Shelby County

51 real estate agents in Shelby County

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Shelby County over the past 12 months.

Sort by

Jim Cottle

5.0 (7 reviews)

Last 12 months in Shelby County

Avg. sale price $225k
Sold (as lead agent) 3
Properties for sale 0

$225k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Jerry Daniel5 months ago

Seller of 1808 Oakwood Drive, Shelbyville

Verified Review

The "Quick Sale" Specialist

The "Quick Sale" Specialist: Working with Jim was the best decision we made for our sale. They prepped our investment property, priced it perfectly, and we had multiple offers within days of the first good weather. Jim's professionalism and communication are second to none!

Accolades

ContactContact Jim

Angie Tonini-Rogers

REALTOR®

5.0 (71 reviews)

Last 12 months in Shelby County

Avg. sale price N/A
Sold (as lead agent) 1
Properties for sale 0

N/A

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Gregory C. Fernberg8 months ago

Seller of 216 Masons View Court, Shelbyville

Verified Review

Awesome agent

Angie was the best real estate agent we have ever dealt with through selling several homes. She kept us informed through the entire process. Very knowledgeable. Returned all communications very promptly.

Accolades

Price Expert

Top 20%

County Winner

Floyd County2026

County Winner

Jefferson County2026

City Winner

Louisville2026

City Winner

Louisville/Jefferson County metro government (balance)2026

City Winner

New Albany2026

ContactContact Angie

Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in Shelby County? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my neighborhood

John Groft

REALTOR® | Sales Manager

5.0 (104 reviews)

Last 12 months in Shelby County

Avg. sale price N/A
Sold (as lead agent) 1
Properties for sale 0

N/A

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Pam and Perry Bronaugh5 months ago

Buyer of 619 Village Lane, Shelbyville

Verified Review

I done business with Realtor,s, let me say Mr Groft has the others still at the starting Gate.

Mr Groft went to the Inspection where I could not. He was able give me enough information to where I was comfortable to buy the Property I was purchasing .He work very hard on commercial loan and Insurance, etc, which I have never seen an agent do. When we were negotiating price, Mr Groft saved me $10,000 Dollars. I will be using Mr Groft on other Properties in the future, because I stick with WINNERS. Sincerely, Perry & Pamela Bronaugh