Shelly's profile

Shelly's reviews

  4.9  
Shelly has 107 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, patient, detail-oriented, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Our whole experience with Shelly was by far the best experience we’ve ever had! ABOVE and BEYOND
over 5 years ago
Our whole experience with Shelly was by far the best experience we’ve ever had! ABOVE and BEYOND

Our whole experience with Shelly was by far the best experience we’ve ever had! ABOVE and BEYOND. Being a military family this was my first BIG move(NJ to Savannah) and my fiancé’s fourth. Shelly was very candid, knowledgeable and honest throughout the whole process. She had recommendations on all areas around Savannah to which homes were in good locations, to which got bogged down with traffic. We found a house that we loved and because it was in such a great neighborhood based on Shelly’s recommendation we didn’t want to wait until we got down there. Everything was done over email and through video conferencing. While it was a little scary for me not being able to physically see the house in person, Shelly was so thorough in showing us the house to even driving around the neighborhood for us to see where we would be located. When we finally got down to see the house in person, there were no surprises. Everything was exactly as she said. Easily the best experience with Shelly and would recommend her to anyone searching for a home around this area!

Buyer review
Shelly knows the Savannah market very well - very important in a sellers market
over 5 years ago
Shelly knows the Savannah market very well - very important in a sellers market

Shelly knows the Savannah market very well - very important in a sellers market. She is very responsive and will do whatever is required to assist her clients in finding the perfect home. We had a very unique deal and she guided the contract process very well. Highly recommend Shelly.

Buyer review
Shelly was an excellent guide to the Savannah area for me
over 5 years ago
Shelly was an excellent guide to the Savannah area for me

Shelly was an excellent guide to the Savannah area for me. I came here needing to find a home immediately and Shelly was on it right away. She knows the area as a lifelong resident, so there’s probably no question that she can’t answer. She’s responsive, engaging and hard working. My daughter actually recommended her after buying a house with her so I figured she would be good. She’s really GREAT and I would say if you need a realtor here, look no further than Shelly LaMonica.

Buyer review
Having not been able to meet Shelly until well into the buying process, she was great at getting me
almost 6 years ago
Having not been able to meet Shelly until well into the buying process, she was great at getting me

Having not been able to meet Shelly until well into the buying process, she was great at getting me information, knowing what I wanted, but also letting me know what else might be out there that was different from my initial criteria. Overall I enjoyed working with Shelly and she got me into my new home very quickly and with little fuss. The only reason I did not give 5 stars on negotiation is because there wasn't much price movement at all from asking to closing. It is entirely possible that is more a result of market forces than anything else, but it's hard to know for sure.

Buyer review
Shelly is the best! She really cares about her clients and you can tell
almost 6 years ago
Shelly is the best! She really cares about her clients and you can tell

Shelly is the best! She really cares about her clients and you can tell. She always answers emails and texts promptly, makes you aware of both the good and bad in the houses she shows, and is very knowledgeable about the area. She will go to bat for you and try her best to get you the best deal on your dream home! She went above and beyond to make sure we were happy with our purchase even once we'd signed on the house. I highly recommend her!

Buyer review
Shelly is a delight to work with! The home buying process was totally new to us, and she made it a b
almost 6 years ago
Shelly is a delight to work with! The home buying process was totally new to us, and she made it a b

Shelly is a delight to work with! The home buying process was totally new to us, and she made it a breeze. She truly takes time to understand her clients and is incredibly knowledgeable about the area. Shelly went above and beyond to make sure we were happy with our new home and that everything’s went smoothly, she truly is passionate about helping people find the right place and would often point out things we hadn’t considered! I trust her completely and certainly recommend her to anyone looking for a home.

Buyer review
My husband and I live on the West Coast but have been visiting Savannah for more than 15 years toget
about 6 years ago
My husband and I live on the West Coast but have been visiting Savannah for more than 15 years toget

My husband and I live on the West Coast but have been visiting Savannah for more than 15 years together to visit family. We had been dreaming of a second home in downtown Savannah for a few years and finally decided to make the jump in late February 2020 right before the COVID wave hit the market. We arranged a quick trip to Savannah and connected with Shelly. She was efficient with understanding what we were looking for and we decided quickly what properties we would tour over two days in Savannah. Within six weeks we closed on a 2 BR/ 2 BA condo. We couldn’t be happier! What we liked about working with Shelly: Being out-of-towners she helped us get up to speed on the downtown Savannah market quickly She didn’t waste our time and understood what properties to show us and arranged the tour efficiently Once we decided on a condo to bid on she helped us strategize on the right offer that fit our budget and helped us with negotiations when it came to a sticky counter situation She connected us with all the vendors we needed to complete the closing transaction (Closing attorney, local mortgage co, property managers, inspection company) Even after we were owners she continued to work on our behalf to get our keys to our property managers who she helped us find. Overall, we had a great experience with Shelly who made the whole process for us out-of-towners as smooth as it could be even when we couldn’t be around for the close (thanks to COVID) In closing, if you don’t live in Savannah and need a local guide to the market who can help you get smart and find a place efficiently, call Shelly!

Buyer review
What a great realtor Shelly is
about 6 years ago
What a great realtor Shelly is

What a great realtor Shelly is. We worked with her purchasing a property in the Historic District. We live in Winter Park, Florida and were interested in a Pied-a-Terre in Savannah. We found the one we wanted, but it was during the Covid Pandemic. That posed a special challenge since all had to be done remotely. Shelly assisted us each step of the way, making us feel like we were in Savannah during the process. I highly recommend Shelly to both local and distant clients.

Buyer review
Shelly was great to say the least!!! This was not my first home purchase but proved to be a trying p
about 6 years ago
Shelly was great to say the least!!! This was not my first home purchase but proved to be a trying p

Shelly was great to say the least!!! This was not my first home purchase but proved to be a trying process in a busy market and Shelly was with me every step along the way. Every time we needed to "start over" we did and she was always on top of things. She is incredibly knowledgeable about the area which was helpful because I have not lived here long. She quickly got to know me as a buyer and was more like a friend than a agent. If I had to do this again, it would be with Shelly :)

Buyer review
We were first time home buyers and we are so incredibly grateful that we found Shelly! She was amazi
about 6 years ago
We were first time home buyers and we are so incredibly grateful that we found Shelly! She was amazi

We were first time home buyers and we are so incredibly grateful that we found Shelly! She was amazing and went above and beyond to explain the complex and lengthy process of purchasing a home to us. She was always honest and patient with us throughout the entire process, plus was wonderful at communicating and keeping us in the loop, which can be hard to come by nowadays! We are so, so happy in our new place and we will definitely be recommending her to our friends when they get started looking for houses.

85 - 96 of 107
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent