From 7 reviews overall

Libby Capps
Highlands Elite Real Estate LLC - McMinnvile
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Putnam County
1270 Flatt Circle Cookeville
When I was thinking about listing my childhood home I knew that I wanted and needed to work with an agent that knew me and my family. This was not just selling a house. It was selling our family home of 52 + years. Growing up in one place was a gift from our parents. Libby was the friend I turned to for the task. She was so helpful along the way. Provided advice when asked and helped me walk through decisions that had to be made. She was constantly cognizant of my needs and interests through the entire process. I could not have asked for a more dedicated realtor/friend to trust the sale of my childhood home to anyone else. Libby more than exceeded my expectations. I have closure. Our home will now become a home for a new family to make new memories. Thank you so much Libby!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Putnam County
2392 Nelson Way Cookeville
This five star review is admittedly a bit tenuous. We viewed one house, then fell in love with a house that hadn't been built yet. Eleanor was wonderful, but honestly we didn't hear from her much because all of our dealings were with the builder. Eleanor called us their "Easiest Sale."
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Putnam County
6510 Clemons Ridge Road Putnam County
Jessica is very knowledgeable about all things real estate. She was flexible with our crazy work schedules and always prompt at answering any questions or concerns, even after the process as we get our footing with first time home ownership. I could not recommend her enough.
From 50 reviews overall

Donna Baisley
Baisley Hometown Realty, LLC

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Putnam County
338 South Cedar Avenue Cookeville
I came into my deal without an agent I think it’s important to note that for the following reasons. Since I was using a VA loan there were numerous requirements to make the property suitable to pass the VA appraisal and inspection. Donna went above and beyond to see the deal through. Again, as aforementioned I did not have an agent which meant she was on double duty without compensation to address not only my concerns but ultimately the sellers. I do not believe if she did not take an active interest or diligence I would not have been able to complete the process without her. If you are a home buyer or seller, first time or tenth time, I guarantee your experience will be exceptional.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Putnam County2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Cumberland County2026