From 55 reviews overall

Pamela Shumaker
American Heritage Realty Inc

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Seneca County
160 Elm Street Fostoria
We couldn't be happier with the experience of selling my mother's home. She relocated out of Ohio to live near me and the process of selling her home was smooth, stress-free and seamless. Ms. Pam was very professional, attentive and incredibly knowledgeable about the market. I was concerned about selling her home while being out of state, but Pam put those fears at ease with clear and timely communication. We felt confident and supported throughout the entire process from listing to closing. When we needed to address a few repair items at closing, she promptly connected us with an honest plumber and roofer who handled everything quickly and professionally, giving us great peace of mind. We absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a top-tier real estate agent! She truly had my mother's best interests at heart.
55 Christopher Drive Fostoria
I can not recommend Pam highly enough. Selling my elderly mothers home was emotional for her, but Pam made the process seemless and stress free. Her extensive market knowledge was evident from our first meeting. She knew exactly how to price the home and let us know if we needed to make any small updates that would give us the biggest impact. Thanks to Pams expertise, my mother had multiple offers and sold her home quickly. Beyond Pams professionalism, she was very respectful to my mother, taking time to explain every detail. I highly recommend Pam at American Heritage. She is very knowledgeable and truly cares about her clients.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Seneca County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Fostoria2026From 51 reviews overall

Shannon Conine
Shannon Conine

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Seneca County
211 Summit Street Fostoria
Selling my home with Shannon was an excellent experience from start to finish. Communication was always clear and prompt I was kept informed at every step and never left guessing. Her market knowledge and pricing strategy were spot-on, which helped generate strong interest and a great result. She handled negotiations confidently and professionally, always advocating for my best outcome. What really stood out was how organized and proactive she was, every detail was handled smoothly, which made the entire selling process feel stress-free. If you’re looking to sell your home and want someone who truly knows the market and goes above and beyond, I highly recommend Shannon.
1440 North State Route 19 Republic
At our first meeting, Shannon shared the story behind her company, including the significance of its name - Stable - a word that conveys reliability, permanence, and a place of safety and security for everyone. Stable means family, and family means love. Not only do I love that sentiment, but Shannon's commitment to our own (sometimes dysfunctional) family was truly remarkable. She didn't give up on us, she went out of her way to help us get the best possible price for our family - the home our father built for his growing family is. Shannon visited us multiple times, patiently walked us through the process, what needed to be done, and did it all with honesty, humor, and a little tough love when needed. She even bought beautiful flowers...and planted them. If you have the good fortune of working with Shannon, take it. She will take care of you - and your home - with heart. I am forever grateful, thank you, Shannon.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Seneca County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Tiffin2026From 12 reviews overall

Brittney Laird
Polter Real Estate

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Seneca County
187 Walker Street Tiffin
For a first time home buyer: Brittney is your woman! Home buying initially felt overwhelming and scary, but she really helped me feel empowered each step of the way. I felt like I had someone in my corner helping me understand all the details, answering all my questions (no matter how big or small), and giving honest feedback. A plus: she was able to break down things in a way that was easy to understand. Also, another "biggie", Brittney was able to accommodate my busy schedule from work to kids to activities, allowing me to find my perfect home on my time. Brittney truly helped make me feel at ease and educated throughout the whole process!
397 Miami Street Tiffin
Brittney came out on short notice to see the property and give us her professional advice. We decided to list the house as-is and she showed it to multiple people. She always communicated when and what the feedback was. Brittney made everything so easy! I highly recommend her service.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Seneca County2026