
(16 reviews)
Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 7246 Applewood Drive, Plain City
Jorie Close helped us find our dream home and was there every step of the way. We are first time home owners and she answered all of our questions, and I mean ALL of them. She has a very quick response time and is very professional. I highly recommend her! We couldn’t have done it without Jorie.

(57 reviews)



Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(82 reviews)



Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 7652 North Goodrich Square, New Albany
Jeff is so knowledgeable and experienced. He gave us great advice and found us the perfect house in German Village before it even hit the market. Jeff’s connections and knowledge are invaluable, particularly if you are selling or buying in German Village.
Buyer of 204 Jackson Street, Columbus
I haven't bought a home in decades. And, this transaction was particularly personal. Jeff guided me through every step. He was smart, patient and always had time to answer every one of my questions. When it comes to German Village, there is simply no one who knows the market better. I am grateful to have had the very best agent at my side for this entire process.

(17 reviews)

Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 6817 Oliver Way, Dublin
Neil is very knowledgable about the Dublin area for home buying. He helped us by telling us about "right size" vs "downsize". That helped us decide which home would be right for us, even thought it may not have been smaller!
Buyer of 6886 Lakebrook Boulevard, Columbus
Was extremely helpful in making the right decision with my home purchase. I had been looking in a particular area for a few years without any luck. Neil made sure that we found the right home for me. His knowledge of the market is unmatched, and he has all the right insights that any buyer or seller would be looking for. His attention to detail, his responsiveness and his insight is something that is seemingly more and more rare in today's market. You are in the best hands with the Mathias Team! I cannot recommend the team enough!
National Top 100
United States2026
(0 reviews)
Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

(163 reviews)

Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 5011 Smothers Road, Westerville
Tiffany Bafford is what I think all Real Estate Agents should be. She took a very unique property like ours and found the right solution. She brought in the right partners and gave us many options to help US make the right decision for our personal situation. That was an auction. If you know me I am not a risk taker! This felt risky! That said she brought us the experts to tell us why it was a GOOD RISK! She struck while the iron was hot and the timing was good. We put it on the market and went through the pain staking steps to prep our house of 14 year and get it ready to show. She also took us to see a few houses. At this time if you did not make and offer at the point of seeing the house you lost the opportunity. She found us a great home in the right community that kept us in the same school district and met our unique needs. She suggested a financing person that could talk us though selling an buying a house in this crazy market. He was great. We have now been in our new place for 3 months. We sold prior to the auction and did not have to under go the stress of the actual auction. I believe this was due to Tiffany's Marketing and connections in the market with other realtors! She was able to vet out the right interest and find us the right buyer. She navigated this like a pro and stepped us through it. I was a nervous wreck. This is not a reflection of Tiffany's support it is just my personality on big life decisions and purchases. Tiff got us through it and put us in a great spot. I will be forever grateful for her professionalism and support. In my opinion she was able to thread the needle on the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. I don't easily endorse sales people especially Realtors!!! Tiffany Bafford has my full endorsement!!! She is the gold standard for what a great realtor should be!
Buyer of 812 West North Street, Hebron
We worked with Tiffany as a first time homebuyer. In our initial meeting she reviewed the whole process, documents we would see and made it very clear she had our best interest in mind. We created an easy working relationship with a text group chat and always answered each and every question we had clearly and quickly. The whole process was generally overwhelming but Tiffany made it easy and manageable. She helped us to understand that what we were looking for was highly sought after by others and therefore we had to move fast. She was great at guiding us through making an offer and what the offer and other details should be. She was great at working with the sellers and their agent to make a deal that was fruitful for all parties.
State Top 3
Ohio2026National Top 100
United States2026Region Top 10
Midwest Region2026
(4 reviews)
Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 171 Clinton Heights Avenue, Columbus
John made the process so much easier. I wanted a sewer line inspection done and the company I hired never showed up. He found someone to come out immediately and conducted the inspection on my behalf. Found a local mowing service and had a list of contacts for other jobs. Highly recommend him!

(20 reviews)


Reviews in 43064
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 387 West 2nd Avenue, Columbus
Stephen was fun and serious to work with on selling our home. He was always available to answer questions and make pertinent suggestions. And at the crux of deal he was savvy and sensible. Greatly appreciate him! Thank you, Stephen!
Seller of 674 Park Street, Columbus
Jim Meyer helped us sell our condo in the Short North on Goodale Park. He went above and beyond in meeting with other agents who were showing the property so he could explain the parking and show them the private gym. He thoroughly knows the neighborhood and community, we would highly recommend working with him for any of your real estate needs!
Buyer of 387 West 2nd Avenue, Columbus
While buying my first home, I was not represented by a buyer’s agent. Stephen was the seller’s agent, but he was so kind, helpful, and patient with me throughout the whole purchase process. Any questions I had, he was quick to respond. When the sale went through, I felt genuinely supported and that he was happy for me. If/when I go to sell my property, Stephen will be my first phone call!
National Top 100
United States2026