Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
124 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, reliable, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
A Realtor Without Boundaries
8 months ago
A Realtor Without Boundaries

We had such a great experience working with Jim. From the very beginning, we knew our search wasn’t going to be simple since we were looking at homes across a wide range of areas. Most realtors we contacted told us, “That’s not my area,” and wouldn’t help. Jim was the only one who didn’t put limits on where he would work. He stepped up, was willing to go wherever we needed, and made us feel supported the whole way through. He was patient, knowledgeable, and extremely responsive — always quick to answer questions and guide us through the process. He made things seamless and never made us feel like we were asking too much. That kind of dedication is rare, and it really set him apart from the rest. If you want a realtor who truly goes above and beyond, who is flexible and committed to helping you find the right home no matter where it is, I couldn’t recommend Jim more.

Jim Bennett

Jim Bennett

  5   (12 reviews)
Buyer review
Incredibly helpful buying my first home!
8 months ago
Incredibly helpful buying my first home!

Joshua helped me find and purchase my first home in the Williamsport area. I have been living out of state, so finding the right home, touring it, and making the right decisions seemed like such a daunting task. Joshua was so helpful and knowledgeable, and also flexible given my circumstances, and made navigating the process so easy. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a home in the area. His honesty, professionalism, and consideration for his clients is extremely appreciated.

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
OUTSTANDING!
8 months ago
OUTSTANDING!

Jim right from the start was very prompt with communication. Very knowledgeable in the real-estate market. We had no worries with Jim from start to finish.

Jim Bennett

Jim Bennett

  5   (12 reviews)
Buyer review
Great experience!
8 months ago
Great experience!

Cherry is always wonderful to work with—polite, professional, and attentive. She helps make the home-buying process smooth and stress-free, ensuring every detail is handled with care. We value the partnership!

Cherry Lorson

Cherry Lorson

  5   (9 reviews)
Seller review
Worked out Okay
8 months ago
Worked out Okay

Mark took care of the details well, but I feel I was oversold on who Mark knew and his contacts before signing and soon as the first decent offer came in it was sell-sell-sell. Would probably make a different choice if I had to do it again.

Mark Caviston

Mark Caviston

  4.9   (16 reviews)
Seller review
Professional service
8 months ago
Professional service

Rob is Extremely knowledgeable and diligent. He took care of all the details.

Robert Pierce, Jr.

Robert Pierce, Jr.

  5   (7 reviews)
Seller review
Problem solver and GREAT communicator!
8 months ago
Problem solver and GREAT communicator!

If you're looking for a realtor with top notch communication and listening skills this is the one! Cara took the stress out of selling our family home. She went above and beyond to solve problems and provide answers! Great job Cara!

Cara Burch

Cara Burch

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Can't Ask For More
9 months ago
Can't Ask For More

Josh was very friendly and professional throughout our entire home-buying process. He was attentive and responded quickly to every question and request. Josh was personable and invested the time to make us feel like valued clients and even friends.

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent
9 months ago
Excellent

I had such a wonderful experience working with Anne McDonald. From the very beginning, she was attentive, professional, and always put my needs first. Anne made the whole process so much less stressful by keeping me informed, answering every question, and guiding me step by step. What I appreciated most was her honesty, patience, and dedication, she truly went above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly. Thanks to Anne’s hard work, I felt confident and supported the entire way. I would absolutely recommend Anne McDonald to anyone looking for a reliable and caring realtor.

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, knowledgeable, and friendly!
9 months ago
Professional, knowledgeable, and friendly!

I've used Anne both to buy and sell a house. On both occasions she has been amazing. An expert in her field and in regards to the market, enthusiastic, professional, and friendly. Never had any issues and all of my questions were answered thoroughly.

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (5 reviews)
Buyer review
Would highly recommend
9 months ago
Would highly recommend

Met Josh at a house showing. An we were like that house isn't gonna work for us. But we got a good vibe from Him. So we chose him to be our realtor. I feel we made a good choice there. He was very helpful. through every step of the way. He was great with communication an got things done. He don't mess around!

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (21 reviews)
73 - 84 of 124
Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
Contact Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent