Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
208 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, responsive, reliable, attentive, well-prepared, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Dedicated Realtor Who Gets Results
8 days ago
Dedicated Realtor Who Gets Results

Sara isn’t afraid of a challenge and always gets the job done! We had about six weeks to sell our home, which was in a challenging location next to a large commercial construction site. Sara developed a great plan to get our home in front of as many prospective buyers as possible. Thanks to her efforts, we had several showings, two open houses, and ultimately two offers to choose from. She’s a great communicator who genuinely cares about her clients. We couldn’t be happier with our experience and highly recommend Sara!

Sara Westrich

Sara Westrich

  5   (34 reviews)
Seller review
Great attitude
9 days ago
Great attitude

He was as quick as he could be when we had questions or concerns

Adam Montgomery

Adam Montgomery

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Jamie is very educated & informed on the real estate as well as financing.
10 days ago
Jamie is very educated & informed on the real estate as well as financing.

Jamie does a great job breaking out the details & shares info in an educational ( not condescending). I am a buyer who needs the fine details & Jamie demonstrated a commitment to educating us on entire process. She knows the Brownsburg market but the great Indy market too. This helped us put things in perspective. Jamie is also an active listener, checking for understanding. She is a pro!

Jamie Hall

Jamie Hall

  5   (37 reviews)
Seller review
Very knowledgeable
12 days ago
Very knowledgeable

Sara is a friend of the family and always knew I would use her as my agent when I would sell my house cause she is a professional, and knowledgeable and helped me through any questions I had.

Sara Westrich

Sara Westrich

  5   (34 reviews)
Buyer review
Couldn’t have asked for better!!
20 days ago
Couldn’t have asked for better!!

My wife and I are first time homebuyers. Going into the process we had questions fears and more unknowns than either of us have ever experienced in our lives to date. The only thing that I knew for certain was that we needed someone who was gonna be in our corner with our best interests at heart. Sara was an answered prayer. She fought for us, she kept the ball rolling, anytime there was a delay or a discrepancy we could text her or call her and within minutes we had an answer or she was on top of it, figuring it out for us. We love her and are so grateful for everything she’s done for us❤️

Sara Westrich

Sara Westrich

  5   (34 reviews)
Buyer review
Reba was so sweet, kind and so knowledgeable!
24 days ago
Reba was so sweet, kind and so knowledgeable!

Reba was always 5 steps ahead of us. So patient with all of our thousand questions we had on a daily basis. You ask her anything and she had the answer. We felt she went beyond what was expected of her as our agent. We would highly recommend her to everyone!

Evans Team Reba & Amy

Evans Team Reba & Amy

  4.9   (13 reviews)
Buyer review
Jamie went above and beyond in helping us find the perfect home!
26 days ago
Jamie went above and beyond in helping us find the perfect home!

Jamie was very available for showings and sent us new listings as soon as they hit the market. Her knowledge of the area and the market was excellent. She also gave great advice on different aspects of the house that most people don’t normally think of. Jamie also navigated us through terminating a deal after inspection and then guided ya through negotiations on our final purchase. I can’t recommend her enough!!! Her colleague, Lea, also went above and beyond to help when Jamie was on vacation.

Jamie Hall

Jamie Hall

  5   (37 reviews)
Buyer review
Jamie Made Buying Our Home Easy!
26 days ago
Jamie Made Buying Our Home Easy!

Jamie was absolutely fantastic to work with! From the beginning, she was responsive, knowledgeable, patient, and always willing to go the extra mile to make sure we felt comfortable and informed throughout the entire process. Loved that she was happy to chat via text whenever we needed her, so there was no playing phone tag. And she was always ready with an answer when we needed something or felt uncomfortable. Even when we had to bail on a home we initially thought we wanted, she went through extra mile to make sure we came out whole in the process. Buying a home can be stressful, but Jamie made everything feel manageable. She was always available to answer questions, gave us great advice without ever making us feel pressured, and was a strong advocate for us from the search all the way through closing. Jamie genuinely cared about finding the right home for our family, not just getting a deal done. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would recommend Jamie without hesitation to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Jamie Hall

Jamie Hall

  5   (37 reviews)
1 - 12 of 208
Carpenter Realtors -  Brownsburg
Contact Carpenter Realtors - Brownsburg
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent