

Sarah Riggen
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 3105 E Banta Rd, Indianapolis
Sarah was referred to us by a family member. Our last experience in real estate was not one to write home about. For that reason, I was hesitant about the whole process. That said, Sarah went above and beyond for us. One thing I really enjoyed was that she quickly picked up on how I like to communicate. I prefer not to email, and I'm also not fond of texting because things can get lost in translation. She spent all the time we needed on the phone answering our questions, adjusting open house dates, and doing a multitude of other things. I've had people ask me before, Sarah, who we used as a real estate agent. Sadly, I couldn't even remember that agent's name. Now, if I get that question, I can say with great enthusiasm that we used Sarah Riggen at Keller Williams Realty. It's the highest compliment I can provide, and I am happy to offer it on behalf of Sarah!


Shelli Anderson
REALTOR® | Attorney
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 649 Nelson Drive, Mooresville
We accidentally came across Shelli from realtor.com and I’m sure glad we got lucky enough to have her on our side. Working with Shelli was such an amazing experience from start to finish. Shelli had so much patience with us, she stayed dedicated to finding us the perfect home, and even with how busy she was, we always felt like a top priority. She even went as far as working on her vacation for us, which should tell you how hard she is willing to work for her clients. She even went as far as finding other trusted resources for us, like mortgage companies, etc who also turned out to be great. Shelli turned every stressful pop up into a breeze. Realtor aside, Shelli is truly an amazing person to even know. She is such a sweet, genuine, and caring person. Even after going our separate ways, she still shows so much support and care for our family. I will recommend Shelli for the rest of my life. She is truly the person you should put all your trust into and have on your side, she won’t let you down. Even if I wanted to, there’s isn’t a single bad thing I could possible put about her or the experience she provided. Thank you, Shelli again for being such an amazing person to work with. We will always be grateful for you!
Buyer of 6726 Colleens Way, Indianapolis
My husband and I bought our first house at 23 years old, with Shelli's help. There was so much we didn't know but Shelli always took the time to explain all the steps of the process, and gave us honest and realistic possible outcomes when we were making decisions. We were grateful for her outgoing personality and both her knowledge & experience in real estate. We feel that she played a huge role in us ending up in the right house for the right price!
State Top 10
Indiana2026
Jason Gatewood
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Jamie Johann
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here