Tibitha's profile

Tibitha's reviews

  5  
Tibitha has 54 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
6 days ago
Very dedicated to getting the job done

Tibitha was very kind and thoughtful all throughout the whole process. 10/10 would recommend for anybody who’s trying to purchase their first home!

18 days ago
Tibi Made Our First-Time Homebuying Journey Feel Like We Had Family in Our Corner.”

As first-time homebuyers, we had absolutely no clue what we were doing, but Tibi made the entire process feel so much less overwhelming. From the beginning, she was patient, kind, knowledgeable, and always took the time to explain things and guide us every step of the way. When we finally found the house we loved, Tibi was just as excited as we were and wrapped me in the biggest, most heartfelt mom hug. Then she moved mountains to help make sure we got our home! That moment meant so much to us and truly showed how personally invested she was in helping make our dream of becoming homeowners a reality. We are beyond grateful for everything Tibi did for us and could not have asked for a better realtor to guide us through our first home-buying experience. We would recommend her to anyone, especially first-time homebuyers!

3 months ago
Beyond helpful and easy

We used Tibitha’s help when purchasing our first home so it was a no brainer to use her again. She made it so easy by having what seemed to be all the answers. Very fast to respond if we had a question and when finding our new home had us a viewing instantly. Selling our home was a breeze and do to following her guidance we had our home sold in 48 hours with papers signed

3 months ago
The experience overall was phenomenal. Tibby was amazing to work with!

Working with Tibitha was a breath of fresh air. I was a nervous first-time homebuyer and she walked me through every step with patience and care. She never rushed me, explained all our options in plain English, was always super attentive and supportive, and even pointed out things in houses i wouldn't have noticed. She didn't just help me find a house, she helped my family find a home. We couldn't recommend her more!

3 months ago
Perfectly matched my needs to the perfect house

Tibitha uses her extensive real estate knowledge and experience to help her clients find their best house. She provided honest insights on viewed properties to minimize the possibility of unforseen surprises after purchase. 10 out of 10 - would definitely recommend.

5 months ago
She was on our team for every step of the process

Tibitha was an excellent realtor who we were able to trust and was by our side for every question and decision. We had no idea what the process of selling a house was, how to prepare, or how to start. She was with us every step of the way and always got back to us right away. She is personable but still knows how to put the job at hand first. We were fully confident in all our decisions with her by our side and I would recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell.

6 months ago
Our Second time working with Tibitha

Tibitha and her assistant did an outstanding job helping us sell our house. We purchased the house through Tibitha back in 2012 and knew it was in our best interest to stay with her due to her many years of experience in real estate in our area.

6 months ago
Excellent, Knowledgeable realtor that is so easy to work with!!

Tibitha is an Excellent realtor! We have used her in the past and she puts everything she has into helping her clients!! She is so knowledgeable and helpful with everything she does!! We highly recommend having her as a realtor!!

7 months ago
Excellent Realtor!

Tibitha Matheney guided us through the sale of our home and the purchase of our new home. She showed us many homes until she found the perfect home for us. Tibitha is professional, knowledgeable, and listens to her clients. My husband and I are so pleased with her as our realtor and will definitely recommend her!

8 months ago
Great experience!

It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of your house and tells you what to expect. She did a detailed market analysis of other properties around mine and gave me an honest opinion on the value of my house. She was very responsive to any inquiries and alway kept me up to date on anything that was happening with the property. I highly recommend her.

8 months ago
Exceptional Agent

Tibitha has been an exceptional realtor to work with. Their communication is always clear, timely, and professional, making every step of the process feel smooth and manageable. They are consistently friendly, approachable, and genuinely invested in helping clients succeed. Their dedication and hard-working attitude truly set them apart. I highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive real estate professional.

1 - 12 of 54
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent