Back Middletown

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

39 real estate agents in Middletown

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Middletown over the past 12 months.
View Jennifer Wall's profile
5.0

From 64 reviews overall

Jennifer Wall

Jennifer Wall

RE/MAX Gold Lake County

Top 20%
Price Expert

Last 12 months in Middletown

$247k

Avg. sale price

5

Sold (as lead agent)

2

Reviews in Middletown

Market ReportEmail
View Rochelle Costello's profile
5.0

From 11 reviews overall

Rochelle Costello

Rochelle Costello

Navigate Real Estate

Last 12 months in Middletown

$171k

Avg. sale price

4

Sold (as lead agent)

2

Reviews in Middletown

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Rochelle was thorough and knowledgeable and had great communication the entire process. I wouldn’t recommend anyone but her from now on! I’ll definitely use her again if I buy or sell.

4 months ago
Email
View Shannon Williams' profile
5.0

From 33 reviews overall

Shannon Williams

Shannon Williams

The Pinnacle Group

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Middletown

$218k

Avg. sale price

7

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

Quickly sold 4 lots

Last April newly segregated seven acre parcel into 4 lots quickly sold with Shannon Williams Very thorough competent agent, I will work with her again.

Michael Gallanter 12 months ago

Video

Accolades

County Top 5

ratemyagent award

Lake County2026

City Winner

ratemyagent award

Hidden Valley Lake2026
Market ReportEmail
View Kathey Crothers' profile
5.0

From 7 reviews overall

Kathey Crothers

Kathey Crothers

Century 21 Epic

Last 12 months in Middletown

$206k

Avg. sale price

3

Sold (as lead agent)

1

Reviews in Middletown

Kathy is the best ever

This is purchase # 4 I believe working with Kathy as my agent . No issues and all details covered smoothly. Kathy rocks!

about 1 year ago
Email
1 - 9 of 39

Suburbs in Middletown

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent