Back NY, 12458

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

18 real estate agents in NY, 12458

Sorted by most reviews for agents in 12458 over the past 12 months.
View Mary Sheeley's profile
5.0

From 22 reviews overall

Mary Sheeley

Mary Sheeley

Stoeckeler Real Estate Service

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in 12458

$325k

Avg. sale price

3

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12458

Professional, patient, and a pleasure to work with throughout our home purchase

We worked with Mary on the purchase of our vacation home in Greenfield Park, NY, and had a very positive experience. From our first conversation to the closing day, Mary was professional, patient, and dedicated to helping us make the right decision. She is extremely knowledgeable about the local market and provided honest, practical guidance at every step. What we appreciated most was her responsiveness and calm approach. Mary was always available to answer questions, provide updates, and keep the process moving forward, even when unexpected challenges came up. Mary handled negotiations with care and integrity, ensuring that communication between all parties remained clear and constructive. Her experience and steady guidance gave us confidence throughout what can easily be a stressful process. We truly value her professionalism, kindness, and deep understanding of the region. If you’re looking for someone who knows the Hudson Valley and Catskills markets and genuinely puts her clients’ interests first, we highly recommend working with Mary.

6 months ago
Email
View Robin Kelly's profile
N/A

From 0 reviews overall

Robin Kelly

Robin Kelly

Last 12 months in 12458

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12458

No reviews in 12458 yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Email
View Danielle Moore's profile
5.0

From 1 review overall

Danielle Moore

Danielle Moore

Howard Hanna Rand Realty

Last 12 months in 12458

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12458

I've have been working with Danielle on finding...

I've have been working with Danielle on finding a house and she has been amazing!!! Very patient and taking the time to help me find the property that is just right for me! She responds to properties I ask her about and she sends me properties to look at based on what I've told her I'm looking for! She puts the time and effort in and is very professional and personable! She gets back to me right away and has no problem taking me to see the same house more than once. I would highly recommend her!!!

Bonnie Rule almost 7 years ago
Email
View Philip Szumlaski's profile
5.0

From 3 reviews overall

Philip Szumlaski

Philip Szumlaski

Keller Williams Realty

Last 12 months in 12458

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

0

Reviews in 12458

Extraordinary

Philip Szumlaski is a very supportive, professional, friendly and proactive. He will lead you all the way, from providing you with a list of available homes for sale, pre-approval, schedule for you to see the properties, answer all the questions you may have. Philip will find what you want, according to your needs and budget. Even after the closing day, he will contact you to see how are you doing. We do highly recommend Philip because he cares and loves what he does. Thanks so much!!!

Angel & Mercy Portalatin about 4 years ago
Email
1 - 9 of 18

View nearby Suburbs

© 2026 RateMyAgent