Tiffany's profile

Tiffany's reviews

  5  
Tiffany has 54 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Tiffany's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, proactive, friendly, well-prepared, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Tiffany is a wonderful full-service realtor!
7 days ago
Tiffany is a wonderful full-service realtor!

Tiffany is NOT a one-and-done realtor! She believes in long-term relationships and providing ongoing assistance to her clients. We worked with her for months - we weren’t sure of the area we wanted or if we even wanted to stay in the state. Tiffany was so patient and understanding throughout our journey. When we finally found “the” house here in Colorado Springs, she was a fierce advocate for us during the negotiation stage all the way through closing. We have many upgrades planned and she has proved to be a TREASURY of knowledge for the local tradesfolk. Being relatively new to CO, her help, but most of all, her friendship is something we will cherish for years to come.

Buyer review
Exceptional, Personable Realtor
15 days ago
Exceptional, Personable Realtor

Tiffany exceptional to work with. She was extremely patient did not pressure us to purchase a house. Tiffany was easy to contact, extremely knowledgable of the area, and fought hard to get us a great deal.

Buyer review
She Saved Our Move!
about 1 month ago
She Saved Our Move!

Tiffany Carroll is a brilliant example of why Realtors exist. When we started our move to Colorado Springs, we'll admit we were nervous — and honestly, at one point we started to wonder if the whole move was a mistake. We struggled for weeks to find a home and nothing was working out. Then we met Tiffany, and everything changed. Her online profile says real estate is her passion and that she strives to go beyond the transaction to build relationships with her clients. This is not marketing fluff. It's the truth! Tiffany is the best of the best. From day one, her attention to detail made the entire process go smoothly and efficiently — nothing fell through the cracks, and we always felt like we were in expert hands. She patiently coached us through every step, helping us understand the market and ultimately find the perfect home for our family. What struck us most was the rare combination Tiffany brings to the table: total professionalism paired with a warmth and approachability that made every interaction easy and enjoyable. With well-deserved rankings and awards as a realtor, she's clearly one of the busiest agents around, but she never once made us feel like we were competing for her time or attention. We always felt like her top priority. Her team at Fletcher is fantastic — her associate Halle was amazing to work with, and the inspector Tiffany recommended was top notch. It's clear she's built relationships with people who share her standards of excellence. We came to Colorado Springs unsure of what to expect, and thanks to Tiffany, we're now excitedly settling into our new home. But beyond the successful transaction, we walked away with something even better: a true, trustworthy friend. If you're looking for a Realtor who will go above and beyond, look no further than Tiffany Carroll. We can't recommend her highly enough.

Buyer review
Amazing all around!!!
about 1 month ago
Amazing all around!!!

We had such a wonderful experience working with Tiffany Carroll and Halle Marsh! They went above and beyond throughout our home-buying journey and made what can be a stressful process feel incredibly manageable. They were attentive, proactive, and always kept us in the loop. We never felt like just another client—they genuinely listened to what we wanted and worked hard to make it happen. Their negotiation skills, attention to detail, and dedication really stood out. We’re so grateful for their guidance and hard work in helping us get into our new home in under 30 days! We would absolutely recommend Tiffany, Halle, and the Fletcher Team to anyone looking for a team that truly cares about their

Seller review
Great realtor!!!
about 2 months ago
Great realtor!!!

Tiffany was one hell of a realtor! She waited patiently until I was ready to put my home on the market and when it was ready, she took over! When she took over, I had just literally moved to my new home (in another state) and she came in with her cleaners and photographer and had my house listed within a few days. She stayed in communication with me during the WHOLE process and had her contractors on the phone very quickly (for a VERY reasonable price) if something needed to be done. She was always very professional and just kind with a heart of gold. I will say that if you read your contracts and have questions or what not on the meanings of certain things she is very patient and will take the time to talk with you about it is you need to understand. I highly recommend Tiffany Carroll as a realtor and very grateful for everything she was able to do to sell my house within a month.

Seller review
Every step of the way, she was there.
about 2 months ago
Every step of the way, she was there.

It was nice to find an agent willing and ready to sell our home, but Tiffany was even more than that. She was there to guide us through the process even when things were not going our way. Her marketing skills were a great asset in selling a home that I thought would be impossible to sell. She made it work with her pricing suggestions, getting repairs made and her being there, right down to the wire. We could not have been happier and highly recommend her. She's professional, friendly and knowledgeable about the market.

Seller review
Cared about getting it done.
2 months ago
Cared about getting it done.

Tiffany was quick to reply when we had questions and was able to articulate exactly what needed to be done to get our house sold at a slow time. Would recommend her for sure.

Seller review
Selling process was full of hurdles but Tiffany and her team got us through it all.
3 months ago
Selling process was full of hurdles but Tiffany and her team got us through it all.

I highly recommend Tiffany! She took amazing care of me through the entire process of selling my home. No matter what was going on in either of our personal lives, she made communicating any and all updates to me a priority. Even through an extremely tedious battle with my HOA, she kept my wife and I in the loop on every step and never lost momentum. There was always a plan and a backup plan, and a backup to the backup plan! I cannot recommend Tiffany and her team enough to anyone looking for someone to trust with either buying or selling a home. Rest assured if you work with her, you will be well taken care of.

Seller review
Tiffany is wonderful!!
3 months ago
Tiffany is wonderful!!

Tiffany was so easy to work with, extremely communicative. She would always respond to our messages quickly. She definitely made the process of selling our house so easy. I would definitely recommend her to anyone

Seller review
Excellent communicator, very hard worker!
3 months ago
Excellent communicator, very hard worker!

Always reached back day or night with any questions we had when buying and selling, really helped us out on selling before I did my PCS! 10/10 recommend, don’t go to anyone else.

Seller review
A Highly Skilled and Caring Realtor
3 months ago
A Highly Skilled and Caring Realtor

Tiffany has been a great pleasure to work with. We are thankful for her experience and having the knowledge to negotiate difficult matters with the home selling process in a difficult market. Tiffany was effective in keeping us calm through our lengthy 9 month listing period. Her advice on price adjustments in this difficult market kept us in the game culminating with a successful sale. As an example we had rejected an offer we felt was too low. However, as the market continued to worsen she advised us to reach back out to that buyer to see if their interest in our home and the offer was still good. The buyer was still willing to make the offer and about a month later the sale was final. There were many other complexities as the closing was approaching and she handled those with great skill as well. We really did select the best realtor for our selling our home!

1 - 12 of 54
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent