

Amanda Warner
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 26977 Valeside Lane, Olmsted Falls
We were looking for a house on the west side of Cleveland. And we looked at a lot of houses and put in several offers (lost some and rescinded a few, too)! Amanda was always helpful, offering her opinion on price, amenities and location. She pulled neighborhood comps and sent them to us promptly. We appreciated her positive attitude, quick responses, and professionalism. This was tested when the seller was always at the property (showing, inspection and walk through) and then was delayed on move out day. Amanda handled each situation with poise and grace, which we appreciated. I recommend Amanda to assist with your house purchase!
Seller of 824 Wildberry Cir, Avon Lake
Amanda is personable, professional and always available to answer any questions and was very responsive in setting up showings and open houses. She gave us great advice during the whole buying and selling process and always had our best interests at the forefront of each deal. I highly recommend her to anyone who is looking for a realtor who will go the extra mile for you and ensure a smooth process.

Rich Motts II
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale


Melody Caraballo
Licensed Real Estate Agent | REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 2910 Commonwealth Drive, Parma
Melody went above and beyond for us when we sold our home. She guided us on what we should fix or improve—and perhaps more importantly, what we shouldn’t. She was also candid about anything that could make our home more challenging to sell. And she was right! The feedback from showings confirmed the things Melody had warned us about. Knowing those things in advance made the process so much smoother because she already had a Plan B and a Plan C. She was always thinking ahead and prepared us for different scenarios rather than simply reacting when something came up. Melody also worked with other agents to make sure they understood the value of our home. She helped us know when to stand firm and when to be flexible, which made a big difference during negotiations. We sold our home quickly and above asking price! We couldn’t have asked for a better real estate agent to guide us through the process.
Seller of 9753 Prospect Road, Strongsville
I’m so glad I chose Melody to sell my home. I do wish I had used her when I purchased my new build—I had already signed the agreement before we connected. After this experience, I definitely wish had her in my corner then, too. If you’re considering a new build, talk to Melody before you ever even meet with the builder. When it came time to sell, Melody took the time to really walk through the house with us and point out the things that were worth fixing or changing to make it more marketable and help avoid issues with the loan process. She also told us what wasn’t worth fixing, which saved us a lot of time, work, and money. She spent a whole day with us getting everything ready for the pictures and listing. She noticed all the little things we probably would have overlooked. The video she made of our house was incredible, and the marketing was honestly impressive. Then came the open house. There were so many cars that it looked like the parking lot at the fairgrounds! We ended up getting $30,000 over asking and were under contract in just two days. I couldn’t believe it. We couldn’t be happier with the outcome. She worked hard for us, gave us honest advice, and knew where our time and money were best spent. After this experience, I would absolutely have Melody represent me on both the buying and selling side next time.
Buyer of 9812 Vienna Drive, Parma
Melody is hands-down one of the best in the industry! I have worked with multiple agents over the years, and her personal "concierge" style of service exceeded expectations I didn't even know I had! Her communication with us was always same day if not immediate, and was very clear in her responses. She showed us houses right away (mostly same day), and was genuinely excited for our family to find a new home which was so refreshing! She cared about our needs/wants and put our interests front and center. She also wasn't afraid to let us know about potential problems of a house, even if I initially loved it. She was honest with us about everything, and that put my husband and myself at ease knowing we can trust that she was telling us the truth about everything. Instead of feeling overwhelmed, scared and confused about what to do next, Melody made our house hunting fun, laid-back and exciting! We could rest easy and focus 100% on finding the perfect home for our family, knowing she had everything covered. Lender? Check. Local market knowledge? Check. Negotiation skills, home knowledge, inspection requirements? Check Check Check! Melody worked with us so efficiently that we were able to find a home and have an offer accepted just days after we started our search! We were so impressed, we will be using her as our listing agent to sell our old home! We truly appreciate how simple and enjoyable she made the entire process, and highly recommend her for all your real estate needs!


Jeff Worthington
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 3674 Fenn Road, Medina
We had an outstanding experience working with Pam & Jeff Worthington of Cutler Real Estate in selling our home in Medina. From the very beginning, they were professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly dedicated. Our home was marketed beautifully, shown multiple times, and included an open house that generated strong interest from many potential buyers. Jeff was especially helpful in guiding us through questions about our property, setting a competitive and realistic price, and navigating what can be a difficult market. He was always responsive, patient, and reassuring, which gave us great confidence throughout the entire process. Thanks to their expertise and hard work, we were able to close at asking price in under 60 days. We couldn’t be happier with the results and would highly recommend Pam & Jeff Worthington to anyone looking for a trustworthy, knowledgeable, and effective real estate team in the Northeast Ohio area.