Carpenter Realtors - Columbus

1033 Jackson St Suite A Columbus, IN 47201
  •   5   (45 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Carpenter Realtors - Columbus has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

17
Reviews
38
Properties for sale
58
Sold properties
$324k
Average sale price
$18.8m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 11 agents at Carpenter Realtors - Columbus.

Paul Furber
Paul Furber

REALTOR®

  5   (31 reviews)
About Paul
Hi, I'm Paul Furber, a proud Columbus, Indiana local and realtor with over 11 years of experience helping people buy and sell homes in and around Columbus and surrounding the areas. Since moving to Columbus over 16 years ago, I have become attached to this wonderful community. Real Estate isn't just my job- it's my passion. I love getting to know my clients, understanding their stories, and helping them take the next big step in life with confidence. My journey in the industry has equipped me with the knowledge, skills, and a keen understanding of the ever-evolving market. Whether you're relocating from out of state, moving into your first home, or saying goodbye to a home full of memories, I'm here to walk with you through every stage. I believe in honest advice, clear communication, and keeping things as smooth (and stress free) as possible. My goal is to make you feel right at home- before you even get the keys. When I am not out selling homes or negotiating deals, you might find me hitting golf balls at the local golf courses, or even frequenting the local restaurants and coffee shops. I genuinely love this town, and its surrounding areas, and nothing makes me happier than making other's fall in love with it too.
View Profile
Quincy Robinson
Quincy Robinson

REALTOR®

  5   (2 reviews)
About Quincy

Quincy currently has 8 active property listings and 18 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Rusty Downey
Rusty Downey

REALTOR®

  5   (2 reviews)
About Rusty

Rusty currently has 15 active property listings and 31 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Char Ison
Char Ison

REALTOR®

About Char

Char currently has 1 active property listings.

View Profile
About Debbie
A graduate of East Central University (Oklahoma) and mother of two, I relocated to Columbus in 2010 after having been very successful professionally both with the phone company, (AT&T) and in educational settings. In a relatively short period of time, I have developed and cultivated many community ties within Columbus. I volunteer regularly at "Just Friends" at Mill Race Center and is an active member of the Columbus Chamber of Commerce. I have been a full time real estate agent for the past eight years. I have been successful by any and all standards in our profession, posting 22 closed sales in 2018 with a goal of increasing that this coming year. I am certified in relocation to work with clients of Cartus and Sirva. I have received numerous awards and recognition over the years including the 2017 Quality Service Award, 2015 Quality Service Award, 2014 Quality Service Award, 2013 Quality Service Award and 2011 Quality Service Award! When not busy with all the aforementioned items, I most enjoy spending time with my granddaughters and family. Travel and fitness are also passions and goals of mine! All of my accomplishments and skills aside, I care for my clients! This is quickly realized by reviewing the many customer testimonials provided by my highly satisfied clients. Of particular note, one recently wrote, "Again, trust plays a big part in client comfort. Debbie's knowledge of the area, houses in general, her profession and people make her an excellent broker. She represents herself and her company beautifully." The client continued, "Debbie Barrett is excellent at what she does. She relates well to her clients; she represents a property knowledgeably and truthfully, she advocates for her clients' welfare and interest. My husband and I highly recommend Debbie to others." They conclude, "Couldn't have been easier both buying and selling."
View Profile
Glenda Bolton
Glenda Bolton

REALTOR®

About us

Carpenter Realtors' Columbus office has proudly served Bartholomew County and surrounding communities with trusted real estate expertise for generations. Our experienced agents understand the local market, from historic neighborhoods to new developments and everything in between. We are dedicated to providing exceptional customer service, strategic marketing, and personalized guidance throughout every step of the buying or selling process. Supported by Carpenter Realtors' statewide network and innovative tools, we help clients make confident real estate decisions while building lasting relationships within the communities we proudly serve.

Our reviews

  5  
45 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 6.
Buyer review
Great experience!
13 days ago
Great experience!

Quincy made the whole home search experience seem uncomplicated. He is a valuable resource of local information and real estate knowledge, and has a great sense of humor. Would definitely recommend him to others for their real estate needs!

Quincy Robinson

Quincy Robinson

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Quincy did an excellent job helping us
15 days ago
Quincy did an excellent job helping us

Quincy was always available if we had a question we would get it answered right away never impatient always nice and helpful very good realtor

Quincy Robinson

Quincy Robinson

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Team!
17 days ago
Great Team!

It's pretty simple really. I decided to look for a home and a few short weeks after that I had the keys in my hand. Rusty, and his team, were extremely helpful from the first home that we looked at and through the entire process. His knowledgeable team provided excellent guidance and invaluable input. I felt very well represented throughout. Thank you, to the entire Carpenter Team!

Rusty Downey

Rusty Downey

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Quite the professional.
18 days ago
Quite the professional.

He was always alerting us on any updates as soon as they came in. Communication was top notch. Always gave us great advice on things we should do, or decisions we should make.

Rusty Downey

Rusty Downey

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Working with Rusty has been one of the best decisions we've made
about 1 month ago
Working with Rusty has been one of the best decisions we've made

Working with Rusty has been one of the best decisions we've made. This year alone, he has guided our family through buying and selling four homes, and every transaction has come with its own unique challenges. Through it all, Rusty has been knowledgeable, patient, honest, and unwavering in his commitment to looking out for our best interests.When we needed to sell the home we purchased for our daughter, Rusty stepped in and helped us navigate a difficult situation involving an unethical cash buyer. His expertise and determination helped us mitigate what could have been a much larger financial loss.A few months later, he helped us purchase our dream home. The negotiations were anything but easy, but Rusty never gave up. His professionalism, strategic approach, and persistence were instrumental in getting us across the finish line.As if that wasn't enough, he also helped us purchase the home next door for our daughter, making our dream of creating a family compound, a vision we've had for over 20 years, a reality.Now, Rusty is helping us through one of the most emotional milestones of all: selling the home where we raised our four children for the past 16 years. Having someone we trust so completely by our side during this transition has meant more than we can express.If you're looking to buy or sell a home in the Columbus area, I cannot recommend Rusty highly enough. He isn't just an outstanding realtor—he's a trusted advisor, a skilled negotiator, and someone who genuinely cares about the people he serves. We are incredibly grateful for everything he has done for our family.

Rusty Downey

Rusty Downey

  5   (2 reviews)
Show all 45 reviews
map

Our properties

Carpenter Realtors - Columbus has 38 properties for sale and sold 58 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$285,000
502 East 16th Street
Seymour IN 47274
3
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Carpenter Realtors - Columbus
SoldAug 7, 2026
$270,000
3375 Carolina St
Columbus IN 47203
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate and Carpenter Realtors - Columbus
SoldJul 30, 2026
$245,000
1341 Magnolia Drive
Greenfield IN 46140
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Carpenter Realtors - Columbus and Carpenter Realtors - Geist
SoldJul 30, 2026
$272,000
8159 S Fox Ln
Princes Lakes IN 46164
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REMAX Advanced Realty | Greenwood and Carpenter Realtors - Columbus
Show all 96 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent