Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
792 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
almost 6 years ago
Our selling experience

Two words. The best.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Successful sale

The sale of our house took a bit longer than we expected. Peter is honest and ethical, we had confidence that he was acting on our behalf at all times.

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Roger is a true professional.

The National web network Roger employs brought the right buyers to us.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Overall a good experience.

Very experienced, good knowledge of market, good advertising and promotion. Only disappointment was the staging exercise. Having to buy the staged furniture and then dispose of it was disheartening. Would rather have had another choice on staging.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do

Selling your home is such a challenging process. For us, we needed someone to take the reins, put the plan in place, remind us regularly of what needed doing, and recognize when a small thing could make a big difference. Who knew that a ceramic pineapple would resonate with our buyers? Well, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer, our agent, did. If you want a full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do, check out her website and give her a call. You'll be surprised how fast you sell. Home 1 sold in a week with multiple offers. Home 2? Three hours! And with multiple offers and over asking. What more could you want?

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (74 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Excellent Experience, Highly Recommend!

Shayla and her team are excellent; throughout our sales process, they constantly communicated, answered questions and kept us informed. Their knowledge of the Longboat Key real estate market is unmatched. They even went above and beyond by assisting the buyer and their agent with information for lenders. My wife and I highly recommend Shayla!

Shayla Twit

Shayla Twit

  5   (3 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Exceeds all expectations and exceptional people/business skills

Peter is one of those rare people who have the depth to navigate complex situations. I had a challenging VA loan on a 1920's property which presented a number of curveballs on conforming, and inspection. From offer to closing he went above and beyond to keep my transaction moving. His communication was always timely and on point. He offered appropriate suggestions and went above and beyond. He worked closely with the seller's agent to ensure the deal remained viable, even with unexpected delays from the VA. I can honestly say that Peter's attention to detail, high degree of professionalism, and overall business acuity is a main reason my wife and I are in our new house today. I would not hesitate to work with Peter again, and I strongly recommend you do as well.

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
A trusted professional

My wife and I enjoyed working with Pete Snyder during our search for a beach front condo. He was extremely helpful and knowledgeable about the area. Pete had been referred to us by our friends who had gone through this process a few years earlier. It quickly became obvious to us why our friends trusted him. He helped save us a tremendous amount of time by educating us on the island, condo HOAs, and different condo facility amenities. I would highly recommend him as we enjoyed how personable, friendly and professional he was to work with.

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Never gives up!

It took a while in a confused market but Pete got the job done for us!

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Purchase a Condo

We looked for over a year at different developments, perhaps as many as 15 different locations. Pete was always on top of new listings that matched our needs. Ultimately, he helped us find our dream Florida residence within our price range. Great Job Pete!!

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Sale of a Condo

Presented comps and developed a recommended sale price above our expectations. Sold the Condo within 60 days within 5% of asking price. Readily available at all times. Completely professional!!

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Great Customer Service

Peter worked very hard to show our property by holding open houses and showing to other agents. He was always attentive to our questions and would recommend his services to anyone.

Peter Snyder

Peter Snyder

  4.9   (12 reviews)
637 - 648 of 792
© 2026 RateMyAgent