

Molly A Mosley
REALTOR® | Licensed Real Estate Agent | Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 573 Dunkle Road, Circleville
We truly cannot say enough amazing things about working with Molly. Buying a home is stressful enough, but we were purchasing completely out of state while moving from Florida back to Ohio, and Molly made the entire process feel effortless. We had to rely heavily on her judgment, and she went above and beyond in every way possible. She walked through homes for us, gave honest feedback, paid attention to every detail, and ultimately helped us confidently choose the perfect house for our family — without us even being there in person. That level of trust says everything. Her communication was outstanding, her knowledge of the market was invaluable, and she truly treated the process as if she were helping her own family find the right home. At every step she advocated for us, guided us, and made sure we felt comfortable with every decision. Because of Molly’s dedication and professionalism, what could have been a very stressful cross-state move turned into an exciting and smooth experience. We are incredibly grateful for her and would recommend her 1000 times over to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares and delivers true 5-star service. We feel so lucky Molly was on our side through this journey.
County Top 5
Pickaway County2026City Winner
Circleville2026Dawn Hayes
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 461 North Court Street, Circleville
From start to finish throughout the entire process dawn has exceeded our expectations. Dawn has literally handled every situation in a timely manner with such professionalism. Definitely gonna use her in the future.
Seller of 566 Willow Lane, Circleville
Dawn is the best of the best in the real estate business. I have bought and sold multiple properties with her, and each time she makes the process nothing but simple and stress free for us by providing frequent communication and a strong knowledge of the real estate market. She will drop what she is doing at any moment to take us to tour a property, and she goes above and beyond to speak with us at any hour of the day when we have questions or concerns. She is not just an agent, she is an asset and truly a part of our team at Cedar Pines. We would not be able to do what we do if it were not for Dawn and her amazing work! Anyone would be lucky to work with her.
Seller of 17284 Little Walnut Road, Circleville
IT was a pleasure working with Dawn Hayes. She is very dedicated and knowledgeable on selling my property. She sold it in a short time and got me a lot more money than I was asking for. I highly recommend her for your realtor. I give her an +A plus

Holli Jones
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 7865 Pleasantville Road Northeast, Thornville
As soon as we connected with Holli she set up a day for us to meet in person to get to know my wife and I and what we were looking for in a house. She was very quick to respond to text and calls. Kept me in the loop with everything going on as far as time line and the different processes taking place. I will definitely being giving her name out to anyone looking to buy or sale.
Seller of 235 Tarkiln Road Southeast, Lancaster
Working with Holli was a great experience. She is competent, very easy to communicate with, and always had our back. Holli made the entire process, start to finish, seamless. We told her we wanted to sell our house, she made it happen. Couldn't have been a better experience!

Deborah Blowers
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 7883 Otterbein Trail Northwest, Lancaster
Deb was our friend - first - and a wonderful friend, too. It was that friendship that opened the door to her being our realtor. She was sensitive to our friendship, and really sought what was best for us the whole way through. Her spirit is right and her sense of real estate is on target. We were so pleased to be able to work with her and thankful for all of her help! It was a long search, but when it finally happened - we were ALL thankful and excited.
Buyer of 7883 Otterbein Trail Northwest, Lancaster
Deb was wonderful to work with. She truly got to know us and what we were looking for. The regular email with homes in our area was helpful, but she also was hands on helping us find the right home and neighborhood for our family. She was also very patient with us and available to help us view homes in a timely manner. She’s not pushy at all- but very helpful and informative. So thankful for her work with us but also her friendship.