Back NY, 11971

34 real estate agents in NY, 11971

Sorted by most reviews for agents in 11971 over the past 12 months.
View Thomas McCarthy's profileThomas McCarthy

Thomas McCarthy

4.9 (17 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price $839k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 5
  • Properties for sale 9
Dillaye Kruseabout 6 years ago

Seller of 585 Peconic Lane, Peconic

I was advised immediately of the best way to present the property and he also advised us the best wa

I was advised immediately of the best way to present the property and he also advised us the best way to get the house cleaned up and ready to show. By how fast the sale was, he advised quite correctly.

Accolades

Contact
View Nicholas Planamento's profileNicholas Planamento

Nicholas Planamento

5.0 (1 review)
  • Avg. sale price $1.2m
  • Sold (as lead agent) 5
  • Properties for sale 2
Anonymousabout 1 year ago

Seller of 318 5th Avenue, Greenport

Nicholas is knowledgeable and professional. He responded to concerns ASAP.

Nicholas was always available to help the seller with any concerns and would immediately step in to solve any problems that arose. His knowledge of the local real estate market is vast and he knows what buyer and seller need to make the deal happen. His manner with client and buyer alike is pleasant and supportive. He was highly professional from listing until closing.

Accolades

Contact
Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in 11971? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my neighborhood
View Timothy O'Keefe's profileTimothy O'Keefe

Timothy O'Keefe

N/A
  • Avg. sale price $730k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 4
  • Properties for sale 0

No reviews in 11971 yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

Contact
View Mariah Mills' profileMariah Mills

Mariah Mills

5.0 (1 review)
  • Avg. sale price $1.8m
  • Sold (as lead agent) 3
  • Properties for sale 3
jreeves335almost 6 years ago

Seller of 1089 Main Road, Aquebogue

Even before my husband and I met Mariah, we knew she would be the right agent for us just from her c

Even before my husband and I met Mariah, we knew she would be the right agent for us just from her carefully curated social media presence. Once we did meet her, it solidified our instincts. She was professional, honest and laid out a game plan as to how she would sell our house. From pricing to closing, Mariah always made herself available via email and text, maintained Covid-19 protocols and made what can sometimes be a harrowing experience, an absolute pleasure. Thrilled to say we accepted a full-ask offer and went into contract within three days thanks to her hustle. If you’re looking for an amazing real estate agent on the North Fork, look no further than Mariah Mills. You can thank me later!

Accolades

Contact
1 - 9 of 34

View nearby Suburbs

© 2026 RateMyAgent