Susan Kelley

Susan Kelley

Associate Broker / Licensed Real Estate Agent at Neuhaus Real Estate, Inc. member of The Kelley Team
Colorado: FA100097470
  •   5   (14 reviews)

Susan's sales performance at a glance

See how Susan has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

5
Reviews
1
Properties for sale
3
Sold properties
$575k
Average sale price
$973k
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Susan

Real estate is about more than just transactions - it's about creating connections and guiding people toward new chapters in life. I strive to make every client feel valued and cared for, not just as a business deal but as a meaningful partnership. My approach blends curiosity, enthusiasm, and loyalty to ensure each client feels empowered and supported throughout the process. Colorado's stunning landscape fuels my passion, whether I'm hiking or skiing with my family and friends or enjoying community life. I bring that same adventurous spirit to my work, treating each opportunity with optimism and persistence. I see challenges as moments for growth, finding creative solutions to help clients achieve their dreams. With a focus on honesty and respect, I aim to leave every client feeling confident, safe, and excited about their next step. Let's discover your new home and turn your dreams into reality!

Susan's reviews

  5  
Susan has 14 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 6.
Review Susan
Susan's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
I hired an excellent realtor and made my first friends in Ft. Collins.  Couldn't have better!
about 1 month ago
I hired an excellent realtor and made my first friends in Ft. Collins. Couldn't have better!

Susan and Roger demonstrated comprehensive market knowledge answering questions about the area, home details, utilities, area services like health care, and questions I didn't even think of. Communication was always timely but unobtrusive using text, email, phone even video touring properties for my elderly parents. They quickly adapted to our special need for two walkers, wide doorways, no stairs... Negotiation was an impressive display of insight, recognizing an opportunity for bidding the right price at the right time. They worked tirelessly through the inspection/objection process offering solutions, options for technical service, and negotiating to reach a timely closing. Susan and Roger are the definition of professionalism. I felt like we were in good hands all the way through. They quickly earned my trust and delivered on every level, I could not have asked for a better experience.

Buyer review
Roger and Susan were outstanding - We couldn't have asked for better agents to work with!!
5 months ago
Roger and Susan were outstanding - We couldn't have asked for better agents to work with!!

We were out of town buyers who contacted Roger and Susan after reading on-line recommendations like this one. We felt very fortunate to have ended up with them and hope that this helps others in their decision. They were just what we were looking for.... great market knowledge, professional, informative, patient, and not at all pushy. Their communication, follow-up, and attention to detail were simply outstanding. We were relocating from Florida so, other than coming out for a house hunting trip, everything was done remotely. From negotiating the contract, getting through the inspection process, obtaining repair estimates, and finally closing on the property, Roger and Susan were always there to help. In addition to coaching us through the process, providing valuable insight along the way, and keeping everything on track, they made frequent trips out to the property to meet with vendors and inspectors on our behalf. When we had questions or concerns, they got answers, contacting qualified professionals as needed and always making sure that we had solid information on which to base our decisions. Going through the home buying process can be scary, especially when doing so remotely, but Roger and Susan made it as stress-free as possible. They are a great team and we couldn't have had a better experience. They have our highest recommendation.

Buyer review
Extensive market knowledge, excellent communication, impeccable professionalism
7 months ago
Extensive market knowledge, excellent communication, impeccable professionalism

This was not our first home purchase, but it was surely the easiest and the most enjoyable. Roger and Susan were warm and friendly, always helpful, and always available to answer questions via phone, email or text. Their market knowledge and experience are extensive, their communication skills are outstanding, and their professionalism is impeccable.Roger was very helpful with providing reliable contacts and information for any repairs necessary for our home. Communication regarding our purchase was always prompt and thorough. I highly recommend Roger and Susan.

Seller review
Susan is a rockstar realtor and a genuine person.
10 months ago
Susan is a rockstar realtor and a genuine person.

Susan is an absolute rockstar realtor! Her thoughtfulness shone through in every step of selling our home—she listened to our needs, offered brilliant insights, and made the process seamless. She was incredibly generous with her time, always available to answer questions or provide updates, no matter how small. Her professionalism was unmatched, handling every detail with expertise and confidence, from helping staging to closing. Susan’s passion for her work and genuine care for her clients made all the difference. We couldn’t have asked for a better partner—she’s simply the best!

Seller review
She will work hard for you!
11 months ago
She will work hard for you!

Susan is extremely organized, responsive, and will bend over backwards to help you sell your house. She and her entire team are amazing!

Seller review
The Best Real Estate Agents
about 1 year ago
The Best Real Estate Agents

Roger and Susan were both professional, knowledgeable, and personable from the very start. They have a wealth of market understanding and offer great recommendations for lenders. We flew to Colorado from Texas for a showing. The Kelley Team was so kind in offering a ride to us so we didn't have to rent a car for a few hours. This is the difference in Roger and Susan. Roger is highly educated and made negotiating with the seller's agent seamless. I would highly recommend the Kelley Team to anyone in the market to buy or sell real estate!

Show all 14 reviews
map

Susan's properties

Susan has 1 property for sale and sold 3 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

Under Contract
$434,900
717 10th St
Windsor CO 80550
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate - Neuhaus
SoldMay 26, 2026
$199,200
4464 Espirit Drive
Fort Collins CO 80524
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC (W - TR04 - Colorado) and Neuhaus Real Estate, Inc.
SoldMay 26, 2026
$199,200
4464 Espirit Drive
Fort Collins CO 80524
2
2
2
Single-Family
SoldAug 8, 2025
$575,000
5008 5th Avenue
Timnath CO 80547
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Neuhaus Real Estate, Inc. and REMAX Alliance | Windsor
Show all 4 properties

Susan's sold properties

Susan has sold 3 properties in the past 12 months, showing 3.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
4464 Espirit Drive, Fort Collins, CO, 80524
4464 Espirit Drive
Fort Collins CO 80524
2
2
2
Single-Family$199,200May 26, 2026
4464 Espirit Drive, Fort Collins, CO, 80524
4464 Espirit Drive
Fort Collins CO 80524
2
2
2
Single-Family$199,200May 26, 2026
5008 5th Avenue, Timnath, CO, 80547
5008 5th Avenue
Timnath CO 80547
2
3
Single-Family$575,000Aug 8, 2025

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent