

Pamela Shumaker
Principal Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 160 Elm Street, Fostoria
We couldn't be happier with the experience of selling my mother's home. She relocated out of Ohio to live near me and the process of selling her home was smooth, stress-free and seamless. Ms. Pam was very professional, attentive and incredibly knowledgeable about the market. I was concerned about selling her home while being out of state, but Pam put those fears at ease with clear and timely communication. We felt confident and supported throughout the entire process from listing to closing. When we needed to address a few repair items at closing, she promptly connected us with an honest plumber and roofer who handled everything quickly and professionally, giving us great peace of mind. We absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a top-tier real estate agent! She truly had my mother's best interests at heart.
Seller of 55 Christopher Drive, Fostoria
I can not recommend Pam highly enough. Selling my elderly mothers home was emotional for her, but Pam made the process seemless and stress free. Her extensive market knowledge was evident from our first meeting. She knew exactly how to price the home and let us know if we needed to make any small updates that would give us the biggest impact. Thanks to Pams expertise, my mother had multiple offers and sold her home quickly. Beyond Pams professionalism, she was very respectful to my mother, taking time to explain every detail. I highly recommend Pam at American Heritage. She is very knowledgeable and truly cares about her clients.
City Winner
Fostoria2026County Top 5
Seneca County2026

Brian Whitta
Principal Broker | Owner | REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 1721 North Union Street, Fostoria
Brian was incredibly helpful and professional from the start of our working relationship. He not only did a market analysis for the property for me, but also gave me helpful tips of some updates that needed to be done to the house to help with inspections and this was even before I hired him to sell the house. He helped me navigate the sale of a house that I was the trustee of in an estate and answered all of my questions along the way of this more-complex process and truly was my advocate during all the negotiations of the offers and final sale. I would not hesitate to hire Brian as my real estate agent in the past and if you chose to you will not regret it! His experience and professionalism were above and beyond all expectations!
Seller of 130 West Culbertson Street, Fostoria
I was so impressed with Brian’s suggestions for the sale of my moms house. He suggested we empty the house to make it seem larger. The pictures he took for the web site were outstanding. He posted the house on Friday and we had three offers by Sunday. My mom went to a nursing home so we needed to sell the house quickly. He sold it quickly and we received the asking price. Thank you Brian for helping us in a difficult time.


Shannon Conine
Principal Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 211 Summit Street, Fostoria
Selling my home with Shannon was an excellent experience from start to finish. Communication was always clear and prompt I was kept informed at every step and never left guessing. Her market knowledge and pricing strategy were spot-on, which helped generate strong interest and a great result. She handled negotiations confidently and professionally, always advocating for my best outcome. What really stood out was how organized and proactive she was, every detail was handled smoothly, which made the entire selling process feel stress-free. If you’re looking to sell your home and want someone who truly knows the market and goes above and beyond, I highly recommend Shannon.
County Winner
Seneca County2026City Winner
Tiffin2026
Allyson Reiter
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 220 W Tiffin St, Fostoria
Allyson was always quick to respond and kept me informed of all showings and offers. She was able to market the home in a way to bring in heavy traffic, and a quick sale. Highly recommend Allyson for all your real estate needs.