Back Castle Pines

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

140 real estate agents in Castle Pines

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Castle Pines over the past 12 months.
View Nicole Faulk's profile
5.0

From 26 reviews overall

Nicole Faulk

Nicole Faulk

Price Expert

Last 12 months in Castle Pines

N/A

Avg. sale price

2

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Castle Pines

Smoothest Transcation We've Ever Had!

From start to finish, Nicole has an attention to detail that truly goes unmatched. Her professionalism and knowledge is something that even a seasoned home buyer would benefit from. We stumbled into an open house, fell in love, made a call to Nicole, and she took off running trying to get the deal done before another buyer could secure the property within 24 hours. What made this process even easier for all was the relationship Nicole formed with the other agent, such a partnership that truly made the process seamless. Even details that wouldn't normally be required of an agent (purchasing seller's personal items in the home), Nicole took on and worked with the other agent to make that process just as smooth. You can tell for Nicole she chose this profession because she loves helping people achieve their dreams and goals, and will do everything she can to make those dreams and goals a reality. Thanks so much Nicole for such a wonderful home buying experience!!

Brenda Bowker 11 months ago
Market ReportEmail
View Scott Matthias' profile
5.0

From 45 reviews overall

Scott Matthias

Scott Matthias

Madison & Company Properties, LLC

Price Expert

Last 12 months in Castle Pines

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Castle Pines

Hands Down the Best Realtor in Colorado

Scott is truly exceptional at what he does. This is our second time working with him, and I couldn’t recommend him more. He’s incredibly detail-oriented, communicative, organized, and deeply knowledgeable about the market and on top of that, just a great guy. We’ve worked with him on both the buying and selling sides and had outstanding experiences each time. He successfully sold our condo despite several challenging factors, and he handled everything flawlessly. Hands down the best realtor in Colorado.

Brooke 3 months ago
Market ReportEmail
View Sandy Schiel's profile
5.0

From 29 reviews overall

Sandy Schiel

Sandy Schiel

Schiel Real Estate Group

Last 12 months in Castle Pines

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Castle Pines

Smooth Process

Sandy walked us through everything and made this a very smooth process for us. Highly recommend!

Jason Brassell about 1 year ago
Email
View Penny Smith's profile
5.0

From 25 reviews overall

Penny Smith

Penny Smith

Last 12 months in Castle Pines

N/A

Avg. sale price

1

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Castle Pines

A Rare Pro

Penny is a professional. In any industry, you find relief as a customer when you know you've found the "right" specialist. She's very friendly and polite, but works to get to the point and execute the transaction on your behalf. Despite our real estate purchase being highly complex, she was able to navigate each hurdle without issue, communicate concerns, and find solutions with impressive efficiency. We were able to buy our dream property at reduced cost thanks to her negotiating skills, and always knew we had a strong realtor to rely on during stressful milestones. Penny is a good person, and high caliber professional. I would recommend her beyond any realtor I've worked with prior, to all family and friends without hesitation.

Ryan & Jamie about 1 year ago
Email
10 - 18 of 140

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent