185 real estate agents in Peyton

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Peyton over the past 12 months.
View Monica Shea's profileMonica Shea

Monica Shea

5.0 (263 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Benjamin Davis8 months ago

Seller of 9701 Beryl Dr, Peyton

So Much More Than a Realtor, Monica Quickly Became a Trusted Family Friend

Working with Monica Shea has been an exceptional experience in every way. Her market knowledge is second to none—she understands the trends, the timing, and the strategy needed to make confident decisions whether you’re buying or selling. We’ve had the privilege of working with her as both, and each time she guided us with clarity, patience, and insight. Her communication is outstanding; she keeps you informed at every step and makes the entire process feel smooth and manageable. Her professionalism is truly unmatched. But what sets Monica apart is who she is as a person. She has supported our family in so many ways over the years, far beyond the scope of real estate. She’s more than a realtor; she’s someone you can trust, rely on, and genuinely call a friend. We’re grateful for her expertise, her heart, and the lasting relationship we’ve built with her.

Video

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert
Top 20%
Top 20%

State Top 10

Colorado2026

County Top 5

El Paso County2026

National Top 100

United States2026

Region Top 20

Mountain Region2026

City Winner

Gleneagle2026

City Winner

Monument2026
Contact
View David Almquist's profileDavid Almquist

David Almquist

5.0 (17 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Jennifer Booneover 1 year ago

Buyer of 14675 Teleo Court, Peyton

Fantastic agent to work with

We had the pleasure of working with Dave to purchase a home while relocating to Colorado. Dave is a one of a kind agent! Zero pressure, fantastic communication and dedication. He is highly knowledgeable of the market and as a licensed realtor and appraiser, you can rest assured you are making a sound decision after reviewing the CMAs he provides. His flexibility for showings and communication is second to none, and talking with him is like talking with an old friend. The entire process (with one of us being across the country) was as smooth and painless as possible, and Dave’s genuine enthusiasm and personality was truly refreshing! Highly recommend using Dave for any buying or selling needs if you want a truly one of a kind agent!

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert
Top 20%
Top 20%
Contact
Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in Peyton? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my city
View Cindy K Harkins' profileCindy K Harkins

Cindy K Harkins

5.0 (24 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 1
  • Properties for sale 0
Anonymousabout 1 year ago

Buyer of 4950 Slocum Lane, Peyton

Cindy helped me find my Little Piece of Heaven

I recently purchased a home with the help of Cindy Harkins, and I couldn’t be more pleased with the experience. From start to finish, she was professional, knowledgeable, and truly had my best interests in mind. I ended up getting an amazing home in the area I’d been looking for for months. The entire transaction went smoothly overall. Even when we faced an unexpected delay with the closing, Cindy handled the situation with calm and confidence. She kept me informed every step of the way and helped navigate the process so that everything stayed on track. I always felt supported and well-advised. If you’re looking for someone who is responsive, experienced, and genuinely invested in your success, I highly recommend Cindy!

Accolades

Contact
View Don Stull's profileDon Stull

Don Stull

5.0 (15 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price N/A
  • Sold (as lead agent) 0
  • Properties for sale 0
Manny and Carmel Melendezabout 2 years ago

Seller of 7820 Midnight Rd, Peyton

Let's do this again!

I say let's do this again because we have LOVED working with Don! His experience shows in every step of the process. He was patient with us in the purchasing of 2 homes and the selling of one. His knowledge was a huge confidence booster when we didn't fully understand moments. It's not often that you can feel personally connected with a realtor but Don truly cares about you. I have and would easily buy another home with Don. He's the best!

Accolades

Contact
19 - 27 of 185

Zip codes in Peyton

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent