From 93 reviews overall

Freeman Jeff Smith
Coldwell Banker Realty - Clinton Office

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08848
10 Kelsey Farm Road Milford
Jeff went out of his way to work with my lawyer to resolve a very unusual easement issue. He also was able to put me in contact with different people to complete work that needed to be done to the house before selling. It seems Jeff knows everyone and was able to get various contractors to come on short notice and at fair prices. I would highly recommend Jeff and I’m so glad I chose him to be my agent.
198 Rick Road Milford
We had an excellent experience with Jeff. Jeff guided us throughout the entire selling cycle. We had some issues to resolve after the home inspection. Jeff helped us with that as well. He made selling our home more pleasant and less stressful.
15 Kelsey Farm Road Milford
Truly Jeff gives a complete comprehensive service as a sellers agent. Prompt communication great explanations … if you live in Hunterdon and choose a different agent all I can say is … good luck. Choose Jeff and listen to what he tells you and you’ll get it sold.
State Winner
ratemyagent award
New Jersey2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Hunterdon County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Milford2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Mid-Atlantic Region2026From 61 reviews overall

Mary Malone
Coldwell Banker Realty - Flemington Office

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08848
689 Riegelsville-Milford Road Milford
You would be hard pressed to find another agent with Mary's level of expertise in our area. I have a marketing background and I can say that Mary is really skilled at identifying and articulating each home's unique selling proposition, and one that is going to appeal to the target market. This is especially important when the target is a niche market and not "everyone". We put our house on the market at a not-so-great time of year (January, which was unusually cold and snowy) and had a solid offer in less than a week, which definitely exceeded our expectations! She also communicated very clearly throughout the process, which was especially helpful because this was the first time we had sold a home. She let us know what was and was not worth spending time and money on as it related to staging the home for sale, and saved us time and money. Selling a home for the first time is a stressful experience but I could rest easy knowing I was in such good hands. I highly recommend Mary and her team!
236 Stamets Road Milford
Wow what a wonderful experience we had with helping our son purchase his first home. Mary is amazing, she communicates and explains everything you need to know along with being very quick and timely. Mary is always available for your questions and goes the extra mile to help if you need something. The process was so easy, Mary helped us every step of the way and her supporting staff/recommendations were all fantastic. We could not of asked for a better experience!
236 Stamets Road Milford
We cannot recommend Mary enough! Mary provided excellent service from start to finish throughout our home buying process. She was always available, incredibly responsive, and truly cared about finding the perfect fit for us. As first-time homebuyers, her knowledge, professionalism, and expertise made us feel confident and at ease every step of the way. What really set Mary apart was how seamlessly she coordinated with her internal team at the Luxe Service Group and trusted network of local professionals, including lawyers, inspectors, and mortgage advisors. Her strong relationships ensured everything moved efficiently and without stress. We are incredibly grateful for her support and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home. Working with Mary was hands down the best decision we made and we are so grateful to have had her by our side for such an important milestone!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Hunterdon County2026From 84 reviews overall

Nicole Yard
Coldwell Banker Realty - Clinton Office
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08848
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here