From 35 reviews overall

Amanda Justus
Coldwell Banker Realty - Clearwater / Palm Harbor

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33782
7846 Cayuga Dr New Port Richey East
Working with Amanda has been an exceptional experience from start to finish. We stayed in touch on and off for two years, and throughout that entire time she remained consistent, responsive, and fully committed — even when I wasn’t actively searching. That level of dedication is rare. When I decided this spring that it was time to move forward with buying a home, Amanda immediately shifted into high gear. She handled every step with precision and professionalism, staying ahead of potential issues and keeping the entire process organized and efficient. Her communication was clear, her guidance was solid, and her follow‑through was flawless. What stood out most was her integrity. She never pushed, never rushed, and never treated the process like a transaction. She approached it like a partnership — one built on trust, competence, and genuine care for the outcome. If you’re looking for a realtor who is reliable, knowledgeable, and truly committed to doing the job right, Amanda is exactly who you want in your corner.
1884 San Mateo Drive Dunedin
I chose Amanda for her market knowledge and her presentation during our first meeting. She came prepared to show me how she presents homes to sell and what to expect during the process. I was especially impressed with the booklet she compiles for interested buyers, which helps answer many questions and provides buyers with something to take away at an Open House. I believe that the marketing piece was a big help in the quick sale of my home. I was a first-time home seller and had a lot of questions. She answered all of them knowledgeably which helped me make the right decisions about the sales process. Amanda is calm and methodical. She was so easy to work with, and available to answer questions and "take care of business" from start to finish. I wasn't pushed to an assistant; she worked with me the entire time. I appreciated that type of personal service. Another important fact I considered was that I researched how many homes Amanda sold in the past year. This is not a part time job, nor is she just starting out. She knows the business and that is what I was looking for in a realtor. Knowledge and experience. I got that 100 percent and am very happy that I chose her as my agent.
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Palm Harbor2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33782
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33782
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33782
607 Fox Hills Drive Sun City Center
She was able to answer all of our questions and gave us the information needed to make a final decision. She showed us a variety of houses, so we could make sure our needs were met. She also helped us with getting utilities and insurance information.
16114 Cape Coral Dr Sun City Center
Stacey learned quickly what we were looking for in a home. We traveled from GA into FL several times to view homes that Stacey had FaceTime with us . She is patient , dependable and ensures her client is satisfied. The market was challenging during our search. Stacey would make multiple calls to follow up with other agents regarding a home that we were interested in purchasing. She continuously gave us updates regarding the market conditions in the area and advised us. I would recommend Stacey to any of my friends and family. She is focused on finding her clients the perfect home.
1738 Bonita Bluff Ct Ruskin
Stacey helped me with buying a home. It took several offers on a few properties but ultimately she found me the perfect home. She assisted in each step along the way and gave me an awesome closing gift! . She’s now helping me sell another home. I highly recommend her for any and all real estate needs.