Youngstown

241 real estate agents in Youngstown

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Youngstown over the past 12 months.

Sort by

Robert O'Bryant

5.0 (21 reviews)

Last 12 months in Youngstown

Avg. sale price $172k
Sold (as lead agent) 4
Properties for sale 2

$172k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Anonymous7 months ago

Buyer of 6581 North Timberidge Drive, Youngstown

Verified Review

Rob was great!

I met Rob after experiencing 3 agents that just weren’t for us. Rob gave us exactly what we were looking for in an agent. He didn’t just unlock the door at each property, he explained plenty and gave us tips on every one. He was great!

Accolades

ContactContact Robert

Tibitha Matheney

REALTOR®

5.0 (54 reviews)

Last 12 months in Youngstown

Avg. sale price $157k
Sold (as lead agent) 13
Properties for sale 10

$157k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Gabriel Inga3 days ago

Buyer of 180 Clarencedale Avenue, Youngstown

Verified Review

Very dedicated to getting the job done

Tibitha was very kind and thoughtful all throughout the whole process. 10/10 would recommend for anybody who’s trying to purchase their first home!

Accolades

ContactContact Tibitha

Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in Youngstown? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my neighborhood

Joseph Sabatine

5.0 (15 reviews)

Last 12 months in Youngstown

Avg. sale price $274k
Sold (as lead agent) 14
Properties for sale 3

$274k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Anonymous12 months ago

Buyer of 7818 Huntington Cir, Youngstown

Verified Review

Communication and professionalism

Joe did a phenomenal job of walking us through the process of buying our new home! Was always available for questions and answers! Worked day and night to close the deal!

Accolades

County Top 5

Mahoning County2026

ContactContact Joseph

Paul Bevilacqua

Licensed Real Estate Agent | REALTOR®

5.0 (14 reviews)

Last 12 months in Youngstown

Avg. sale price $282k
Sold (as lead agent) 4
Properties for sale 3

$282k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Properties for sale

Anonymous4 months ago

Seller of 2921 Decamp Road, Youngstown

Verified Review

Great. Great communicator and kept me appraised and took care of all detail, made the process easy

Had great comparables and gave great guidance on what was needed to get house prepared and had great references for services needed to get the house ready

Bill Mazzoli5 months ago

Seller of 1562 Medford Ave, Youngstown

Verified Review

There’s no one better.

I actually bought the house through Paul 14 years ago. When it was time to sell I knew who my first call was going to be to. Above and beyond the call of duty!