beyond!

Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf

  5   (206 reviews)
Seller review
Over my expectations!
over 1 year ago
Over my expectations!

I had the pleasure of working with Andy Anderson, and I can confidently say he is one of the best in the business. From our very first meeting, it was clear he was not only knowledgeable and professional but also genuinely invested in helping me sell my home. He was incredibly responsive and proactive throughout the entire process—always a step ahead, making sure everything moved smoothly. Whether it was scheduling showings, negotiating terms, or explaining paperwork, Andy made the experience feel seamless and stress-free. What truly set him apart, though, was his integrity and his ability to really listen. I never felt pressured or rushed, and he always had my best interests at heart. Thanks to his guidance and expertise, I found exactly what I was looking for. If you're looking for a real estate agent who brings skill, dedication, and heart to the table, I highly recommend Andy Anderson.

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Got it done
over 1 year ago
Got it done

This was a tough one. Despite the VA, despite rocket, despite some crucial details being unmentioned by the other side, Andy worked hard on these obstacles and made it happen. Would definitely use Andy Anderson again!!!

Andy Anderson

Andy Anderson

  5   (110 reviews)
85 - 96 of 351
RE/MAX Signature | Green Valley
Contact RE/MAX Signature | Green Valley
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent