Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
181 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, attentive, clear communication, reliable, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Stephanie is the best
about 1 year ago
Stephanie is the best

Stephanie is knowledgeable and professional. You won’t find better! She can recommend an electrician or a restaurant, can refer to the poetry of Khalil Gibran or the local tax codes, and genuinely loves this area.

Stephanie Calder

Stephanie Calder

  5   (15 reviews)
Buyer review
Seasoned expert
about 1 year ago
Seasoned expert

Anne made us feel like VIP clients from the beginning even though we were shopping in a modest price range. She worked quickly and efficiently and answered all of our questions thoroughly and patiently. She is clearly an experienced professional of the highest caliber and I would recommend her to anyone and without reservations. Thank you, Anne!

Anne Macdonald

Anne Macdonald

  5   (11 reviews)
Buyer review
Absolutely excellent. Stephanie is very knowledgeable and beyond helpful throughout this process.
about 1 year ago
Absolutely excellent. Stephanie is very knowledgeable and beyond helpful throughout this process.

Stephanie was so great to work with throughout this process. She is very knowledgeable and made sure to help me every step of the way. This was my first home and I was very new to how everything worked. Stephanie listened to me and helped guide me to my dream home. I am beyond grateful for her help and enjoyed working with her. If I am ever in the market to buy again she is the first person I will contact. I cannot thank her and fish real estate enough for all their help.

Stephanie Calder

Stephanie Calder

  5   (15 reviews)
Buyer review
A Thousand Stars!
about 1 year ago
A Thousand Stars!

This was my first time buying a home, and it was an insane roller-coaster. All while we were searching for homes, I tragically lost my sister and was faced with my mother getting extremely sick, and my fiance and his mother in the middle of being evicted. It was the worst possible time to be buying a home in our lives, and I can say with 1000% certainty that without Josh's calm and experienced guidance, I would have lost my mind. Josh went to bat for us when we put in our first offer, helping us build an offer that was competitive, and when it wasn't accepted, he helped us build counters and battled it out with the seller for us. He worked with me to help us find our perfect home and we did! Josh did a virtual tour of the home for us, checking for technical issues, highlighting everything that we would need to pay close attention to, and keeping in mind all the quirks and desires he had picked up on from our time touring other homes. Josh is the only person in the world I could have trusted to view the home with us remote, and when our offer was accepted, he was just as excited as we were to find the perfect fit. When we had mortgage lender problems and our calls went unanswered, Josh stepped up and went to bat for us again. I know for a fact we would not have been able to buy a home without Josh, because of just how many times he was there to help us pick up the pieces, fight for what we wanted and needed, and all the while calm, collected, and ready for anything. Josh stayed in touch throughout the process and after, and now as one of our neighbors, I can't wait to repay the many times he helped us with summer BBQs and pool parties. In short, if you're looking for an agent that knows the area like the back of his hand, is calm enough to deal with all the crazy you can throw at him, and a fighter when you need him to be, call Josh. He is who other realtors should be measured against for excellence.

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (23 reviews)
Buyer review
A local who knows the area!
about 1 year ago
A local who knows the area!

Josh drove us around and showed us the area and gave us lots of local insites. He was also more then happy to research and answer any questions we had. He made the experience so much better. I cannot give a more glowing review. Easily 10 out 10.

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (23 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgable and professional.
about 1 year ago
Knowledgable and professional.

Josh was knowledgeable of the market and willing to go above and beyond what was expected. His communication was frequent and he traveled many miles for every showing. We were very pleased on how everything went.

Joshua Tagge

Joshua Tagge

  5   (23 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding
about 1 year ago
Outstanding

Highly professional Knows the marketplace. Is approachable and addresses any issues

Tony Nardi

Tony Nardi

  5   (12 reviews)
Seller review
Professional partner in real estate
about 1 year ago
Professional partner in real estate

Mark is our go to professional in real estate.

Mark Caviston

Mark Caviston

  4.9   (20 reviews)
Seller review
A great experience
about 1 year ago
A great experience

Mark, is great at making both buying and selling a comfortable experience. Quick when required to deliver and patient when things need time.

Mark Caviston

Mark Caviston

  4.9   (20 reviews)
Seller review
Top Notch Realtor!
about 1 year ago
Top Notch Realtor!

Jim Bennett from Fish Realty is a top notch realtor. He was knowledgeable about the market, answered my questions with ease, and very clearly explained the preparation and process for the sale of my late sister's home. Jim was always available if I had questions. On top of all this, his sense of humor was an added bonus! Working with Jim was a real pleasure, and in no time my sister's home was sold. It sold in less than a week! What a blessing! Thank you Jim!

Jim Bennett

Jim Bennett

  5   (19 reviews)
Buyer review
Tony was absolutely amazing!
about 1 year ago
Tony was absolutely amazing!

Tony was absolutely incredible from the start of our experience until the end. He made the process SO easy and went above to make sure things were taken care. I’d recommend anyone who is in the market of purchasing or selling to talk to Tony.

Tony Nardi

Tony Nardi

  5   (12 reviews)
157 - 168 of 181
Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
Contact Fish Real Estate - Williamsport
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent