Tara's profile

Tara's reviews

  5  
Tara has 186 reviewsacross 33 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Tara's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, friendly, reliable, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The best agent ever
over 1 year ago
The best agent ever

Tara communicated with me frequently on what was happening and gave suggestions on what buyers were looking for. She was the best agent to have in a down market. I’ve told friends in the Canta Mia sub division to pick Tara if you want to get your house sold.

Seller review
Tara was the perfect agent at the perfect time to sell my home!
over 1 year ago
Tara was the perfect agent at the perfect time to sell my home!

I reached out to Tara in August of 2024 for a market analysis of my home and she was right in the ballpark of what I wanted to get for my home. I just didn't think the market was right for how much i wanted and I didn't want it to sit on the market for months on end. She advised me of a few items that I could do in the meantime to make it more appealing for when I thought the time was right to sell. Fast forward to August of 2025 when I called Tara and told her I was ready. Everything from there on out was easy and seamless. There were a few other houses in my neighborhood that had been on the market, 1 for several months and another for over 1 year and they kept having to lower the asking price. This made me very nervous, but I knew that Tara was the perfect agent to sell my home. The listing went live and all it took was less than 24 hours and 1 showing to get full asking price! Tara knows the West Valley very well and was such a pleasure to work with.

Seller review
Couldn't have done it without Tara and her team!
over 1 year ago
Couldn't have done it without Tara and her team!

This was my second time utilizing Tara for this home. She was my agent when I bought it as well. The purchase went incredibly smooth. I had some difficulties with the sale, but Tara already had the answers when I asked. 10/10 would recommend.

Seller review
Hire only the best.
over 1 year ago
Hire only the best.

Tara Rutkowski is honestly the best realtor we have ever worked with. We have had 2 transactions with Tara, one purchasing and one selling, she has been consistent with both. Tara is very knowledgeable and professional and knows the real estate market very well. She is a wonderful agent and I would recommend her to anyone.

Seller review
Top notch real state agent!
over 1 year ago
Top notch real state agent!

Well I've known Tara since 2006 and seen how she has transformed into a absolute fantastic real state agent. She has help us and my in-laws buying and selling our homes. She goes above and beyond, her excellence as an agent, very knowlegeable on homes and sales on her area. I'm so happy to know someone that I can trust handling sales of my home or buying a new home. I highly recommended Tara for buying or selling your home. Thank you so much and we will be talking again when we are ready to buy again. Once again a fantastic Real state agent.

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
over 1 year ago
Excellent Realtor

Tara was excellent. She responded to our request to meet her quickly. She presented herself professionally. She demonstrated extensive knowledge of our area. She priced our home appropriately and thus we had a buyer during the slowest months of the Goodyear market.

Seller review
Kind, caring & knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Kind, caring & knowledgeable

Tara is very professional & honest . She was knowledgeable about the market in my neighborhood. I appreciated her compassion concerning the unique situation we were facing. She was always flexible in facilitating temporary time off market. She did a great job negotiating the sale price of our home & walking with us through closing. I will definitely recommend her as an agent to sell your home.

Seller review
Simply The Best
over 1 year ago
Simply The Best

Tara is the best because: 1. She shares her in-depth market knowledge clearly & objectively 2. She has a network of contacts for everything - title co, repair people, movers, etc. 3. She is on top of the process at every step - no dropped balls. All of the above make what can be an extremely stressful process into much smoother sailing.

Buyer review
Absolutely phenomenal!
over 1 year ago
Absolutely phenomenal!

Tara is an absolutely phenomenal real estate agent! Without having her spearhead the home buying experience it would’ve probably never happened. I used her because she was the listing agent and negotiations went a lot faster and smoother. There were several speed bumps that she was able to maneuver around and still solidify the deal. There is no question whatsoever that I highly recommend her and her team. Excellent communication, goes the extra mile and then some, makes you feel that you are important, and is available at any given moment. If you plan on buying a house, make sure you strongly consider using Tara and her team. Some Agents are just in it for the commission, and I can certainly assure you this is not the case. She works extremely hard and is super intelligent, and very trustworthy ,does her job excellent. She has a happy demeanor and business mindset. She is super thorough, to detail mindset, and a true superstar!

Buyer review
Wonderful and Knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Wonderful and Knowledgeable

Tara was so great throughout our whole experience of looking for a new home, selling our home, and purchasing a new home/build. Tara knew so much about the market, solar, different areas around the valley, what to look for and take into consideration-- we felt so comfortable and lucky to get to work with her. We found her through an informational online presentation she hosted on buying/selling homes with solar. The home we sold had a nice solar system set up, and we wanted to be sure we were approaching the market in the best way we could. We're so grateful to Tara for sharing all of her knowledge with us and guiding us through everything. Tara was amazing at navigating the offers on our home, and getting all of the information to us. When we were looking for a new home, it was great to have Tara there with us- giving us things to consider and how to navigate the purchase of a new build. We couldn't recommend her more!

Buyer review
Very Personable
almost 2 years ago
Very Personable

Tara, Abby and her team are great to work with. She had our best interest at the forefront of the transaction. Her knowledge was much appreciated and she was in constant communication with us which gave us peach of mind with our first home purchase.

Buyer review
The absolute best!
almost 2 years ago
The absolute best!

Tara helped coordinate the sale of our previous home, contingent on buying a new build in Phoenix. We had to move quickly, and although there were a ton of moving pieces, Tara was well-organized and helped guide us through every step of the process. She was in constant communication with us and we were never surprised by anything. Moving is a stressful time and a lot has to happen in order for things to complete. Tara made the process as easy as possible and we couldn't be happier. Her advice, partnership, professionalism, and friendship are so valued, and we will always be forever grateful.

61 - 72 of 186
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent