From 171 reviews overall

Angela Mae Schlagel 208HomePros
Homes of Idaho

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 83644
8495 Silverwood Way Middleton
Angela was professional & fun from the moment we met her. She had a sixth sense, she could tell when one of us was feeling anxious or frustrated or... Her assurances were heartfelt and honest when she would offer a word or encouragement. She was straight up with us about her advice,we'd openly discuss our options and we decided which route to go; change prices, pre -inspection, landscaping, change furnishings etc. We were selling in a tough market and she got it done for us with the least intrusions I've had selling.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Idaho2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Ada County2026From 5 reviews overall

Anne Pedracini Gentry
John L Scott Boise
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 83644
8148 West Marcum Court Boise City
Anne was the best person to help me find a home. She was patient and knowledgeable and kept me up to date on everything that was going on right when it was happening. Anne was accessible for my questions and concerns at anytime of the day, any time of the week. She took the time to find answers for me and explain every situation that I couldn’t understand on my own. The house I was selling had quite a few mishaps- out of both my and Anne’s control- and I am so glad I had Anne to help me through that process. She went to bat for me and we ended up in the best possible outcome. Anne goes above and beyond for her people and I couldn’t be anymore appreciative or thankful.
From 106 reviews overall
Paul Heim
Silvercreek Realty Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 83644
8140 W Kingsbury Dr Middleton
Paul went above and beyond throughout our entire home-buying process. He spent countless hours driving us around to view properties and really took the time to understand what we were looking for. He even took the time to get to know our family — memorizing all seven of our kids’ names — which really showed how much he cared about helping us find the right home, not just any home. His deep knowledge of the local areas helped us narrow things down quickly and confidently. He stayed on top of every timeline, contingency, and negotiation, keeping us informed every step of the way. When we couldn’t be there in person, Paul drove to properties and video called us so we didn’t miss a thing. He even researched specific property details like what types of animals were allowed — something especially important to us. Even after closing, Paul continued to go the extra mile. He personally drove to the property to pick up keys and make sure the home was secure while we were still out of state. If you’re looking for a real estate agent who truly cares, is incredibly knowledgeable, and goes well beyond what’s expected, Paul is the one you want on your side.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Idaho2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Mountain Region2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Boise County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Robie Creek2026From 15 reviews overall

Michelle Welch
John L Scott Boise
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 83644
2114 West Gelding Street Middleton
Our experience felt very hands-off. After the initial pitch, we were set up on an automated email list and ended up finding most of the homes ourselves. Communication was minimal, which made planning a weekend trip from out of state stressful—we often didn’t know what showings were scheduled until last minute. When we came to town, she showed us a few houses, then had to leave for a personal commitment and gave us builder codes to tour homes on our own. We found a new build we liked, she submitted the offer, and we closed without any negotiation. After that, there was little follow-up, just a card asking for referrals. It would have been nice to feel more supported, especially being out-of-state buyers who relied heavily on our agent’s guidance.