Youngstown

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

243 real estate agents in Youngstown

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Youngstown over the past 12 months.

Sort by

5.0

From 20 reviews overall

Robert O'Bryant

BHHS Stouffer Realty, Inc.

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Youngstown

$172k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Youngstown

6581 North Timberidge Drive Youngstown

Verified Review

Rob was great!

I met Rob after experiencing 3 agents that just weren’t for us. Rob gave us exactly what we were looking for in an agent. He didn’t just unlock the door at each property, he explained plenty and gave us tips on every one. He was great!

3 months ago

5.0

From 50 reviews overall

Tibitha Matheney

CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Youngstown

$157k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Youngstown

2101 Cherry Hill Avenue Youngstown

Verified Review

She’s a deal maker. You can’t go wrong with her representation!

She went the extra mile for me. I had a difficult property to sell and she made it happen! She’s a deal maker!

Michael Connolly 17 days ago

5.0

From 15 reviews overall

Joseph Sabatine

BHHS Stouffer Realty, Inc.

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Youngstown

$274k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Youngstown

7818 Huntington Cir Youngstown

Verified Review

Communication and professionalism

Joe did a phenomenal job of walking us through the process of buying our new home! Was always available for questions and answers! Worked day and night to close the deal!

9 months ago

Accolades

County Top 5

ratemyagent award

Mahoning County2026

Market Report

5.0

From 10 reviews overall

Paul Bevilacqua

Coldwell Banker EvenBay Real Estate - Boardman

Trusted Agent

Price Expert

Last 12 months in Youngstown

$282k

Avg. sale price

Sold (as lead agent)

Reviews in Youngstown

2921 Decamp Road Youngstown

Verified Review

Great. Great communicator and kept me appraised and took care of all detail, made the process easy

Had great comparables and gave great guidance on what was needed to get house prepared and had great references for services needed to get the house ready

18 days ago

1562 Medford Ave Youngstown

Verified Review

There’s no one better.

I actually bought the house through Paul 14 years ago. When it was time to sell I knew who my first call was going to be to. Above and beyond the call of duty!

Bill Mazzoli about 1 month ago