From 157 reviews overall

Deborah Citarella
Coldwell Banker Realty - Westfield East Office

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 07852
1796 Mountain Avenue Union County
My fiancé and I had a fantastic experience working with Deborah to sell our home. She is extremely knowledgeable about the market and guided us confidently through every step of the process. Deborah was always communicative and responsive and made sure we felt informed and supported from start to finish. She also brought a great sense of humor and genuine kindness to what can be a stressful experience, which made working with her a pleasure. Her hard work and dedication truly showed in the successful and quick sale of our home. We highly recommend Deborah to anyone looking for an outstanding realtor.
2039 Church Street Union County
First I’d like to state that I’m not personal friends with Deborah Citarella, or am affiliated with her or Coldwell Banker in any way. I am merely someone who was fortunate enough to choose Deborah as our realtor to handle the sale of my mother’s home after she passed away. I was the executor of the estate living out-of-state 4 hours away, but Deborah quickly proved herself as an extremely competent realtor who could be entrusted to handle every aspect of the listing and sale process. My siblings and I met with a few realtors before deciding to go with Deborah, and within a few minutes of our initial meeting, we knew she was the agent to list the home with.She met with us at the house fully prepared with effective sales strategies. She also had with her a complete packet of research of the current market value of my mom’s house, as well as every single house in a 2-block radius of my mom’s house. She provided us with similar comps of several other homes in the same town. She is extremely knowledgeable of the real estate market in the county. She showed up at our initial meeting ready to work for us – even before we decided to go with her. This woman exuded confidence, experience and the ability to make things happen. She offered invaluable advice, had excellent resources, has an excellent report with others in the real estate market field (home inspector, home appraiser, contractors, town hall, mortgage lender, real estate attorney, etc.) which proved to be a huge asset.It was a 5 star experience working with Deborah Citarella. Choosing to work with her was the best decision we made when selling my mother’s home. Deborah was great to work with and went above and beyond for us. The house sold for over the listing price, and in a very short time frame.If you're looking for a professional, experienced, knowledgeable real estate agent who is sharp, trustworthy, and truly exceptional at what they do, I highly recommend Deborah. She is absolutely phenomenal!
23 Oak Ridge Union County
My experience working with Deborah was exceptional from start to finish. Her command of the local market was evident in every recommendation she made, from pricing strategy to positioning the home for prospective buyers. Deborah communicated with precision, consistency and genuine care throughout the process, and her professional judgment repeatedly proved correct as we moved from listing through closing. She anticipated issues before they emerged, guided me and my family through each decision with clarity, and ensured that every detail was handled with a level of thoroughness that significantly reduced the stress of selling a home. Deborah’s negotiation skills were particularly impressive. She maintained a steady focus on protecting my interests while fostering a productive and respectful dialogue with all parties involved. What stood out most was her unwavering dedication. She was present, engaged, and fully committed at every stage. I always felt supported and informed, and her integrity made it easy to place full trust in her recommendations. I would strongly endorse Deborah to anyone who wants a highly knowledgeable, communicative and genuinely professional real estate partner.
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Union County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Westfield2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 07852
From 2 reviews overall
CHRISTOPHER CAFARO
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage - Chester
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 07852
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 07852
5 Arielle Way Sussex County
Catherine Kut is an exceptional knowledgeable professional caring realtor. We are extremely pleased to have Catherine Kut as our realtor. The process from listing our home with the exceptional advertising and professional pictures and drone footage to the process of our closing was impressive. Catherine guided us answered all our questions and listed/closed our home in a timely fashion. We highly recommend Catherine Kut !