Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43316
139 East South Street Carey
This is the 2nd home I've purchased while working with Allyson. She's always quick to respond to any questions and she's always been on-time for showings. I look forward to my next house purchase and will definitely contact Allyson, when that time comes.
From 90 reviews overall

Heidi Nuhfer
Key Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43316
522 West Front Street Findlay
I watched YouTube videos on how to pick a realtor. Heidi met all the suggestions on what to look for. She had a manageable number of houses for sell close to my houses price range, which allowed me to get the attention I wanted (answering questions timely, helping provide guidance when needed) and indicated to me that she understood who our targeted buyer would be. She had comparable properties and made a suggested price for the house that she could back up with reasons for pricing it the way she did. And her sell history indicated to me she sold previous house for at asking price or above asking price a majority of the time and typically did not have to lower the house price to get it moving. These reasons plus the smart suggestions she made for final touches made me confident I had picked the right realtor and getting the offer that lead to closing in 4 days and 4 hours proved it.
533 Hull Avenue Findlay
Heidi was great at communicating and keeping us informed. She never made us feel stupid for asking questions and made sure we knew what we were getting into. Also, she was very professional and was great for our first time buying a home.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Ohio2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Hancock County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Findlay2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43316
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 43316
222 Grove Street Bluffton
NIcki is especially professional in that she she is very knowledgeable about how to negotiate the selling of your home and is creative with marketing by using social media and/or in person via open houses. Having never sold a home before, Nicki was always kind and patient with any questions we had and thorough with her answers. She was always prompt to return a call if she had been unavailable at the time. Overall, we were pleased and appreciative of all Nicki did to assist us with selling our home.
135 Grove Street Bluffton
This summer we decided it was time for our family to make a big change, and everyday I am so grateful it was Nicki who answered my Zillow request to view the home I am now writing this from! She immediately responded, was quick to schedule a tour plus a few other homes. When we decided to put an offer on our new home we still had to get our previous home ready to sell; our initial offer wasn't accepted, so we got our house ready to list in hopes we could get it under contract quickly. First, we tried selling it on our own, and even though we had not listed it with Nicki, she was still intentional to check in regularly to see how the FSBO was going. After a few weeks (and tears...) of showing our house with no luck, we decided to list our home with Nicki, and it was the best decision we made. By listing with her we were able to negotiate a new offer on our new home, have our previous home under contract within the set closing window, negotiate a 2 week closing on our previous home, manage home inspections and lender requirements - and she handled every text, email and phone call for both properties. Her help/knowledge with negotiating offers was probably the most eye-opening and valuable piece for us - we would have left money on the table and possibly lost out on our current home without her guidance. I can't put a price on the amount of stress she off-loaded for us during an already difficult season; her personal and professional knowledge she shared with me was invaluable. She truly was an answer to prayer. I can't say enough great things about Nicki and I can't wait to recommend her to everyone I know looking to buy or sell!