Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
143 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, attentive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Every Detail Covered!
5 days ago
Every Detail Covered!

Stephanie is the ultimate realtor. She is extremely knowledgeable, communicative, and professional and her expertise was particularly helpful in guiding me through a competitive bidding situation. What really makes her stand out is how she goes the extra mile to make sure every detail is covered. For example, when an issue arose that could have delayed the closing, she immediately connected the appropriate parties to find a solution which saved the day. Likewise, when it was learned during the final walkthrough that the house had not been cleaned adequately, and several pieces of furniture, loads of trash, and packing materials had been abandoned in the house, she immediately got with the listing agent to ensure the house was cleaned and all debris was removed prior to closing. I am so appreciative and grateful! I highly and enthusiastically recommend Stephanie if you are in need of a realtor.

Stephanie Calder

Stephanie Calder

  5   (10 reviews)
Seller review
Carol is an excellent communicator and works diligently for the seller.
5 days ago
Carol is an excellent communicator and works diligently for the seller.

Carol responded on a holiday at 10:00 pm in order for us to bid on our home. And after we purchased said home she was responsive to our needs in selling our home to the right person and once again on a holiday. She has great marketing skills and is always cheerful, knowledgeable and professional!

Carol White

Carol White

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Made the entire process of selling a home seamless!
5 days ago
Made the entire process of selling a home seamless!

Anne was extremely helpful from the first conversation we had. Walked us through the entire process before we even had a contract put together. She was always communicating and very responsive to any questions we had as we went through the process. I would highly recommend Anne to anyone that is considering selling or buying a house.

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (8 reviews)
Buyer review
Perfection wrapped in excellence!!!
6 days ago
Perfection wrapped in excellence!!!

Mark takes caring, knowledge and going the extra mile to an all new level. He is invested in your needs and goes more than the extra mile to help you find the perfect home. Once he accomplishes that he sees that everything goes smoothly and extends himself to assure it happens to the very end. My husband and I would give him 100 stars. This is the second time we have had the pleasure of working with Mark. I recommend him WITHOUT reservation. Thank You Mark

Mark Caviston

Mark Caviston

  4.9   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent agent, knowledgeable and caring
12 days ago
Excellent agent, knowledgeable and caring

She is well informed about the area and involved. A wealth of knowledge and experience, her opinions have merit. She is friendly and caring. She showed up with her family to help me empty the moving truck when she heard I was working alone! I highly recommend Anne and her firm.

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (8 reviews)
Seller review
Attention to detail, sensitive to all the emotional aspects of moving
15 days ago
Attention to detail, sensitive to all the emotional aspects of moving

Stephanie did a great job with everything involved. She’s on the ball with details and deadlines!! Excellent communicator and knows her market!! We had a seamless transition selling and buying !!

Stephanie Calder

Stephanie Calder

  5   (10 reviews)
Buyer review
Understood our wants and needs in a house.
15 days ago
Understood our wants and needs in a house.

Tony has been more than an agent for us. He has helped us navigate Williamsport as we relocate from the Midwest. He has offered white glove service every step of the way. We are grateful for his efforts to find us a home and make us feel welcome to the community. Highly recommend.

Tony Nardi

Tony Nardi

  5   (9 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communication and collaboration.
16 days ago
Excellent communication and collaboration.

I worked with Rob initially in setting the sale price of the house. He reviewed comparable home sales with me. I asked him to expand the comparison coverage and he did. We ended up with a good asking price. He communicated updates to me timely and assisted with correcting several issues in the house either by contacting an outside company or correcting it himself. He guided me along the entire process and I could count on him handling any issues that would arise. I would recommend Rob to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Robert Pierce, Jr.

Robert Pierce, Jr.

  5   (8 reviews)
Seller review
Josh made buying our second property easy with his dedication, honesty, and outstanding service.
17 days ago
Josh made buying our second property easy with his dedication, honesty, and outstanding service.

This is the second property my wife and I have purchased with Josh Tagge, and he has earned our trust once again. He was patient, reliable, and always willing to go the extra mile to ensure everything came together successfully. His guidance and attention to detail gave us confidence throughout the transaction, and he helped us navigate every step with ease. Josh genuinely cares about his clients and works hard to help them achieve their goals. We appreciate everything he did for us and would gladly recommend him to anyone looking for a dependable real estate agent. We look forward to working with Josh again on future investments. Thank you, Brooke and Shawn Fillman

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (22 reviews)
Seller review
Awesome realtor
18 days ago
Awesome realtor

Very strong market knowledge

Brenda Everett

Brenda Everett

  5   (4 reviews)
Buyer review
Anne was great to work with through the whole process.
19 days ago
Anne was great to work with through the whole process.

Anne was wonderful after my in-person search helped find a place we had to move quickly on to ensure I didn't loose it. I then had to work remotely from North Carolina through to the day of closing when I returned. Her energy is matched by her communication skills and her goals of making sure I'm happy with the house I got (I am) and connecting me with the people I need in the community to continue to care for my new home. She has been a wonderful introduction to the Williamsport community and I'm so grateful I was connected with her for my hunt!

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (8 reviews)
1 - 12 of 143
Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
Contact Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent